Opinion

The Truth About the Green River Killer

Gary Ridgway should have been caught a long time ago. His choice of victims had everything to do with why he wasn't.

By Silja J.A. Talvi, 12 Nov 2003, AlterNet.org

In a calm voice and with an expressionless gaze, a bespectacled 54-year-old Washington State resident by the name of Gary Ridgway confessed to killing 48 women.

To be accurate, Ridgway raped, choked, killed and discarded 48 women, including many teenagers as young as 15 years of age.

Ridgway was a married man and a father, a white guy from Auburn, Washington who held the same job for 30 years -- and who got away with killing one female after another for over 20 years.

When America's worst captured serial killer finally began cooperating with authorities to reveal the locations of his victims, people in the Pacific Northwest breathed a collective sigh of relief. Finally, the notorious Green River Killer had been caught. And finally, the family members of the deceased could have some peace of mind, knowing that the nightmare, at least in one sense, was over.

Detective work, diligence, and a decision on the part of the King County Prosecutor to spare Ridgway the death sentence in exchange for information are all being hailed as a job well done. Ridgway will never kill again.

But the question remains: Why was he allowed to kill, again and again, when so much evidence had already pointed in his direction two decades ago?

The answer, in great part, lies in Ridgway's own admission of who he preyed upon.

"I picked prostitutes as my victims because I hate most prostitutes and I did not want to pay them for sex," Ridgway said in his confessional statement. "I also picked prostitutes as victims because they were easy to pick up without being noticed. I knew they would not be reported missing right away and might never be reported missing. I picked prostitutes because I thought I could kill as many of them as I wanted without getting caught."

At least one-third of Ridgway's female victims were girls and women of color, and the vast majority were under the age of 22. Ridgway, an extreme incarnation of a brutal misogynist, considered killing female prostitutes a "career." He felt proud of what he did, and thought he was damn good at it.

In Ridgway's mind, he even believed that he was helping the police out, as he admitted in one interview with investigators.

"I thought I was doing you guys a favor, killing prostitutes," he said. "Here you guys can't control them, but I can."

Prostitutes were an infestation, a sickly disease to which Ridgway thought he had the cure. So he "cured" young women of what he saw as their pathetic and undeserving lives. Not everyone he killed was a prostitute, but in his mind, they all deserved what they got.

But like most street prostitutes, these were girls and young women with families. Some had drug and alcohol problems and yet stayed close to their parents, who tried to help them through. Some had boyfriends or even husbands who knew what they did for a living because of the dire economic circumstances of their lives.

Street prostitution is one of the most dangerous ways for a woman to make a living, and it is also the method of making income that is the most judged and moralized against. Nevada's legalized brothels and emerging progressive feminist attitudes toward sex work aside, prostitutes continue to be reviled.

Attitudes toward prostitutes -- their very dehumanization -- underlies the Green River Killer case, and yet prostitutes are the aspect of this story that has been least discussed.

Would Ridgway have been stopped in his tracks 20 or fifteen years ago if his female victims had had different class backgrounds, had not participated in the street economy, been more "innocent" in the eyes of the law?

In April 1983, the boyfriend of 16-year-old Kimi-Kai Pitsor told police that she had gotten into an older green Ford pickup truck, and he described the driver. Ridgway's girlfriend at the time owned an older, light-green Ford. (Four years later, Pitsor's boyfriend picked Ridgway's photo out of a montage.)

Then, in May 1983, Marie Malvar, 18, disappeared after getting in Ridgway's truck. Malvar's boyfriend actually took police to Ridgway's house four days later, and then identified the pickup he saw Malvar get into. When two detectives questioned Ridgway, he actually admitted to picking up prostitutes, but denied any contact with Malvar. Despite the eyewitness identification, the neighborly, upstanding Ridgway was left alone.

Ridgway continued to have many close calls with police, evading and fooling officers and detectives all the while. Would Ridgway have been let go, time after time, had he been anything other than an "ordinary" looking middle-class white man who preyed on the vulnerable, the poor, and the powerless?

In 1984, Rebecca Garde Guay actually came forward to police to say that she had been assaulted two years prior by a man who tried to kill her with a chokehold. Not only did Guay know Ridgway's place of employment (he had shown her an identification card), but she also picked him out of a book of photos. What's worse, Ridgway had the sheer gall to admit having "dated" Guay and even choking her.

But by then, Guay no longer wanted to pursue charges. She became the only known survivor of the Green River Killer. Perhaps she was afraid of being hunted down, or perhaps she just knew that she wouldn't be believed. And in this way, Ridgway was allowed to return to his life, killing many dozens more young women along the way.

Although Ridgway copped to 48 murders, he says it's possible he killed as many as 60 women and girls.

"In most cases when I killed these women I did not know their names," Ridgway stated. "Most of the time I killed them the first time I met them and I do not have a good memory of their faces. I killed so many women I have a hard time keeping them straight."

To Ridgway, they were faceless, nameless females who wouldn't be missed.

And in some ways, he was right. The victimization of prostitutes--a rampant phenomenon across North America--occurs as frequently as it does because so few people do care, and because prostitutes themselves are so afraid to report the abuse.

