How to Be a Good Wife

In 1913, that is. 'Perpetual Honeymoon for the Vancouver Bride' told how. Part of a two-day series on marriage then and now.

By Crawford Kilian, 26 Aug 2004, TheTyee.ca

Flour13

If you were a new bride in the Vancouver of 1913, you had serious responsibilities. You had to make sure both you and your husband looked your best, you had to decide on home furnishings (and on moving smartly from a rented apartment to a house of your own), and you had to know how to deal with a range of medical crises, and even with a death in the family.

And you had to cook.

These were the messages, explicit and implicit, in a 240-page hardbound book given away to newlyweds just before the war. The Real Home Keeper: A Perpetual Honeymoon for the Vancouver Bride. (View this article's gallery of images to see some pages from the book).

Almost a century later, "The Real Home Keeper" shows how much has changed in Vancouver--and how much hasn't. The book was really a kind of elaborate advertising flyer, with articles written by the advertisers themselves. Like today's advertisers, Vancouver's 1913 merchants wanted to sell not just useful goods and services, but a sense of status. They literally had to speak the bride's language, and to offer her a vision of domestic and social success.

"To have your home faultlessly equipped according to the requirements of etiquette and the canons of good taste, and to be a success as wife and hostess, are not the least of your ambitions."

That 34-word sentence in an ad for O.B. Allan, a jeweller, tells us a great deal about the 1913 bride. She wasn't interested in self-expression, but in conforming to requirements and canons. The advertiser expected her to be able to read a long, involuted sentence and to agree with its content. Today's advertisers would expect much less.

The Butler Did It

While the bride was likely middle-class and therefore concerned about saving money, she also aspired to an upper-class elegance. So she learned about the butler's duties even if she couldn't afford one. (Among other tasks, "He prepares the salad. He attends to the bell, to the fires, to the lighting of the house. He makes and serves afternoon tea and sets the table for dinner. He announces all the meals, serves the dinner, does all the carving.")

She also learned what was involved in hosting a formal dinner: "Name cards should be placed on each cover. Each gentleman should be given a card, on entering the dressing-room, with the name of the lady whom he is to escort to the dining-room, and the letter R or L, also on the card, indicating to the right or left of the hostess." At an informal dinner, the bride as hostess would serve the soup, dessert and coffee, while her husband as host would serve the fish and the roast.

Such events would require a large house with an ample kitchen. By 1913 Vancouver had enjoyed a long real-estate boom, so newlyweds were urged to consider buying a lot and building a bungalow. The Maritime Trust Company said: "We will sell you a nice, cozy bungalow, inside city limits and close to our car line, for $100 cash and the balance as rent, $25 per month. South Vancouver lots, $425 each." (In 2004 dollars, that would be about $7,400.) For the more adventurous, a lot in Port Alberni was going for "$150 to $175--$10 down and $10 per month" when $10 was worth 175 of our dollars.

If she'd been a hard bargainer, the 1913 bride might have driven the price down still more. The boom had busted, and Vancouver was suffering a serious depression.

The Need for Good Eats

Once settled in her home, the 1913 bride's chief obligation was to feed her family. The title page of "The Real Home Keeper" summarized her situation:

If you would enjoy distinction
As a cook for the elite
Just turn the leaves of R.H.K.;
Your success will be complete.

One ad spoke to the husband:

You know very well, Daddy, that every man has a weakness for good cooking, but you cannot expect to get "good eats" unless your wife is fully equipped with a line of Modern Cooking Utensils.

The time to start fitting your kitchen is NOW before you call a biscuit a "sinker" and defame the qualities of the pie crust.

"Good eats" were, by today's standards, an orgy that could lead only to stupefaction and premature cardiac arrest. One ad described "a typical Canadian breakfast":

Oatmeal, with Butter (or Cream) and Sugar;
Buttered Toast;
Soft-boiled Eggs, with a lump of Butter;
Griddle Cakes, with Butter.

