Beware of Mining Hype
Despite PR blitz, First Nations have little to celebrate.
Ceremony to protect Amazay/Duncan Lake.
The Tse Keh Nay leadership is compelled to add its voice to the recent hoopla surrounding the B.C. mining sector's claims of glory, such as those made by Michael McPhie in his recent editorial in the Vancouver Sun and those recently made in this publication.
From our perspective, far too many First Nations in this province have very little to celebrate when it comes to mining.
The irony is not lost on us that in mid-May, while Mr. McPhie and Minister of State for Mining Kevin Krueger were falling all over themselves to sing the praises of the industry during Mining Week in B.C., we were in public hearings in Smithers dealing with the proposed Kemess North mine.
We are here to protect our sacred and pristine Amazay Lake from Northgate Minerals Corporation, which plans to turn it into a massive contaminated dump. Our message to the panel and the public is simple: Amazay Lake will not be sacrificed for the benefit of the mining industry.
Industrial development has not been good to the Tse Keh Nay. In 1824, the fur trader and explorer Samuel Black came into our territory looking to establish a trading post. Our people guided him to Thutade Lake, near the site of the now proposed Kemess North mine. Here they fed him and took care of him. In turn, he carelessly set several fires, destroying large parts of our forests. We have been fighting to protect our land ever since 1824.
The flooding of our homelands to create the Williston Reservoir in the 1960s further harmed our people. We can no longer eat the mercury-contaminated fish from the lower half of our watershed. Now the upper half of the watershed is threatened from the Kemess North proposal.
Steamrolled
Because of the mineral wealth in the Kemess region, the entire upper Finlay watershed has been tenured out to mining and exploration companies with no consultation with us. Not one square inch of our land is free from the threat of exploration and mining. Moreover, the government confesses it neither tracks nor coordinates any cumulative impact risk management in relation to mining, or any other developments.
Recent impacts on us include the Kemess South mine, which was steamrolled into our territory in the 1990s as part of a "compensation" package by the provincial government to Royal Oak Mines for the creation of Tatshenshini-Alsek Park. In this instance, while the company received an additional $160 million in tax breaks and subsidies, we received nothing much more than a contaminated mine site located on top of our sacred sites and in the middle of important caribou routes.
To us, today's mining boom looks a lot like the old fur trade and gold rush. Strangers come into our territory without permission, take our resources, spoil our land, and then walk away with the profits, leaving us with the mess. For example, we are confronted with one of B.C.'s top 10 Crown contaminated sites -- the former Bralorne mine with its toxic levels of mercury and other heavy metals.
And so it goes. Much glowing talk is made of paying workers $94,500 per year and of the $7 billion in investments provincially, yet far too little of that is realized in our communities. Instead, our communities remain in abject poverty, living in over-crowded, mould-ridden homes on tiny reserves. All the while, government and industry continue to suck our lands and resources out from under us.
It must be made clear that we are not against mining. We are however not going to stand by and allow government and industry to conduct business in our territory as they did in the past.
New Relationship?
Our position is that mining companies cannot march into our territory, stake out and explore sacred areas without permission, impose one-sided unsustainable plans to contaminate our waters, poison our fish, scare away our wildlife, and trample our medicinal plants. If that is what they have in mind, we will put all of our energy into stopping them any way we can.
The First Nations Leadership Council has made important statements about mining in the context of the New Relationship, on the need for them and government to recognize and respect our aboriginal rights and title. That is all we are seeking. But if the mining industry and government try to force themselves upon us, as in the past, then we will join forces with our allies to prevent this.
Instead, our message is this: We are more than willing to work with government and mining. We invite them to come to us in a respectful way, recognize our rights and title, our spiritual laws, engage in mutual land-use planning and cumulative impact management regime, then we will talk about meaningful revenue-sharing, jobs, contracting and reclamation opportunities as part of any reasonable mine proposal.
The mining industry cannot remain stuck in the old way of doing business, where its wealthy executives and its self-serving flatterers and its highly-paid labour force celebrate Mining Week in B.C. while we fight for our survival.
Related Tyee stories:
- Inside BC's Mining Boom
Why billions are pouring in for copper, coal, uranium. - Tahltan Resistance to Mining, Drilling Grows
Iskut band joins Telegraph Creek protest and rebuffs Shell execs. - At the Table
A 'new relationship' perhaps, but Stó:lō frustrations are mounting. Last in a series.



15
Login or register to post comments
doggone
4 years ago
Well spoken
I worked for Mining exploration outfits in the late '60s and early '70s. We may or may not have explored land claimed by First Nations.
There was an understanding back then that we could only (at best) explore.
No developement could proceed without consent of the "Land Holder" who ever that might be.
What has changed?
