- Ms Kaye is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Mary Carlisle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Prem Gill is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nancy Flight is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Justin Everett is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- John Westover is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nora Etches is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Edward Henderson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Bharadwaj Chandramouli is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Dean Chatterson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Marius Scurtescu is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Robert Parkes is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- James Murton is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Susan Doyle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Vincent Strgar is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Helen Spiegelman is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Subir Guin is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Kimball Finigan is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joanne Manley is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- David Leach is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
COPE Turmoil: What Fred Said
The words that threaten to break Vancouver’s civic party apart were presented as a bid for unity.
[Editor’s note: At COPE’s monthly membership meeting on Feb. 6, Vancouver city councillor Fred Bass made the following speech, which was subsequently cirulated by e-mail.]
Welcome and thank you for coming this Sunday afternoon. I want to speak to three groups within this audience: COPE members, Larry Campbell, and the media.
First, members of COPE:
In the fog created by the division and separatism within the COPE council caucus, you may have lost track of our accomplishments. We have done more than the previous five councils put together. These include: the Vancouver Climate Change Action Plan (“Cool Vancouver”); the Southeast False Creek Plan, committed to both the environment and to housing all economic segments of Vancouver; the Women’s Task Force; the Ethical Purchasing Policy; North America’s first safe injection site; the redesign of Woodward’s; the Food Policy Organization; legalizing secondary suites; referenda on major issues; major capital investment in bicycle infrastructure; and many more.
COPE, be very proud of what your COPE council has done.
Second, Larry Campbell:
I am your true friend and doing what a true friend should do — telling you when you are off course. Let me be clear, there should be only one COPE council caucus and you, Larry, should be its leader.
You bring many positives attributes: a quick and profound wit, a high capacity for work, and the capacity to relate to a wide variety of people. You also bring the negative: sometimes an intolerance of dissent, and sometimes a disrespect for those who do not share your point of view.
Over the past months I have repeatedly asked you to come back to the caucus that you abandoned many months before December 14, 2004, and you have said no. You have divided the COPE council caucus into two groups that don’t meet face to face. You are raising money separately from the party of which you profess to be a member. Apparently, you have now turned your back on the COPE debt.
Let me tell you a story. In ancient Greece, after a long war between the Greeks and the Trojans, the Greeks gave the Trojans a large wooden statue of a horse as a symbol of peace and left it outside the gates of Troy. The Trojans brought the horse into their city. That night, under cover of darkness, armed soldiers crawled out of their hiding places within the wooden structure, destroyed the Trojan army and ended the existence of Troy.
I ask you Larry Campbell not to be a Trojan Horse …to stop your factional war within COPE, and to work jointly with all COPE councillors to serve the people of Vancouver. I ask the executive and the supporters of COPE not to allow armed men to come into our midst and destroy COPE values that this party has struggled to maintain for 36 years.
The COPE constitution says, as its first purpose, that “COPE stands for uniting individuals and groups behind a program of civic reform.” We are a united coalition of progressive electors.
In 2002, Larry Campbell, COPE welcomed you as our mayoral candidate. By building a splinter group within COPE and raising funds separately, you are doing something unethical and going against the COPE constitution.
No councillor should ever have to choose between loyalty to the mayor or loyalty to the platform on which he or she ran. I challenge you to show true political leadership by promoting teamwork that allows for democratic differences, rather than insisting on chain-of-command obedience and conformity. Valuing dissent is the cornerstone of democracy and of good group decision-making.
COPE and the people of Vancouver need a mayor who will cherish diversity and build a council team that will get re-elected this November. I think you are capable of doing that, if you are willing to change course.
Larry, be a leader, not a Trojan Horse.
Third, the Media:
The easy thing for you to do would be to report what I am saying as a manifestation of dissension within COPE instead of my intent — to review our accomplishments and to build unity.
I challenge you to tell the entire story and to recognize that diversity and dissent promote problem-solving and accomplishment. ![]()



14
Login or register to post comments
hombre (not verified)
7 years ago
This sounds far fairer than the Canwest predictably incredibly biased take on the feud. I myself am somewhat disappointed with Larry Campbell's performance in office, although one can of course only imagine the damage that would have been done to Vancouver with an NPA Gordon Campbell, Jennifer Clarke farmteam government in charge. (nonpartisan -that's a hoot!) Remember what gordon liar did to small town BC, now imagine NPA puppets Sullivan, Ladner and Clark carrying out Gordon Campbell's tainted agenda unopposed in BC's largest city. Cope needs to clear the air and find unity before the next election -remember Trojan horses don't know what they are. There is sure to be a protest vote against Larry from traditional Cope supporters, and Canwest is doing it's best to further such divisions. Sam Sullivan is also doing his best to stop Cope from running at all next election using their unreported campaign donations as an excuse. Mr Sullivan, however, refuses to reveal the source of his successful anti-ward campaign funding, the usual plastic ethics of the right, where ethics are simply something to trip the other side, and need never apply to one's own actions.
Randy (not verified)
7 years ago
COPE has NO chance without Larry Campbell.
Tha Geek (not verified)
7 years ago
I'm a huge COPE supporter and volunteered for them in the last election. I'm not impressed with Larry Campbell right now, I want him to build bridges and agree with much that Bass has to say. I became a supporter of the party because of Tim Louis and Fred Bass, not because of Mayor DaVinci.
