'Far, Far Away'
In Kenya, I walk the line between hope and hopelessness.
The first postcard arrived when I was seven. The picture on the front was a woolly alpaca and the message on the back came from my aunt. Growing up, I monitored our mailbox for these dispatches from 'Far Far Away' -- from Bolivia, Nigeria and Pakistan. As a child, these magic glimpses into foreign lands were terribly romantic. I dreamt of towering blue mosques that sparkled under the hot sun and elephants that lumbered though traffic-filled streets.
For me, this fascination with people in every nook and cranny of the planet translated into a bachelor's degree in cultural anthropology. I sorted through ideologies and case studies, tucked everything into tidy file folders and labelled them with academic jargon. I learned the sinister history of development projects and I read about well-intentioned initiatives that crippled their supposed "beneficiaries". Despite these complications, I would still come home for Thanksgiving and lecture my parents about how easy it would be to fix the world.
Then things got more complicated.
Presidential mansions and student headaches
Finally, I am living the opportunity I have always sought -- working for a nongovernmental organization (NGO) in a developing country. I am a Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) intern, living in the western province of Kenya. As a registered nurse, I am helping to improve the health of over a thousand students who attend a network of nine "non-formal education centres." At the airport in Canada, people wished me goodbye and said what a good person I am and how much of a difference I will make. Now in Kenya, I am trying to breath life into the principles and procedures I used to believe were the key to effective development.
It is really, really difficult.
If you think that sorting out your ideas and priorities on development is difficult when you're in Canada, try to figure it out among contradictions of everyday life in the developing world. Try living in my village of Kakamega without losing your optimism, your enthusiasm and your belief in the inherent goodness of people.
When ex-pats here sit around and talk about development, there are often angry words about corruption, bureaucracy, dependence and guilt. And ex-pats aren't the only ones who are disillusioned. Last week, I saw the look on a Kenyan friend's face when he read that his country has slipped a dozen notches on the UN's Human Development Index. Kenyans can't figure it out either -- over endless cups of chai they recite a laundry list of Kenya's assets and shake their heads.
Sparkling clean Land Rovers
These are the dialogues that echo in my thoughts as I fall asleep under the mosquito net at night:
Corruption. Everywhere I look, I see money going to the wrong people or simply disappearing. I read in today's Nation that there is a new house being built for the president at a price of 100 million shillings. I think about how the students at my school complain of headaches. When I ask, they haven't eaten breakfast. Or dinner the night before. Where is their share of the foreign aid that floats Kenya's national budget?
Bureaucracy. Even when money isn't being siphoned off into a politician's pocket, bureaucracy saps the energy and initiative from those people trying to initiate change. A new crop of aid organizations appears every season, each competing for a share of thinly spread resources. I look at the Land Rovers sitting unused in the parking lot of the NGO office next door. They are washed carefully each day -- is this what North Americans thought they were paying for when they pledged money to "the starving children of Africa?"
Culture of dependency. I want Kenyans to believe that they can do this for themselves and that I am here to learn and not just to teach. But I am asked for handouts. I don't even want to think about what percentage of Kenya's budget is aid money. How has development encouraged this passivity, this unwillingness to believe that Kenyans can help themselves?
Inadequacy. In emails home and journal entries, I question what difference I am making. Are my attempts to create change just the imposition of my own culture on people who have their own way of doing things? One of the worst ironies is that when you try to help, you become acutely aware of how big the real problems are. Change comes so painfully slowly; I wonder if I am just imagining it.
But in my late twenties, I am trying to find a place between the stale idealism of youth and the hardened pessimism that dries up so many veteran aid workers. I am not ready to let these narratives of pointlessness become my only words. So I have come up with some personal commandments: Do your research. Think sustainability. Be patient for change. Don't let guilt over not doing enough interfere with doing something.
A new set of postcards
Why is it important to do these things?
Because there are unemployed youths who are not giving up. Just like young people in Canada, they want to contribute something to their society. They bike and walk to village outreach events to sing and perform plays and raise awareness about the disease - HIV/AIDS - that is decimating their peer group.
Because there are mothers walking for three hours up craterous mountain roads to bring their babies to an immunization clinic.
Because at 10 o'clock tea breaks, there are Kenyans discussing politics and democracy with incredible passion, not resignation.
Because there are ex-child soldiers, clad in shiny new Kodak-coloured uniforms, playing soccer instead of killing each other.
Because at HIV training sessions, there are women who stand up from their plastic chairs, swallow the lump in their throat and disclose their HIV status.
Even when corruption, bureaucracy, dependency and inadequacy make it hard to fall asleep, when I do, these are the images I dream of. And these are the images I want to send to friends and family back home. They aren't as picturesque as the postcards of my childhood, but they might help you understand why I remain hopelessly hopeful.
Sarah Jane Crossen is a registered nurse from BC who is an intern working with African Canadian Continuing Education Society, in Kakamega District, Kenya.
Thanks to Tides Canada Foundation for sponsoring our Making the Connections series. Tides Canada is a national public foundation that offers professional giving services to donors who share a concern for social justice and environmental issues - locally, nationally and internationally.