"If the Butter is not first-class, the meal is spoiled, because the Butter is everything; all the other good things depend upon it to make them appetizing."

A formal ten-course dinner was even more daunting:

First Course: Oysters or Clams in Shells, Brown Bread Sandwiches
Second Course: Consomme, Croutons
Third Course: Broiled Trout, Cucumbers, Maitre d'Hotel Butter
Fourth Course: Croquettes or Sweetbreads
Fifth Course: Saddle of Mutton, Currant Jelly, Potatoes, Peas in Fontage Cups
Sixth Course: Punch
Seventh Course: Broiled Quail and Chestnut Puree, Tomato Salad
Eighth Course: Bombe Glace, Sponge Cake
Ninth Course: Fruit and Bonbons
Tenth Course: Fagan's Gold Crown Coffee (Black)
Salted almonds and bonbons to be on the table all the time. Celery to be passed with oysters. Radishes or olives to be passed with fish course.

Guests would wash down this meal with a variety of wines:

Sauterne, slightly cold, with oysters
Sherry, slightly cold, with soup
Rhine Wine, not very cold, with fish
Claret, slightly cold, with entrees
Champagne, very cold, with poultry and meat
Burgundy and Champagne, with salads
Burgundy, a little warm, with game
Port Wine or Madeira, temperature of wine cellar, with desserts
Cordials and Brandies, with Fagan's Gold Crown coffee

After which, presumably, everyone could crawl home down Georgia Street or simply sleep it off under the dining-room table.

The Real Home Keeper also advised the bride on how to cook all these dishes. We might wonder how any nourishment remained in these gargantuan feasts, because green peas were to be boiled 20 to 40 minutes. String beans had to boil for one to two hours, just like tomatoes, spinach, cauliflower, and onions. Husbands who liked their cabbage al dente could eat it after just 45 minutes in the pot, but it could sit there for up to two hours. Making a batch of doughnuts took 24 hours. A ham was another overnight project. Cooking might be done on a gas range, but more likely on a coal-burner.

If the challenge of cooking and cleaning was simply too much, the bride could phone Mrs. Maloney on Homer Street, "For a Maid, Nurse-girl, Cook, or any First-class Female Help, supplied on the shortest notice."

The 1913 Hi-Tech Household

Vancouver newlyweds in 1913 were evidently no market for theatre or films, and still less for outdoor activities or books. But they did not lack culture: "Your home will not be complete without music," warned Hicks & Lovick Piano. A piano would cost just $275 ($4,800 in our dollars), on easy terms, and a Victrola record player could be as little as $20 ($350). Or the bride could visit Waitt & Co.'s Talking Machine Parlors on Granville, where she could choose between Edison phonographs using cylinder recordings or revolutionary new discs.

Chances are she'd go for the high-tech choice every time. B.C. Electric offered a wide range of electrical appliances, including toasters and even ranges. Furniture and appliances were always marketed as "up to date." The price could be high: a 100-watt tungsten light bulb cost $1.50 ($26 in our dollars) and was guaranteed for only 60 days. But if the bride couldn't afford an electric washing machine, the Model Steam Laundry on West Third urged her: "Your Duds and Our Suds--Get Them Together." Prompt deliveries by horse-drawn wagon covered the whole city.

Dealing with Drugs

The Vancouver housewife had to worry about health matters. George Evans offered chiropractic services, G.W. Grimmett examined eyes, and Professor H.G. Clemens treated scalp diseases, made undetectable wigs, and also removed corns and bunions. The Winnitoba Private Nursing Home on Burrard looked after the new mother in "the great and highest crisis of her life," giving birth. Professor Stranack, a "mentalist" using "suggestive therapeutics" in his Richards Street office, offered permanent cures for drinking, smoking, and chewing-- without drugs or medicine.

