- Ms Kaye is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Mary Carlisle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Prem Gill is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nancy Flight is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Justin Everett is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- John Westover is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nora Etches is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Edward Henderson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Bharadwaj Chandramouli is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Dean Chatterson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Marius Scurtescu is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Robert Parkes is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- James Murton is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Susan Doyle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Vincent Strgar is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Helen Spiegelman is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Subir Guin is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Kimball Finigan is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joanne Manley is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- David Leach is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
Campbell and COPE: The New Arrangement
Call it a trial separation, all about hurt feelings, owed money and how to remain loved by the kids, er voters.
It was supposed to be splitsville. Vancouver Mayor Larry Campbell was going to leave his whirlwind bride and strike out on his own as an independent soul. Instead, Campbell told a Tuesday afternoon press conference that he's sometimes been a bad husband in a rocky relationship and he wants to try and work it out.
"I'm not leaving COPE," he said of the party he led to a resounding victory in the 2002 Vancouver civic election. He also shouldered "some of the blame" for the friction.
But, just in case, he's keeping a separate bank account.
What brought him back, after months of speculation — fuelled by Campbell's private musings and personal fundraising efforts — that he would run as an independent in the next civic election? Likely a dose of common sense, courtesy of the people who stood behind him at the press conference, including COPE councillors Jim Green, Tim Stevenson, and Raymond Louie.
While Larry Campbell would walk to a mayoral victory as an independent, his opportunities to shape council's makeup would be limited, nothwithstanding all the yammering about the electoral power of the Campbell "touch." In fact, with Campbell as an independent mayoral candidate, council might become even more Balkanized.
COPE, which has a penchant for self-destructive behavior, might revert to form and run a slate of white ideologues better at opposing than governing.
And the NPA, who Jim Green described Tuesday as "a cadaver looking for a grave to fall into," would be given the breath of life. NPA councillors Peter Ladner and Sam Sullivan would be able to portray themselves as closer to Campbell than COPE's lefties. Green, no doubt trying to shift the media's focus onto the NPA with a bit more hyperbole, said that prospect is "the only thing that can keep them alive."
Follow the money
Then, as always, there's money. COPE was left with a $300,000 debt after the last election. It would be unseemly for Campbell to walk away from his wedding expenses. As well, the COPE executive likely understands that a split would seriously hamper its ability to raise money to fight the next civic election.
So there, behind Larry Campbell, along with the three councillors, was former COPE executive co-chair Carmela Allevato, along with Leonard Schein, the former proprietor of the Fifth Avenue Cinemas and backroom man about town. Allevato and Schein announced the formation of the Friends of Larry Campbell, while Campbell announced an "independent COPE caucus" that will meet apart from the other five COPE councillors.
Some media actually characterized the formation of the caucus as a split, even though it's just a formal acknowledgement of what's been going on since early in COPE's term. Campbell said he hadn't met with the full COPE caucus for two years. Jim Green said he'd been to only one meeting in the past two months.
Although the independents promised to keep talking to their counter-caucus in hope of reconciliation, Campbell acknowledged that their differences of opinion are deeply and honestly held and he's not sure how they can be resolved.
Although some left-out councillors said they found news from the press conference encouraging, they have reason for caution. As any McDonald will tell you, Campbells have feigned peace before and then murdered their rivals in their sleep.
Reconciliation?
One reconciliation remains impossible. Councillor Tim Louis's contempt for Campbell continues unabated; he sees him as betraying party policies on gambling and transit. Campbell sees Louis and others as betraying party policy on the Olympics and transit.
In fact, they both have credible arguments. And while Campbell called for councillors to show discipline and support council's majority decisions, on some key issues most COPE councillors oppose Campbell.
Reconcilliation is unlikely. A war for the support of COPE's membership and control of the COPE slate in the next election seems inevitable.
Louis has clout with COPE's old-school members, but COPE membership has grown considerably — from 1,000 to 3,000, according to Campbell — since he joined the party.