Now we can build roads and bring in the drills and blow the place to smithereens and haul the rocks away no matter who lives there?
For the "Greater Good"?
That was not why I took an interest in Geology
Martin
4 years ago
Abject poverty
The reason for the sad, abject poverty on reserves is that many are not viable without meaningful economic development. Because of their remoteness, resource development is the only realistic model.
Unfortunately, Canada's first nations cling to failed, communal economic systems. In modern times, communal economic systems consistently fail throughout the world. Canada's first nations are no exception.
Frank
4 years ago
Damn stubborn data
Actually the data shows laissez-faire to be probably the worst system on earth. The loose bonds of government regulation and control of many parts of Africa or the communists of Scandinavia and the Canadian Prairies. I know where I'd rather live.
RickW
4 years ago
Check out the Tar Sands, People!
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/edmonton/story/2006/03/10/ed-fortchip20060310.html
And isn't it "strange" that Dr. O'Connor has been told to "zip it" by the medical association......
Fiat lux
4 years ago
The sale of resources is the
The sale of resources is the sale of real capital. It is no benefit but daylight robbery that leads to bankrupcy.
Carpetbaggers come into the country, invited and praised by our sleazy politicians, and strip it bare with the damage they cause, canceling out any benefits to the people of Canada.
Foreign investment is a fraud that brings nothing to the country, but steals everything with the perceived power of imaginary money.
As I wrote it several times before, we have the overloaded ore trucks tearing up our roads, taking our wealth abroad, leaving huge, uncontrolled pollution behind.
And this is what the "fully owned" governments and braindead politicians are celebrating.
There's another project planned for the Chilcotin, to fill up Fish Lake with the rubble from a gold mine. Who the hell needs more gold?
What the world needs is food, not gold and more pollution.
Ed Deak, Big Lake.
BC Dude
4 years ago
Bottom line is not Beautiful
Bottom line is not Beautiful BC but Greedy money mongers who only see gold as their "god" they are the bottom feeders and creators of the world’s poverty and mass misery!
They are the warmongers mining uranium in Canada for weapons of mass destruction or "D"epleated "U"ranium used in all munitions where every bullet, mortar shell, land mines, cluster bombs wherever they land the immediate area will be contaminated for food and all life for many 100rds of years.
Right to Bear
4 years ago
Greedheads All...
Fish Lake is on the Xeni Gwetin' land located in the Nemiaha Valley B.C. The Xeni people have used this lake as their traditional fishing "hole" for centuries. History shows they have defended this land as though it was their Mother. Taseko Mines plan to use Fish Lake as a Talis pond, or essentially, a toxic waste dumping ground. The Xeni people do not support this Gold\Copper mine initiative whatsoever and will indeed once again, stand up for their Mother if push comes to shove...
Taesko is planning on moving 85,000 rare trout from Fish Lake to another location as though that is all that lives there. If this happens, some fish might live, but little interconnected fragile biosphere that live in this lake will all die. Even the 200 wild horses that live on this land drink from this lake, what will become of them without this traditional place of watering??
Once again, Industry brings death to the Earth. Once again Industry\Gov demonstrates no respect of consultation, in a search for an agreement, with people who have cherished this land for generations.
History shows, these are a tough people. My thoughts are if Industry Greedheads do not start listening to these FN people, their selective listening skills will ultimately betray them….
Peace,
Bear
Fiat lux
4 years ago
Thanks Bear ! Here's a
Thanks Bear ! Here's a prayer by Chief Manitonquat, I've been saving for many years and read often:
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
"Hear O Humankind,the prayer of my heart.
Are we not one? Have we not one desire-
to heal our Mother Earth, to bind her wounds?
Are we not all sisters and brothers?
Are we not all grandchildren of the same Mistery?
Do we not all want to love and be loved?
Do we not all want to work and play and sing and dance together?
Hear my heart's prayer, O Humankind!
Life is the only treasure.
Weare the custodians of it.
It is our sacred trust.
Life is woundrous, awesome and holy.
Life is burning glory.
And its price is simply this:Courage.
We must be brave enough to love."
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Now try to explain these words to economists, politicians and "wealth creators" that wealth can not be created, only taken.
Ed Deak, Big Lake.
freebear
4 years ago
Cumulative Impact and the New Relationship
ew Relationship or just talk and same old same old?
Mostly it seems like talk!
Industry also needs to strike up a new relationship with First Nations.
Right now too few respect First Nations.
A 'New Relationship" means recognizing First Nations rights and title and minmizing infringement from development, contributing to First Nations community wellbeing (economic opportunities and so on)and recognizing that there are limits.
You can not pave, mine, log, farm, drill, strip mine an entire First Nations territory, let alone an entire province!
