Opinion

Oil Spills Aren't a 'Not in My Backyard' Issue

Add to the BP Gulf disaster many oil nightmares you never hear about. Wherever they hit, we're all responsible.

By Kai Chan, 23 Jun 2010, TheTyee.ca

Oil-covered duck

Related

It's been two months since the BP Gulf oil disaster began. The spill has morphed from 'major', to the worst in U.S. history, and now to the worst environmental catastrophe the U.S. has ever faced. Lives have been lost, wildlife has died en masse, beaches and wetlands have been fouled, and livelihoods are threatened. Anger is thick as oil continues to pour into the Gulf of Mexico, despite BP's efforts to check the flow. Should we be concerned that such a spill could happen in Canada? Prime Minister Harper was quick to say 'no'.

Of course it could happen here. Big spills have happened in the past, despite apparently strong safeguards. U.S. regulations for oil drilling are not markedly different from Canadian ones. Do we honestly believe that American politicians said anything different when these major drilling projects were approved, after Exxon Valdez?

It could happen off the coast of Newfoundland, where the much greater depth (2.6 kilometres below the surface) of an offshore well planned by Chevron Canada would complicate containment efforts. The choppier waters and the presence of icebergs not only makes spills more likely -- they also slow the response to spills.

It could happen off the west coast of Canada, where Enbridge's proposed Northern Gateway project would mean twin pipelines from Alberta to Kitimat, B.C., and tankers to transport the oil over sea. Oil spills are one of the greatest risks facing globally-significant populations of seabirds and our iconic marine mammals of the Pacific, such as threatened sea otters and endangered killer whales.

It could happen in the Arctic, where cold temperatures and icy conditions complicate containment and mitigation efforts. There are plans to protect these sensitive and culturally significant ecosystems, including through marine protected areas (such as Tarium Niryutait), but current proposals would permit oil and gas activities. The same company responsible for the Gulf oil disaster has plans to drill in our Arctic waters -- and has repeatedly asked our government to relax safety regulations.

But it could happen anywhere.

TOP TEN OIL SPILLS DWARF EXXON VALDEZ MESS

Click here to see ten oil spills all massively larger than the Exxon Valdez -- and all smaller news stories, either because the ships were offshore, or dropped their toxic loads in less developed parts of the world. The Valdez spilled 10 million gallons off the coast of Alaska, the smallest spill in this top ten was four times larger.

Become aware of the global toll

If big oil spills are disasters when they happen here, they're also disasters when they happen elsewhere. Although Canada produces more oil than it consumes, it imports about a million barrels of oil per day from Algeria, Nigeria, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, and other countries. We benefit from the cheap prices on these imports that result from dangerous cost-cutting measures, so we are partly responsible for any spills that occur, even if we don't see the consequences.

And they do occur. In the past century, there have been more than 100 recorded oil spills on land and sea, about half of which have occurred in the past decade alone. Here are just three places where oil drilling mishaps have caused environmental devastation on a massive scale -- examples that never receive the level of reporting now focused on the Gulf catastrophe, but which qualify as catastrophic nonetheless.

In another Gulf of Mexico incident, the blowout of an oil well in the Bay of Campeche in 1979 released about double the amount of oil that's been gushing from the BP well -- and that's a conservative guess. As in BP's case, the blowout preventer had failed.

In 1991, an explosion caused a super-tanker to leak 260,000 tonnes of oil off the coast of Angola -- almost as much as BP's ruptured well, and about seven times the volume spilled by the Exxon Valdez in Alaska.

In the Niger Delta, spills on land from leaky pipes and burning gas flares continue to be a daily occurrence, causing acid rain and contaminating wetlands. Over the past 50 years, almost two million tonnes of oil have spilled into the sensitive wetlands and mangroves.

We must make corporations pay the real costs

As in other places, these spills are just the physical manifestation of the oil exploration in the region, which have also left legacies of corruption, violence, and bloodshed. The problem -- in the Gulf, Angola, Nigeria, and other places around the world -- is that oil companies don't pay the full costs of exploration and development of this public resource. When a big spill happens, birds, turtles, otters, and fish die by the hundreds and thousands, and food webs and ecological processes are disrupted for years. All this exacts large tolls on the people nearby who swim, fish, hunt, or simply enjoy watching animals or seeing healthy ecosystems. Oil companies rarely if ever bear these costs.

As a nation, Canada can ensure the highest practicable standards of oil production, and it can push for the same from exporting nations. The federal government can also ensure that the full costs of production are borne by those who profit, perhaps through strictly enforced regulations, higher accountability for safety standards, and taxation. Such policies would inherently stimulate development of clean energy alternatives, which would position Canada to realize sustained economic growth through competitive advantage in a post-fossil-fuel world.

When we hear about a major oil spill we can and should re-assess our own oil drilling and transportation practices, at home and abroad. An environmental disaster shouldn't have to be close to home before it registers on our moral barometers.  [Tyee]

10  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • mariner

    1 year ago

    GOVERNMENT RESPONSIBILITY AND ACCOUNTABILITY

    Government accountability and responsibility needs to be ensured otherwise diddly squat will happen.

    The likes of the Campbell government (who doesn't know the meaning of the words truth, honour, credibility and integrity) and the Harper government - who wants to continually cover everything up, do little but ensure profitability for their masters - the big multinational companies.

    Of course Harper will say NO if we let him - he works for Alberta oil concerns - not the people of Canada. Similar analogies hold true for Campbell in BC.

    Whilst the governments remain dishonest, then nothing will happen. While governments continually hide from the truth nothing will get done.

    We all need to make our respective governmentsmore accountable to the people they are supposed to represent - the people of Canada and British Columbia.