The book also offered advice on treating cholera morbus ("30 drops of laudanum"), convulsions in children ("give warm water or a lobelia emetic"), and diarrhea ("a large cup of strong, hot tea, with sugar and milk"). The young wife got almost no advice on raising children, apart from recipes for dealing with their ailments. For colds and fever, the recipe called for potash, dilute nitro-muriatic acid, tincture of aconite, spirits of nitrate, tincture of henbane, and glycerine. Heidelberg Beer was "just what the doctor ordered."

If more sophisticated treatments were required, Knowlton's Drug Store, at the corner of Hastings and Carrall, was open all night to fill prescriptions. "The Modern and Safe Remedy for all Female Disorders" was Pond's Tampons, guaranteed to cure "inflammations, displacements, etc. etc." She could also make her own "woman's suppositories" out of zinc sulphate, alum, cocoa butter, white wax, oil of sweet almonds, and extract of henbane.

And if health care failed, Harron Brothers would look after the funeral "when you have not the heart to think of details."

It's striking to see how rarely emotion was expected to influence the bride's decisions. "The Real Home Keeper" is essentially an administrative guide for new managers. They would have to look after everything from wallpaper choices to their husbands' neckties (not to mention their children's convulsions), and their chief concerns would be saving money, keeping up family morale, and impressing guests. Would they find any personal reward in this role?

The Values of a Loyal British Subject

To ask such a question is to comment the historian's sin of "presentism"-- judging the past by our own standards. It was taken for granted that the young wife would rule her household, but only so she could better serve her husband and children, and the community. That service would be its own reward.

Nor was this just a convenient system rigged for the benefit of the husband. Less than 18 months after The Real Home Keeper appeared, many such husbands swarmed into recruiting offices to help fight World War I. Some did so just for three square meals and a place to sleep, or to escape some boring job (or wife). But most went out of a sense of duty, and endured years of misery, fear, and death in the trenches. It was simply what they had to do because of what they were: loyal subjects of the king. So were their wives.

Ninety years ago, the genteel world of bourgeois Vancouver was staggered by the depression and then almost depopulated by the war. Out of 55,000 British Columbians who served in the war, 26,000 came from Vancouver. With peace would come the pandemic of the Spanish flu.

Yet if their life was no perpetual honeymoon, Vancouverites' values endowed them with a spiritual toughness that got them through all that, and a second world war as well. Whether we, their descendants, could cope with such challenges is a question we should hope we never have to answer.

Crawford Kilian teaches at Capilano College.

Also today: Modern Marriage and Its Discontents

Tomorrow: Patricia Robertson on 'status wife envy.' And excerpts from The Bitch in the House and Bastards on the Couch.  [Tyee]

10  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • Earnest Canuck (not verified)

    7 years ago

    Good on you, Mr Kilian, for treating our ancestors (ancestresses?) with the respect they deserve. So much historo-journalism along these lines is sniggering, self-congratulatory "you've come a long way, baby" piffle -- as if, in an era where "cultural relativism" is highly valued, we're still unable to equate that with *chronological* relativism. These Edwardian Canadians were a strong, cohesive, ambitious people, worthy of our remembrance and study. Of course a century makes a difference, particularly in the role of women -- but was their place in society really more circumscribed than that of their "domineering" husbands, who took it as their duty to be slaughtered in European mud?// So convinced are we of the superiority and uniqueness of our own era -- this being a pathology that could only arise in a frankly-amnesiac society like ours -- that our own ancestors, when remembered at all, tend to be derided and dismissed like so many Neanderthals. Really good historical writing, like this, reminds us that today's shibboleths and manners are likely to seem bizarre to our descendants too. We can only hope the 22nd century also remembers us for such virtues as we possess, and makes note of the commonalities that link the Canadian people across the centuries.// Speaking of banalities. Will the people of 3004 finally have dispensed with the nutty, obviously-untrue observation that the Dominion is a "young" country? Hope so. Man, I hate that shit.