A 2001 report by the Coalition Against Trafficking in Women found that nearly 90 percent of prostitutes in the U.S. reported being physically abused by pimps and traffickers. And one-half of women in this study described frequent, sometimes daily assaults.

To progressives, prostitutes are alternately viewed as victims in need of rescue and rehabilitation, or else as sex workers who have the right to decide their form of livelihood. The truth, it seems, lies somewhere in the middle--in allowing women to pursue their occupation of choice but recognizing that many prostitutes (especially street workers) have faced terrible abuse as children and teens, and need a hand to help them out of a life they've become trapped in.

The decriminalization of prostitution would go a long way toward giving women more incentive to report suspicious behavior and violence by lessening their fear of arrest or poor treatment by police.

But in this perversely moralistic culture--where skin and sexuality sell product, but skin and sex themselves cannot be for sale--prostitution is still the dark secret in our midst.

And prostitution, in turn, has become a lightning rod for society's collective hatred of women who "abandon" their families and their children; who fall from grace and descend into "degrading" behavior. Women who consciously choose to sell sex -- to get by, to get a fix, to pay rent, to feed a kid, or to even to go to school--are human beings whose existences we'd rather not deal with or see walking down our streets.

As a society, we still see prostitution as an infestation to be kept under control. Words like "eradication" used in tandem with street prostitution are not uncommon in law enforcement lingo, as if the women selling their bodies are no better than vermin.

Ridgway saw these women and wanted them dead.

If we are not willing to consider how and why a man like Ridgway can come to exist and commit his crimes for years on end, we haven't even begun to dig deeply enough into the dark core at the root of this kind of hatred.

Perhaps Nancy Gabbert, the mother of 17-year-old Ridgway victim Sandra, said it best.

"Fifty years ago, Gary Ridgway was a little baby," Gabbert told the Seattle Post-Intelligencer while explaining her opposition to the death penalty for her daughter's killer. "He's not some monster who was dropped down from another planet. He was created right here in our society."

"How did we do this?" she asked.

She deserves a real answer.


Silja J.A. Talvi is a freelance writer based in Seattle. She writes for AlterNet, In These Times, The Nation and other publications. Her work appears in the new anthology, "Prison Nation" (Routledge, 2003).  [Tyee]

7  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • J Cullen (not verified)

    8 years ago

    In order for us as a society to come to grips with the tupes of crimes that serial killers and rapists commit, we need to look in our own back yard. What are the systemic reasons that propel a man like Ridgeway to act on his impulses? Have we really asked the right questions at the right level? His penchant for killing didn't start as an adult, it likely formed as a youngster or young adult in response to some trauma or stimuli. We would probably find that the subcultures and charateristics that were his young life life led him to the path he then chose. We need to learn from killers like Ridgeway,take those lessons and apply them way back on the time line of child development in order for us be successful in turning our attention to where it needs so much focus - early childhood. The social risk factors for Ridgeway are likley traceable to his upbringing during those formative years. Killers of this magnitude are made not born.

  • anne cameron (not verified)

    8 years ago

    Maybe it's too facile to blame "nurture" and study the babyhood, childhood, youth, and background of such monsters. "Nature" should be considered, too. some people are creeps. Whether big people or small people, some are born without a full deck. The place I would be more interested in seeing some real hard-nosed investigation is in the police who did not investigate. Willie "Pigman" Picton is an example closer to home... we need to raise hell about the way the police as good as helped him in his murderous rampage. Too little attention has been paid to the people who have stepped forward to say they gave information to police years ago which ought to have been acted on and wasn't. Right now we have police admitting to kidnapping, forcibly confining, assaulting and even robbing unsavory men in Vancouver..and the cops are on PAID suspension. That must seem like paid vacation! Where had the police stuffed their heads when they should have been investigating "Piggys Palace"? How many more people have to fight to prove they were framed and sent to jail for years for crimes they did not commit, how many more Donald Marshalls, Jean-Guy Morins, David Milgard...etc., etc., have to prove the hard way that the cops fabricated evidence or deliberately suppressed other evidence in order to "clear the books"... I am not really interested in how Ridgeway or Picton were toilet trained, or if their moms were strict, or lenient or if their puppydog got ran over or... we have ALL of us suffered "trauma or stimulii". And we aren't all out there chopping women to hamburger. Those who were paid to serve and protect did neither. We should get a refund! Neither Ridgeway nor Picton could have gone on as long as they did or killed as many as they did without some kind of help from the cops who did not do their jobs. If either of these wastes of skin had been killing judges or politicians do you really think they'd have been left alone to continue for so many years? But they were slaughtering women. This misogynistic society has been turning a blind eye to that particular passtime for centuries.