Chris H (not verified)
7 years ago
It is no wonder why Larry Campbell split the caucus. He couldn't agree with anything that the more radical COPE councillors wanted. I think Vancouver wants to elect moderates. That is why Campbell got 80,000 votes. If COPE destroys itself and helps the NPA gain control over the Vancouver School Board again, it will be a very sad day for the Vancouver teachers.
deeby (not verified)
7 years ago
Talk about airing your dirty laundry in public...Fred has shown all the political acumen of the average Canadian Alliance MP :-)
Stump (not verified)
7 years ago
So Fred Bass is divisive for calling out Mayor Flip-Flop on his forming a separate caucus and straying from COPE's long-time principles, but Larry the Liar who frequently says what people want to hear to get then promptly does something different is the saviour of Vancouver? Love him or hate him, Bass promises idealism and delivers same. Campbell promises pragmatism and delivers self-interest. Guess who I have more respect for?
ian gregson [rockerbiff] (not verified)
7 years ago
Letter sent to the Province Newspaper: There are those believe political party infighting is often far worse from within than it is from the outside - case in point the recent split between COPE light and COPE classic. COPE have paid the price for going with a mayoral candidate with little or no political experience and hardly any ties to the COPE establishment. What they did go for is an almost celebrity like candidate, who it turns out has a mind of his own an a thin skin to go with it - an explosive combination if ever there was one. I've seen Larry Campbell belittle and bemoan people who oppose him, its not very pleasant to be on the receiving end especially when you know he is wrong. We saw this prior to the 2010 referendum in Vancouver; nothing lights up Larry Campbell's eyes than the dangling carrot of the 2010 Games, so don't get in his way. So the left in Vancouver has imploded after less than a full three year term. Yes, they care more for their own ego's than the people who voted for them and yes they need to settle down and get on with the business of running the city in a more amicable style. Moreover, Larry Campbell has to get off his high horse and remember we elected him as Mayor not Emperor.
James (not verified)
7 years ago
No question, Mr. Campbell's personality is something of a problem. He's a bright guy, though, and probably a good mayor. The best thing for COPE to do, I think, is to let him run as an independent, and concentrate their energy & funds on re-electing COPE councillors citing their accomplishments (which are, as listed by Mr. Bass, pretty impressive).
hombre (not verified)
7 years ago
Thank-you for your admission, Ian Greggson, that are a rightwinger, who speaks of the left "imploding," and who writes letters to the rightwing shill newspaper, the Vancouver Fraser Institute Times,oh, sorry, the Province, whose editorial and letters page is now managed by global warming deniar, and flat earth supporter, jon ferry. What a surprise that he published your maudlin closet rightwinger "theories." Perhaps you could answer my repeated request about your determination to split the vote and reelect a rightwing government that attacks both gay and disabled people, two groups in which you share membership. Oh, those damn unions, eh, greggson...you're a dud!
Stewart Brinton (not verified)
7 years ago
Mayor Campbell may the "celebrity coroner" mayor but he is difficult to work with. It's his way or the highway. It must be remembered that if the NPA hadn't self-destructed Mayor Owen would still be in office-- having won by a landslide. Larry won by default-- the other candidate being hideous backstabber-- and now claims he is COPE. Let him form his own party "Friends of Larry Campbell." It may be easy to garner money from casino interestes but money alone does not make a party. It takes membership and that is not easily accomplished. No matter how much the media totes him as Mister Olympics, Larry Campbell is only one member of the Gang of Four-- now reduced to the Gang of Three.
show him the door (not verified)
7 years ago
COPE should find their own mayoral candidate, and let this ex-movie star mayor, who thinks he is the 'cats whiskers' move back the illusionary world of the movies...where the eltist stars run the show. and ...while COPE is at it...show the door to Raymond Louie, and Jim Green too. The "Campbell" clan seems to be cut from the same cloth, regretably. Campbell's conduct, and the other COPE LITE caucus's conduct is acting like a Trojan horse. Their conduct on the RAV, on expansion of gambling at Hastings Park, is not laudable. I, and many others will not voting for the Cope Lite "crew".
electric (not verified)
7 years ago
the macho boys who raise their money from developers, construction companies and gamblers should leave COPE and take their piggy bank with them. This was once a proud principled civic party until mayor daVinci arrived.
Anonymous
7 years ago
good going Fred. and thanks to the Tyee for publishing his actual speech.
KF (not verified)
7 years ago
Most of you people are on crack. COPE was only too happy to use the Mayor and his coatails to sweep them into office. They just had a problem with him making decisions and exercising leadership on tough issues. When COPE chose him as their candidate they knew he was no lefty ideologue - he was, and is, a centre-left pragmatic governor. But no sooner than they were elected on a moderate platform with a moderate leader, the intolerant, ideological extremists ion COPE decided they would pull a bait-and-switch on the voters who had entrusted them with power in the City of Vancouver. Suddenly, the masks came off and COPE Classic revealed its true colours and intentions. It is no surprise that they have driven Larry and his supporters out of COPE, and they will pay an enormous price in November for their treachery. They will then be back in opposition where they are most comfortable, always able to be righteous, and never accountable for making a decision. What a moral victory! What a lot to be proud of! I hope the Mayor and some reasonable people are elected, otherwise the COPE Classics will have cleared the way for years of NPA rule. Good going guys!