  • Coyote (not verified)

    7 years ago

    "So convinced are we of the superiority and uniqueness of our own ..." writes Earnest C., in a surprising piece, outside his usual mold. There MAY be hope for the guy yet. :-)

    And though I too found the piece interesting, my own reaction was, that it didn't much reflect the more hands on the washboard, make your own soap, and cook up a feast out of nothing at all, when company come calling kind of women I recall, from my early memory. The women authoring these rags, possibly even men, I don't know, like current day Chatelaine, are more often talking down a class, to a lower class of "dreaming" young women "wannabes". Like the authors of current day Chatelaine or Good Housekeeping, these women are anything but "housekeepers". They are "careers."

    And no, though where men have "jobs", women tend to have "careers" :-), there is nothing wrong with either, particularly.

    In those "grittier" days of my memory, there was very little sex outside of marriage. It's what provided a powerful "assist" that drove men and women to it. With no little "pill", the risks were too high for much "casual" sex. Whereas the later pill brought advantages for women, and blissfully, men, but also some disadvantages that flowed from a certain kind of "emotional disconnect". Still a bit of a problem, in my observation of the "young 'uns".

    My respect for those tough, brutally hard working women of that lower class of women of my memory however, (who may have read "The Real Home Keeper", if someone gave it to them), who were at the very centre of the family, bore all those children, and were multi-talented in ways women today have no idea-, remains undiminished. Nay, it has grown as I've got older, and am more inclined to look back.

    Barring a cataclysmic event upon human society however, or that capitalism actually does succeed in taking us all back to a social form somewhat closer to the 1930s, there is no going back. Nor should we want to, for across town from the life touted by the Real Home Keeper, there were other, darker sides to that world and time as well, however. Starvation, brutal work, long hours and precious little material reward, for men and women, and death from childbirth, all stood together like the Horsemen of The Apocolypse, hand in hand and much closer to the fire in the hearth, than I would certainly wish to go back to. And that particular scared, lonely look in the eyes of the women, whose husbands were away to war.

    Nope, I'll take my stand here, and make what changes are needed to sustain it, and fight to move forward, not backwards, like the Right Wing Goon Squads would have us do.

  • shirin (not verified)

    7 years ago

    My first reaction was that Dr. Laura is actually older than she looks and first put out her book on how a wife "should please a man" as a prequel that evidently failed. If truth be told, I don't know how well this book reflects the belief or the conduct of society from that era - just as a guy from the future who may come across Dr. Laura's witless words would think they actually reflect the diverse interests and attitudes of both men and women of today. I know my grandmother - who was a woman of the world - hardly would have picked up such matter - she was more into reading about cures and herbs as she was the local "witch doctor/medicine woman" - as I fondly called her. The woman could cure a belly ache in a snap and send my grandfather out to tailor and farm for their large brood of young guns. As was the custom - she was married young - arranged by parents - and had little thought of finding guidance on matrimonial etiquette from a book. Just as Martha Stewart Living is not the norm of today's households of our dwindling "traditional families", we can't really assess how true to our romanticised (or nightmarish - depending on your stance) view of yester years charms be by basing it on this little homemaker guide from 1913.

  • Coyote (not verified)

    7 years ago

    Yup, Shirin. Idealized chatter that is the stock in trade of this level of "literature", really does not tell us much about the real lives of most folks. Though it may be closer to those who live "idealized" upper class lives, I don't know.

    Did enjoy your little story about your "medicine woman" grandmother though. Here too, old women seemed to be the repository of such medicinal knowledge as existed before medicare, and the average person having affordable access to "modern" medicine. (Much of which is its own kind of voodoo.) And though many of their cures doubtless depended upon the well known placebo effect, it did and does still work a great deal of the time. (I still cure warts by getting my grandchildren to rub raw meat on it, and then take it out and bury it in the yard. Works every time.:-)

    Some though, was sheer nonsense, of course. My wifes mother and grandmother, by way of example, had her convinced that she couldn't bathe on her mensturation, or she might not ever stop flowing. Also, cherries and icecream together were poisonous. And these folks believed it to their dying days. (I still cannot get my wife to eat cherries and ice cream, even though I eat black cherry icecream all the time, to give some idea of the lingering power of those notions.) Of which there were many so-called Old Wive's tales, which oddly, one still hears every once in awhile in popular mythology, as though it is actually true.