As to the provincial approach to cumulative impacts, my experience has been the position is as follows:
What is wrong with only one well in a pristine area - minimal impact
or
What is one more well in an already intensely developed area.
Ever notice how most development review mechanisms are called "Approval Processes" rather than "Review" or "Assessment" processes?
The BC Oil & Gas commission is one example and they still avoid addressing cumulative impacts!
Keep up the fight for your territories!
BC Dude
4 years ago
COME ON PEOPLE! JULY 01 IS
COME ON PEOPLE!
JULY 01 IS CANADA DAY, A DAY WE AS CANADIANS CAN COME TOGETHER MAKE A DIFFERANCE, PEACEFULLY! Just maybe, We can hold OUR heads up high again with Pride for OUR Country?
I used to be a proud Canadian but knowing that I am being an accomplice (by not speaking up) to these Horrors of Afghans being tortured in my nane, on our FN 3rd world conditions on the Federal reserves, the growing poverty in our very rich Province of BC, and in my country, Canada! A sad and shameful Canuck who is willing to get out and demand OUR elected polititions start Working for US the taxpayers and do the “Right Thing” for All Canadians!
BC Dude
4 years ago
Lets start with these
Lets start with these http://www.ndp.ca/page/5332 crooked, uppity corporporations, crooked polititions Federally, Provincially, Reginally, Our scandal ridden RCMP, OUR sslow moving justice system?
Satan is reaping many souls from all over the world including Canada!
Rick Hiller's
Quote:
"Peacekeeping is for wimps"
BC Dude
4 years ago
I'm very sure that if we get
I'm very sure that if we get our justice system back to For the People etc, these brazen Corporations including mining will be opened to the public for indepth scrutiny and how they got that way?
CPAC Shaw Cable ch104 The RCMP scandal, the latest news, there are approx. 12 retired or exRCMP officers who are going to "Blow the Whistle" on the whole upper echelon, including the politicians!
But S Harper is saying "No" I wonder why?
This is even more reason why this investigation should go ahead with no political interference!
If there is a whiff of interference then there should be dire consequences for those involved!
Just look at Our BCRail now cheap rail service for the mining industry!
Right to Bear
4 years ago
...day to day decisions...
Thank you Ed Deak! I will save this wonderful prayer and share with you in reading it often.
The beauty of these people grounds me; the simplicity of their understandings astounds me.
FN people have taught me to believe that in our day to day decisions, we need to reflect what we will so hold in importance and reverence at our life’s end...
Peace Ed,
Bear
hova87
4 years ago
New Relationship
to me is nothing but more fancy words and less action behind them. yes, they look great on paper but thats all it is, and everyone knows FN people were and still somewhat today not a "Document" kind of people, teachings and lessons taught through stories and speaking, not reading it from a book or writing it down. Im only 20 and Im like that as well, and putting "New Relationship" on a piece of paper has no meaning to me whatsoever.
i fully support anyway that your first nation sees fit to protects your rights and land titles. the governments and most of the non-native society continues to ignore the "Real Truth" Hey, theres some fancy words for you, but those words actually have meaning. and as sad as it is true, we as FN people have a long road a head of us before the governments finally admit what they did, and still do today.
canada continues to import and export all the resources our people survived off since the beginning of time. we took what we needed to survive, being respectful to mother earth and all that she provides. and seeing those resources and sacred sites being raped for money, and not being atleast shared with the FN people, but bringing in more immigrants to the country as the First Nations of this country more and more become the Last Nations of this country.
the government is walking into this "new relationship" situation unprepared. todays youth, much like myself, ive grown to hate the non-native world and everything to do with it. we're angry at the past and hungry for justice for the future. there are youth out there who have been sitting and waiting for the day that gives them the chance to fight back and make their mark. there is absolutely NO room for error this time around. Canada needs to stop being the hooker of North America, pull up its panties and fix what they have done do us. yeah, it sucks there are people in other countries who have to suffer from poverty and war, but we as FN people have been suffering the same way, in some regions even worse then 3rd world societies, and still get brushed to the side as more and more boats come in with people who dont belong to country.
As i recall the anthem goes, "Our home and NATIVE land" Does it not?
BC Dude
4 years ago
hova87 I agree with you 99%
hova87 I agree with you 99% as you said G Campbell's DeGreening of BC the Old Growth Forests on VI and all over BC along with mining with no restrictions?
What a disgusting little corporate lapdog Gordo is as the opposition has him and his band of my-way-only-and-don't-question-me =god, cowardly MLA's up against the proverbial wall!
http://www.en-camino.org/node/64
http://thetyee.ca/News/2007/02/22/Investments/
http://ithinkmining.blog.infomine.com/category/region/
http://www.marxist.ca/Documents/04mar_corruption.htm