Are Viral Ads Helping to Kill Newsrooms?
VIDEO: When advertising like Toshiba's timesculpture ad are distributed via e-mail, what happens to news revenues?
Like Christmas or the Tooth Fairy before the big "reveal," this video seems like pure magic to me.
Advertising in the '80s and '90s was different; like Cyndi Lauper (who, don't get me wrong, I love), ads used to be loud, bright and over the top. They shouted, "Look at me," and I sometimes did, but often pressed the mute button or simply turned the page. It seems, though, we're in a new era where it's about making the ordinary extraordinary, and the few hundred thousands views this Toshiba ad has already had suggests it's working on people other than me.
My friend, a film editor, not a magician, explained the trick, and there's a YouTube vid about it, too. Basically, they filmed each person separately, using 200 cameras mounted on a large rig, then did lots of visual effects and compositing, then put it all together. His words: "It would take a really, really, really big amount of work and even more money."
It's not like ad budgets, or the need for innovation, were ever weak: print advertisers had to draw readers' eyes from the columns to the margins, and TV ads had to keep people from turning the channel.
Now, those wily advertisers don't need a page or a TV channel. Since the beginning of newspapers, there's been symbiosis: editorial provided the page, the delivery method, for advertising, and advertising paid for the delivery of editorial.
But since advertisers can now put their videos directly on YouTube, there's no need for an editorial vehicle to provide the eyeballs. Advertisers know that if they make the ad funny enough or catchy enough or magical enough, I'll forward it to all my friends. Three people forwarded me a link to the Toshiba ad last week, and so far I haven't seen it grace my TV screen. It's one of many captivating, expensive ads that bypass media outlets, leaving that space for lower budget ads.
Even I'm changing my forwarding habits. I'm a reading relic: I still spend hours every day reading whole online newspaper and magazine articles and blog posts. And in the recent past, when I read something and thought of a friend, I used to send a link to the whole article, regardless of length, expecting they'd find time to at least skim it, whereas I now copy and paste the relevant paragraph or two into the e-mail itself, and expect that few will even find time to read that (with the exception of my journalist or information junkie pals). Few friends send me links to articles these days; most just send video URLs.
So it's no coincidence that my inbox is also full of e-bulletins about record layoffs in the journalism industry. Most notably, Time Inc. laid off 600 people (including people at Sports Illustrated and People), several Vogue magazines have folded, the Economist is cutting, Radar folded (again) and CanWest announced cuts of 560 people last week. It's not just the inevitable extinction of a print dinosaur, accelerated by announcements that the cost of paper is going up 20 per cent this year, the online-only Gawker Media empire expects ad revenues to be down 40 per cent everywhere due to the economic downturn, and is folding publications and laying off staff. That seems, um, like a lot.
There are endless panels and articles about the death of journalism. But regardless of the reasons, in the end, many people are using their media time to watch cool ads and funny videos, then just quickly scanning the news headlines.
Could viral videos be the charming, captivating killer of the newsroom?
Related Tyee stories:
- Waassssssuuuuuppppp!?
VIDEO: Eight years later, the seminal beer commercial is updated for a more sober era. - Meltdown Marketing
VIDEO: 'Caught on tape' tantrums are so viral, big biz is faking them. - Gorilla Marketing
VIDEO: Simian slams suitcase! In praise of a retro classic.



mjscox
18-11-2008
Tyee is news redefined
So if newspapers may be on the way out over the next decade, with declining readership forcing them to cut costs so much that they become little more than flyers, we still need our news (more on that in a moment) and where best to get it, locally? This website! Support The Tyee not only by checking it daily, and by donation or a modest subscription, and by clicking, now and then, on an advertisement of interest: showing up and reading it will help keep one of the best online news sources alive and vital.
My comment about still needing the news led me to think: it is advantageous for a government, any government--municipal, provincial, and federal--to have an UN-informed public. That way they do what they think is best or most expedient, and we sit back and play our part as CONSUMERS of their agenda. Same goes for corporations: don't think, buy! If we don't value independent, thoughtful analysis of news on local, national and international levels, we will be playing into the hands of those powerful few who gain most by our ignorance, whether they be legitimate governments or terrorists. Information is not mere data, it is power, and I for one do not wish to concentrate any more power in the hands of those who already wield too much power than is already the case.
For instance, read the Tyee article published today (nov 18) on the new ferries. The Ferry Corp restricts access to information--why? Damage control. What they don't want us to know is precisely what we must know, and the only way to find that stuff out is by having paid, professional journalists and an unbiased, aggressive news source, like The Tyee.
morechatter
19-11-2008
Dramatic changes ahead for industry
Its why I believe you don't need to spend a whole lot a money to get your message out there as its a new information age. And it at all our fingertips. You can now travel the world while sitting at home and talk with just about anyone as I speak with those from around the globe. Well maybe not the Chinese as speaking out is not permitted in Communist country and you could end up dead. It is what will bring them down as it does not matter how many people you have to determine a countries wealth but what they are doing and how they are doing. Look at Africa as I often find it difficult to keep up on the news of all the strife going on with her people.
morechatter
19-11-2008
Its Instant Its Real Time
As often videos of news events are posted immediately. The public has been weary of canned news for sometime as they pick up the paper for entertainment and something to read as they drink morning java and make jokes of media providers attempts at brainwashing. New gadgets make internet access a breeze as its a all in one phone, camera, and world wide news.