8
Login or register to post comments
BC Mary
6 years ago
Comments on "'Far, Far Away'"
What a beautiful, meaningful statement ... Thank you, Ms Crossen. Stay strong.
darcy.mcgee
6 years ago
I hear the drums echoing tonight
But she hears only whispers of some quiet conversation
It breaks my heart to think about how little the developed world pays attention to Africa. This is the most forgotten place on the earth.
Fiat lux
6 years ago
The so called "developed world" pays very much attention to Africa with their attempts for neo-colonization under the guise of globalized free trade controlled by a few banks with the imaginary capital they create.
The solution to poverty in Africa, or in Canada and anywhere, is the scrapping of so called "wealth creation through investment", which is nothing more, or less, than legalized theft by artificial capital and the development of local self sufficiencies, using local resources and local labour for local use.
Then genuine trade among the overlapping circles of local and global units, not commerce controlled by multinationals for the exploitation of both the makers and buyers.
Africa is suffering from the artificially induced illness of incompetence, the best weapon for exploitation. A trend that's being forced on the whole world.
Today it is Africa and Asia, tomorrow the whole world.
Ed Deak, Big Lake.
Yammer
6 years ago
"I am living the opportunity I have always sought -- working for a nongovernmental organization (NGO) in a developing country."
An honorable occupation. You are in a position to do something good with your life, what a superb situation. Even if you feel you are not saving the world, you are there, and writing about it for us -- that is something. Tipping point theory says you just have to persuade some key adopters of your views, not the whole populace, to start making a real difference.
"[T]here are often angry words about corruption, bureaucracy, dependence and guilt."
There should be anger! These are human faults, which means that they are unnecessary and changeable. Anger is an energy.
"I read in today's Nation that there is a new house being built for the president at a price of 100 million shillings."
If Kenya is as aid-dependent as you posit, then this is not acceptable use of external funds.
If the existing infrastructure wastes the funds in this fashion, then there are two moral alternatives (stopping the funding is not one):
a) Keep the structure but change the head (i.e. fund a coup, probably not the right thing to do);
b) Ignore the structure and set up your own. In other words, create a parallel structure that works. I don't know how you'd keep it safe from the predations of the Kenyan authorities and military, but I am not that smart.
"I look at the Land Rovers sitting unused in the parking lot of the NGO office next door."
If they are unused, then they are not doing any good obviously. Which NGO? I think funders need to know.
"Culture of dependency. I want Kenyans to believe that they can do this for themselves and that I am here to learn and not just to teach. But I am asked for handouts. I don't even want to think about what percentage of Kenya's budget is aid money. How has development encouraged this passivity, this unwillingness to believe that Kenyans can help themselves?"
Hmmm. I wonder if there is an opportunity here for an aid system which works something like the business development bank, but with more hands-on facilitation for those who need it. So that rather than totally set the agenda themselves on behalf of the weak, the aid organization reviews applications for projects by Kenyan citizens, helping see them through to completion but sharing the management and vision.
"Are my attempts to create change just the imposition of my own culture on people who have their own way of doing things?"
Oh my god. This is the LEAST of your worries. Believe in your culture. Your culture led you to feel responsible for humanity, and to do the best you can for people. That, friends, is a good culture. If other cultures are bent to the will of our culture, good. It is hard enough trying to help people with one hand tied behind your back by bureaucracy; there's no befit in tying up your own hands by wringing them about the poor vanishing culture that produces a culture of starving skeletons presided over by a fat prick in a million-shilling palace.
Please do your work with a completely clear conscience, and the thanks of your countrymen.
Coyote
6 years ago
An accurate piece, Fait.
Ron Erwin
6 years ago
It would sure help if Europe dropped farm subsidies so a market for food products from Africa could thrive.
I mean, do they really need to grow wheat and sugar in France?
And, we , of course don't really want to help except to throw money at the problem. As soon as a Corporation wants to set up a factory in an impoverished area, that just might raise thier pay from 10 cents a day to $10.00 per day, we cry EXPLOITATION, GLOBILIZATION, CORPORATE GREED.
We expect all these jobs to be Union jobs in North America paying $18.00 per hour.
I find this disgusting on our part.
Birch
6 years ago
The thing that scares me about the "expanded trade will cure all our ills, and theirs too" philosophy is the cost, both on the books and off, of the transport. In a world in which the cost of energy is only likely to rise, and in which the environmental costs of using fossil fuels are rising in so many ways, it seems to me that we should be focussing on trading over long distances only those things that we cannot produce ourselves. Competitive advantages as measured by traditional economics have to be dramatically large and should include accounting for environmental costs before long distance trade should be touted as the magical solution to improved living standards.
As for Mr. Erwin's comments, corporations that are going into foreign countries should produce primarily for domestic markets there. Then wages and prices would be pretty much naturally in line. The distortions involved in exploiting cheap labour in third world countries in order to take advantage of gigantic profits in the first world (and continually depress wages here) are indulged in by the corporate world not out of any sense of human obligation to our human brothers and sisters in Africa or Asia, but as a cheap way of making a pile of money for shareholders.
Fiat lux
6 years ago
Excellent points, Cheers, Ed.