    Thank you

  • KWD

    1 year ago

    100 in the last century sounds a bit low …

    “In the past century, there have been more than 100 recorded oil spills on land and sea, about half of which have occurred in the past decade alone.”

    The US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration keeps a watchful eye on the oil drilling industry, and whether it’s personal injury, death, tanker accidents or blowouts, the statistics tell us a slightly different story.

    NOAA’s U.S. Minerals and Management Service claims there were 41 deaths and 302 injuries out of 1,443 oil-rig accidents from 2001 to 2007. And, the MMS also reports that there were 1565 oil spill incidents over a 30-year period.

    39 of those were well blowouts in the Gulf of Mexico. And, industry wide, the Deepwater Horizon calamity is not unique. There have been others, equally as serious.

    On December 1, 1970, Shell Oil Co. Platform 26 in the Gulf of Mexico exploded and caught fire. The platform included 22 production wells with a capacity of 15,000 barrels of crude oil per day. The explosion and subsequent fire killed four people and seriously burned 37 others. The spill wasn’t contained until May 1971.

    In 1979, the 2 mile deep IXTOC I exploratory well, located 600 miles south of Texas in the Gulf of Mexico … the Bay of Campeche incident referred to in this article … blew out spilling oil at a rate of 10,000 - 30,000 barrels per day until it was finally capped on March 23, 1980.

    On August 21, 2009 the Montara, a platform in the East Timor Sea, blew out releasing between 2000 to 3000 barrels per day. News reports at the time claimed the incident was one of the worst spills ever.

  • KWD

    1 year ago

    safety costs money

    As far as pushing for the highest practicable standards, or having oil companies pay the full cost is concerned, Canada, like the U$, is fighting a losing battle.

    The bottom line of those who profit most is suffering. It is increasingly being undermined by the ever-decreasing ratio of energy return on energy invested. The easy-to-get stuff is gone. Which is why deep-water drilling is taking place, why we’re boiling bitumen out of the tar sands and why it’s being done with little regard for environmental impact.

    The oil companies will cut costs wherever possible in order to keep profits flowing to shareholders. Raising the cost of petro products, in order to satisfy shareholder demands, will only work until the cumulative effect of low EROEI driven price increases reaches a threshold, over which consumers can no longer afford to pay.

    For a great many folks that threshold has been crossed which is why the oil giants are pushing for governments to relax safety regs.

  • Luck

    1 year ago

    OIL SPILLS

    [OFFENSIVE COMMENT REMOVED. -MODERATOR.]

    OIL IS HERE TO STAY. GOVERNMENTS CAN NOT WRAP THEIR MIND AROUND ALTERNATIVE FUEL SOURCES AS IT WOULD AFFECT THEIR STEADY INCOMES.

    OIL IS HERE SO LETS USE IT UNTIL IT DRIES UP THEN NO ONE IS OFFENDED.

    WE WAS REALLY HOPING THE YOUNG PEOPLE COMING UP WOULD SEE A LEADERSHIP ROLE TO PLAY.

    EVERYONE IS SMOKING DOPE AND HAVE NO DESIRE TO LEAD.

    GREAT, JUST ANOTHER LOST GENERATION.

    BRING ON THE RAPTURE.

  • soleprobe

    1 year ago

    Canada should not be importing oil

    Another mentally molesting article... many no longer have minds of their own but have been transformed into political automatons by the power of money.

    Imagine the citizens of Saudi Arabia importing oil from Canada and paying $5.20 for a gallon of gas while having to endure articles like this?

  • TTIOT

    1 year ago

    GOVERNMENT RESPONSIBILITY AND ACCOUNTABILITY???

    "Government accountability and responsibility needs to be ensured otherwise diddly squat will happen."
    "The likes of the Campbell government (who doesn't know the meaning of the words truth, honour, credibility and integrity)"
    " Whilst the governments remain dishonest, then nothing will happen. While governments continually hide from the truth nothing will get done."
    " We all need to make our respective governments more accountable to the people they are supposed to represent - the people of Canada and British Columbia."
    As a member of the "government", I really believe you should direct your comments directly to the source. The "government" is not just politicians!! People in the government do know and do uphold the meaning of " the words truth, honour, credibility and integrity" and the great majority of the "government are not "dishonest" nor do they "hide from the truth"
    We are your neighbors ,friends, brothers, sisters, mom, dads, uncles, cousins; we come from diverse ethnic, religious and cultural backgrounds. We do care and we do try and make things happen that improve our society and balance the economic and environmental needs.
    If we want to make " our respective governments more accountable to the people they are supposed to represent" then the next time we go to the voting poles we should vote from our minds, not tradition, not what we are fed by the media.
    Please remember that we live in a democratic country and the only people who can ensure" Government accountability and responsibility" is you and I and if you are not willing to use your democratic right then the only person at fault is you.
    Next election/recall initiative do not sit on your hands offer your hand to others through information and understanding

  • RickW

    1 year ago

    Overheard in a restaruant.....

    ....that the Gulf spill is a great NATURAL disaster.

    The oil industry's PR is beginning to work -- and we are doomed.

  • Okanagan Orchardist

    1 year ago

    Harper will deal with a Canadian oil spill.....

    It is not a matter of "if," but "when" we have a significant oil spill off either of our coasts. I expect that Harper (if unfortunately he is still our PM) will say what he said about the Air India crime, "This tragedy should not have happened."

  • RickW

    1 year ago

    Speaking of NIMBY...........

    http://www.ifitwasmyhome.com/

  • zalm

    1 year ago

    Nice one, RickW

    But I wonder why the sludge diagram isn't centred on Victoria where it belongs?

    Oh, wait a minnit....

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.