    It's hard to believe, but that was all not so long ago in this society.

  • shirin (not verified)

    7 years ago

    Coyote - That's an unusual one - cherries and ice cream a bad mix? I've never heard of that one - the most common "no-no" was fish and dairy - not that I was inclined to go that way anyhow. However, I've learned now that quite a bit of the remedies that my medicine woman granny had some basis: cloves for toothe aches (I've learned it is one of the most potent natural anesthetics around and has anti-bacterial agents); tumeric and honey "milk chai" for a cold with a cough; concentrated peppermint oil (I've no idea where she got her stock - had to be diluted 1/100 and still was extremely potent) - these are a few cures that have some credence. My favourite though is her special "knot" she'd tie while muttering some "special words of prayer" when I lost something dear and was frantic to find. I was convinced that it worked - the my dear uncle mentioned: "Isn't it strange how you always find the thing you are looking for the last place you look." - It took some time (as I was 8 at the time)- for the essence of that truth to sink in. cheers - and may you never experience the life of an aristocrat and suffer the death of boredom after numbing senseless...

  • wellherewegoagain (not verified)

    7 years ago

    That was the time, that women like that has a nigger to do the serving and the washing and the cleaning and ironing. I just saw a picture today of such dinner event, whereas the servant (black of course, man) was behind the curtain and the angle showed just his arm stretched and the hand. He was serving a white male that today is 78 (he was 11 then). So as you can see, there are very few poictures of all the blacks that came to Canada and became servants of these women and men of yonder... for losing something they used to ask for sunlonguinho's help. It works all the time... Oh those black servants, so humble and unassuming... forgoten and disavowed of the sacrifice made that has affectd us all...

  • Crawford Kilian (not verified)

    7 years ago

    Many of the blacks who came to Canada did so as entrepreneurs and independent miners during the gold rush of the 1850s. See my book "Go Do Some Great Thing: The Black Pioneers of British Columbia" (Douglas & McIntyre, 1978) for details.

  • avicenna (not verified)

    7 years ago

    Why stop at "African Canadians"? there were also the chinese, the japanese, the indians (and I mean from India) - and of course, the first nations prior to all. The point being? Discrimination based on race or ethnicity is hardly a novel phenomenon of the "New World" - its been alive and kicking the globe over since the beginning of time - when the Neanderthals were beaten to a pulp by those brutal Homo Sapiens. A dastardly aggressive species that will surely make their own bed to sleep in. However, at least Canadians have attempted a level of "greater conscience" - even in BC - before the Campbell crew took over the state that is..

  • kent (not verified)

    7 years ago

    I can't beleive that menu, and we think we overeat. No wife, no matter how accomplished could have prepared that much food.

  • FiMaxwell (not verified)

    7 years ago

    I'm sure there was plenty of sex outside of marriage, Coyote. Probably why there were so many marriages... "Oops! I'm pregnant". I really have to disgree with you, Coyote (once again) that today's women aren't as tough or resourceful as women of yore. Really, Coyote, how many "women of today" do you know exactly? Do you hang out with us, talk with us, interact with us, KNOW us? "And that particularly scared, lonely look in the eyes of the women, whose husbands were away to war", Coyote writes, made me think of my friend Ericka, three months pregnant, who is in the US army and stationed at the DMZ in Korea, whose husband, a sniper, has just been sent to Baghdad, and who, as of two nights ago, could not reach her family in Florida (where they live in the midst of the hurricane's path). But Coyote- Erikca is very much a "woman of today" and extremely brave and hardworking, and tough and alone right now...

    • No best comments selected by an editor for this story yet. To see all comments, click the All Comments tab, above.
    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.