  • Chuck Beyer (not verified)

    8 years ago

    The fact is that there are so many crimes of morality police dont have time for vilent crime any more. During the last decade we had dozens of women killed by a serial killer in Vancouver. Less than 30% of violent crimes get solved in Vancouver. But all the Vancouver police had time for was their "green teams". All they ever want more momey for is to chase users and growers of plants. As long ridculous crimes like marijuana prohibition exist police will always go for the easy brownie points of a pot bust instead of protecting citizens from real violent crime. And this is inspite of the fact that your chances of getting robbed or beaten on the way home is better than being "marijuanaed". Lets acquire some sanity folks. Tell the yankees to shove thier war on drugs where it fits best ( if ever they can remove thier heads first) and have our police do nothing but solve crimes against persons and property. Police priorities are directly to blame for these serial killers success in perpetrating thier crimes.

  • Anonymous (not verified)

    8 years ago

    Chuck, Please don't use this tragic series of events as a way to spread your Marijuana propaganda.

  • Gem (not verified)

    8 years ago

    Chuck might just have a point here... It seems too true that the police almost everywhere would rather pop a drug user,dealer,grower, than realy prevent or protect the average citizen from crime. Then you have the less than average citizens. low income people, Ladies of the night, gay folk, the homeless people, and the Kids and other folk who hang out on the street. Any arrest on a drug charge is easy money for the prprosecutor's office. ( No one wants drugs in our socity) It's an easy win, and it's not about truth, or justice, it's only about winning. You must understand that prison is big business. this is why we keep building bigger prisons. The States receive money per head, per prison. The state also receives money from the prisoners and from the prisoners familys. Prison aint like they make it look in the movies. Prisoners do the cooking cleaning,almost all the chores inside and outside prison. They buy their own chothes, pay to do their own laundry, and shop at the prison store with a 35% markup than retail stores on the outside. Prisoners are also farmed out to do county work, city work, and work for business who pay the prison, the prison pays the prisoner a quarter an hour and keeps the rest. The poor chump gets out and like a revolving door gets tossed back into prison so the state can keep getting the money from the feds. A few years ago the D.O.C. began shuffeling prisoners from prison to prison. Why? because they had empty beds. And they were being reviewed. They shipped sixty men all over the state to show that the state really needed the money... after all the beds were all full. To get back to the tragic series of avents... There is a serial killer in Minnesota, another one in lower Michigan near Detroit. How about all those murders at the Texas/Mexico border town near El Passo? It seems as though every city of any size, in every state, has it's red light area or place for the street walkers. The girls are going missing everywhere. Even Spokane Washington had it's serial rapest and murderer. Robert Yates, like Gary Ridgeway was a mid class, mid aged screwed up white guy who got away with murdering women who were mothers, daughters, sisters,and friends. All of whom deserved better than they received at the hands, not of their murders, but from society

  • adrienne squires (not verified)

    8 years ago

    We need to document these killers childhood, and blast it on the tv over and over...I agree ,,they were innocent babies,,not monsters.. we need to show on TV these childhoods..so idots raising children can see the MARK they make on children.. but hey ,,,look at the priests, boyscout leaders..do.. Our children are growing up with violence,,dehumanized by it...so you aint seen NOTHING yet... just close your eyes,,watch the tv,,say nothing to your kids..fear they wont love YOU...etc on and on.. IT IS a fatherless nation,,it will GET worse.. I am grateful I have NO grandchildren.. judges, laws..christians..spewing their crap...FAITH without WORKS is dead.......do something.. I am a women,,I am already down the minute Im born..IT is a mans world....wars are fought over MONEY>POWER

  • Anonymous (not verified)

    7 years ago

    Yes the police have screwed this one up, but it may not be because they wern't doing the job they were asked to do. The failure here is to recognize that this behavior is learned behavior, and there is someone teaching this thrill kill style in the Northwest. All these murders are connected, and the real failure is for the multiple jurisdictions to link the people involved. What, do you think that the Northwest has all of a sudden become the bigest killing fields in the civalized world, when we are at peace? The police in Spokane are looking for a brown motorhome, Gary had one, and know one can put that together? Gary used to take that motorhome to BC with friends, and not with his wife. All these guys are working together, and I'll bet there are a lot more lurking on the sidelines. Why Willie, and not his brother Dave. He ran the farm, and the parties. What is the conection between the Piggie parties, that both of them ran, and the rumors, and reports of Porn movies, maybe snuff movies made there? It will never be figured out, because no one jurisdiction is taking contol of the investigation into all the Nothwest murders. All of the Jurisdictions are competing for thier own glory. Many will get away with murder! Many more murders will happen, and are still happening. Trying to blame a persons upbringing for this kind of behavior is BS! This behavior was taught to each of these murders, and they were not the only ones that learned. So far the police and prosicutors have given no reason for any of these perpotrators to give it up on the others. The lack of hard time, or death as a threat was lost to the squeemish in the leftist revolution of the Sixties. Now we have to listen to phycological BS from people looking to get famous on someone elses missory, or self pittying wimps that can't pull them selfs up, but sure know how to whine! A hundred years ago, this behavior would not have been tolerated. These so called men, would be turned in to real swingers, at the end of a stiff hemp rope. Justice will always loose, when people are to weak to demand it. The weak whine the lowdest, for pitty on the wickid!

    • No best comments selected by an editor for this story yet. To see all comments, click the All Comments tab, above.
    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.