He also told the news conference that he wants COPE to put forward an ethnically diverse slate. COPE has no sparkling record there (witness the current overwhelmingly white regime), while the NPA's fixers have ensured that it has done so consistently. To ensure COPE puts forward such a slate, Campbell's Friends will likely recruit new members, and those members will challenge the preferences of some among COPE's old guard.
'Pig wrestling'
In the last election, COPE elected all eight of its candidates to the 10-member council. If COPE again chooses to leave some electoral room for the Green party, some of the existing councillors will have to go. Yet except for Stevenson, who hopes to reclaim the West End riding in next spring's provincial election, there's no indication that any will leave willingly.
And while Campbell tried for a day to be a kinder, gentler mayor, one who will "continue to work with our fellow COPE councillors" and put the money he's raised in COPE's coffers if everything works out, sometimes he just can't help himself, even when he's just trying to explain.
Campbell talked about how ineffective scrapping can be in politics, especially when dealing with senior governments. Then he quoted his father's advice. "Never wrestle with a pig. You both get dirty and the pig likes it."
Uh, but what if the pig is a contrary COPE councillor? In such instances, Campbell has had difficulty adhering to his father's prescription. And if the pig is a clever and impetuous Tim Louis, there is plenty of mud wrestling yet to come.
Charles Campbell is a contributing editor to The Tyee.
![]()



14
Login or register to post comments
Pragmatist (not verified)
7 years ago
In the last civic election, Vancouverites were so anxious to get rid of the NPA, that COPE could have run monkeys and have made a strong showing (some may argue that they did). Voters, despite some of the chaff that replaced them, don't miss the childish antics of counsellor (then called 'aldermen", as most of them were tired old men). The days of Harry's Rankin's "tough titty" outbursts George Puil's czarist superiority and are gone. We now hope for a little more professionalism from our counsellors, as well as fiscally responsible progressiveness. Come the next election, don't be suprised to see Tim Louis and his fellow drama queens on the COPE Classic side turfed from office. We can only hope that we don't overcompensate and swing back to the NPA sweep situation. This council represents, in theory, our most balanced group in many years. There are great opportunities here, but COPE Classic needs to loosen up a bit and accept other points of view, and the newer COPE gang needs to pay more attention to the priorities of those that the classics represent. If they could all stop acting like children and get to work, we'll all be better off.
lewis swift (not verified)
7 years ago
As I said earlier, larry is merely moving towards the formalization of an already existing relationship. In my opinion louis and campbell should both cooperate more, and increase ethnic diversity in COPE. And better monkeys, than rubber-stamp pimps, like the npa, and like our government in victoria...
Old-timer (not verified)
7 years ago
Charles Campbell (look out all McDonalds) writes that Larry Campbell "... wants COPE to put forward an ethnically diverse slate. COPE has never done that...". That's simply not true, in 1993 COPE ran a very ethnically diverse slate, including people of Filipino, Korean, South Asian and Chinese ancestry (remember Jenny Kwan?) along with prominent members of the Gay & Lesbian Community and strong neighbourhood activists. What goes without saying, however, is that once is not enough.
Corrections (not verified)
7 years ago
Carmella Alleveto is the former co-chair of the COPE executive. She did not run for the executive at the last AGM. It is Tim Stevenson (not Stephensen).
Anonymous
7 years ago
Jean Binette, 12/15/2004 4:37:55 AM, writes: - and Jim who wrote "And Lewis I don't even need to respond to your immature back talk. I know 5 year olds who make more mature statements than you". --Point taken.
Charles Campbell (not verified)
7 years ago
I'll forgive myself for not noticing that COPE, once, had an ethnically diverse slate. I'm annoyed that I failed to note Ms. Allevato's recent departure from her role as COPE executive co-chair. But spelling Tim Stevenson's name wrong is unforgivable -- the kind of thing that really wrecks my day -- even if my corrector misspelled my misspelling. My apologies to all concerned, including the readers.
Chevy (not verified)
7 years ago
Larry Campbell is going about this correctly. Hopefully this effort is enough to keep out those idiotic NPA people. Thank you
sdgreen (not verified)
7 years ago
It is quite fun watching the socialists implode!
Name (not verified)
7 years ago
"Pragmatist" has it right. The constant focus on COPE's internal squabbles hardly inspires confidence--they haven't got much hope of another term if they can't learn to cooperate or go their separate ways. Campbell is increasingly coming off as a bully and the other side as inflexible ideologues--and how is the regular voter to decide whether to support COPE if COPE can't tell us what they stand for because they consist of two diametrically opposed camps. The real shame is that they all probably have some good ideas and ideals and that they're bringing down their colleagues on the school board, who have been doing a pretty decent job in a tough situation.
allan (not verified)
7 years ago
sdgreen. Want some more fun? Turn your peepers toward Victoria where implosion is in full swing. Oh, I forget those Liberals certainly aren't socialists now are they. But, hey I'm laughing.
Eddie (not verified)
7 years ago
Is this all we have to criticize about? They haven't sold Stanley Park to a developer yet, They haven't put up a toll on Granville street, They haven't leased the Burrard street bridge to a foriegn country, They haven't got drunk in Hawaii (christmas is just starting, there's still hope)and city hall workers are still Canadian. Good job COPE! Maybe after the next term they will be the scoundrels Vancouverites are used to. Merry Christmas Eddie
Jay Currie (not verified)
7 years ago
allan, sdgreen, the one justification for municipal politics - and for that matter provincial politics -- is, of course, entertainment value. Gone are the days of Harry's rightous indignation, Puil's unfailing ability to rise to any bait at all and, lest we forget, Ed Sweeny.
Sourpusses will, no doubt, suggest that politics should have higher aims than mere entertainment; but, let's face it, would Larry be mayor without Davinci's Inquest. The problem with muni politics is that, after you have declared Vancouver a nuclear weapons free, gay friendly, whale positive, zone you are back to the grind of sewers, back alley improvements and the development game.
Ambitious mayors look to precedent and want to be premiers. And they cannot get there without ditching the hard left. Which Larry is perfectly aware of. You dance with the lady who brung ya until the siren in the corner suggests a trot around the floor.
COPE lite is as much about what Larry is doing in four years and the booming sound from the southern end of Vancouver Island as it is about socialist orthodoxy.
The Glencoe 38 (not verified)
7 years ago
Lads and Lassies! Allevato wouldn't have survived a re-election as an executive member of COPE nor would many of the folks who tried to oust Bass, Louis or Roberts. The large gathering of the clan COPE during its last AGM (the one that was postponed "due to not enough space") would have seen a political blood letting that we MacDonalds would have been proud of. The so-called Lites or Gang of Four and their supporters were outnumbered 5 to 1! The Glencoe 38 have a New Years message for ye all: Defeat the Campbells in 2005! In our tiny public house in Glencoe we still hang a sign outside and it reads, "No Campbells allowed". Now take heed me lads and lassies, we learned the hard way and now you have. Rid yeselves of the Campbells! They're just no good!!!
Nolan Strom (not verified)
7 years ago
Put everything aside here and the fact is that COPE needs Campbell. He has the money and the broad support needed to win a second term. As for municipal politics being meaningless????? Are you crazy? Vancouver is on a 30 year growth spurt and has a considerable ways to go before it's going to slow down. The reality is that it's the municipalities that are going to decide what this all looks like. Also what about the lower east side? COPE's efforts to deal with the problems there using the 4 pillar approach have received attention from LA to NYC to Washington DC. If successful they could set precedent for a workable and compassionate alternative to the "war on drugs." The only people that municipal politics should be boring to are people who don't live in Vancouver.