Opinion

Brace for the Security Games

To truly keep the peace, police must not overreact if Olympic protesters break the law.

By Michael Byers, 8 Feb 2010, TheTyee.ca

Police Brutality Protest Flickr

Protest against police brutality, Vancouver, August 2009. Photo by nofutureface from the Tyee Flickr pool.

Related

Just six of us flew from Salt Spring Island to Vancouver early last Friday morning. But it took eight government officials and a special security-screening bus to ensure that we did not pose a threat to the 2010 Olympic Winter Games.

Our luggage was x-rayed, we were sent through a metal detector and then checked again with a wand, patted down for good measure. A RCMP officer scrutinized the inside of the float plane with a flashlight before we climbed on board. Although it cost me just $87 to fly across the Georgia Strait, it cost the Canadian taxpayer thousands of dollars.

The temporary screening on Salt Spring Island is part of a nearly $1 billion effort intended to protect the heads of state, corporate executives and other assorted dignitaries descending on Vancouver for what could, as a result, be called the Security Games.

A decade of overreaction

Vancouver was selected as the host city less than two years after the 9-11 terrorist attacks on New York City and Washington, D.C. It was a period of fear and uncertainty, especially in the United States. The Bush administration overreacted, curtailing civil liberties at home while launching two wars and a program of torturing suspected terrorists abroad.

'CIVIL LIBERTIES AND THE 2010 WINTER OLYMPICS'

Click here to find the Civil Liberties Advisory Committee report.

The Canadian government reacted too, but not because it feared terrorist attacks on Canadian soil. Rather, the overriding concern was that Americans, perceiving Canada an easy point of entry for terrorists seeking to infiltrate the United States, would impose border controls that would damage Canada's export-based economy. Billions of dollars were spent on border security, and on increasing the size and effectiveness of the Canadian Forces, Royal Canadian Mounted Police and Canadian Security and Intelligence Service. The Department of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness was created to mirror the new Department of Homeland Security in the United States. Civil liberties also took a beating, with information on Canadian citizens like Maher Arar being shared freely with U.S. officials, and security certificates being used to detain non-citizens without charge.

It was in this context that the planning for the 2010 Winter Olympics took place, with the security services identifying every conceivable means by which terrorists might strike, and with politicians -- and through them, taxpayers -- willing to foot increasingly large bills.

Misplaced spending

The screening of float-plane commuters is just one of the resulting excesses. Scuba divers are patrolling Vancouver Harbour, guarding against a James Bond-style attack. Soldiers are camped in the backcountry near Whistler, on the lookout for terrorists on snowshoes or skis. Canadian Forces fighter jets are in the skies, ready to shoot down any hijacked plane, while frigates lurk offshore.

Many cities have an inflated sense of self-importance. Yet Vancouver, as a target for international terrorism, simply doesn't have the cachet of London, New York City or Washington, D.C. The 2010 World Cup in South Africa offers far greater global prominence in a less organized place.

Nor are terrorists stupid. They know about the nearly $1 billion security budget and are, as a result, more likely to strike elsewhere. Police forces across Canada will be operating on skeleton-staffs this month -- because thousands of their officers are working the Games.

Most tragically, hundreds of millions of dollars have been wasted that could instead have been spent addressing some clear and present problems -- including a homelessness crisis, underfunded healthcare system, and hundreds of earthquake-vulnerable schools.

It's too late to recoup the money, but it's not too late to prevent another, potentially negative consequence of the security overload.

For as the threat assessments have decreased -- to the point where even the Integrated Security Unit (ISU) admits the terrorist risk is "low" -- all the planning and spending has become a solution in search of a problem. As a result, the threat from domestic actors has been given greater prominence than it deserves.

Protests no surprise

We can expect protests during the Winter Olympics, since the presence of the global media offers a prime opportunity for opinions to be heard. Poverty, homelessness, the plight of indigenous peoples and Canada's record on climate change might figure among the protesters' concerns.

The first big protest will occur on Friday, Feb. 12, when thousands of people will march from the Vancouver Art Gallery to B.C. Place Stadium, just as ticket-holders arrive for the Opening Ceremony. The ceremony could be delayed, causing embarrassment for Olympic organizers.

But instead of being concerned, we should celebrate that our fellow citizens are able to express their views on the world stage. The rights to free assembly and peaceful protest are fundamental to democratic societies. Most people would agree; it's better to live in a free society, with all the messiness it entails, than in the stifling grasp of a police state where conformity is a survival skill.

Although most of the protestors will respect the law, a few might not. Nobody should be surprised if someone throws paint on the Olympic Clock, impedes traffic, breaks a window or unfurls a banner from a bridge. One does not encourage or excuse such acts by anticipating them.

The ISU will also have anticipated such acts, and that is them doing their job. Good planning can reduce the risk of an overreaction, whereby police in riot gear are sent to shut down an otherwise peaceful protest, or sweeping arrests are made in response to the actions of a few.

Primed to escalate?

But planning combined with the need to justify nearly $1 billion in spending can also lead to overestimating the risks. Bud Mercer, the RCMP officer who heads up the ISU, has taken to showing people a newsletter produced by a fringe group that encourages violent protest. Mercer has, in the past, been involved in heavy-handed action against First Nations, environmental and human rights protestors. In 1997, during an Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit on the University of British Columbia campus, he was among the RCMP officers who pepper-sprayed students protesting the presence of Indonesia President Suharto.

One quiet evening last spring, another group of RCMP officers arrested a handful of UBC students after they had built a bonfire out of a shipping pallet while protesting a construction project on campus. The officers also threatened to Taser the students -- a threat that carried particular menace in the aftermath of police brutality against Robert Dziekański, a 40-year-old Polish immigrant who died at Vancouver Airport after being Tasered five times by the RCMP.

If all is going well, the Vancouver Police Department will handle all citizen-police interactions within the borders of the City of Vancouver during the Olympics. The VPD has more experience than the RCMP in working with rather than against protestors, with peaceful protests occurring on an almost weekly basis throughout the year. But the VPD could call for help -- or the ISU could decide to intervene -- if some protestors behave illegally.

The presence of RCMP or even Canadian Forces personnel on the streets could trigger new protests, transforming a situation where few, if any, lives were at risk into a repeat of the Battle of Seattle in 1999.

Tell the police to keep cool

When Doug Ward of the Vancouver Sun asked Alissa Westergard-Thorpe of the Olympic Resistance Network whether any protestors would try to breach the security perimeter around B.C. Place Stadium on February 12, she replied: "That really depends on what type of police repression we face during the day. You know if we have a day where we're being beaten back by the police when we're simply trying to march, people's tempers can get high."

It is even possible that some of the police, having spent years anticipating and preparing for trouble, might be tempted to instigate it. At a NAFTA summit in Montebello in August 2007, undercover Quebec provincial police officers were exposed posing as protestors. The police were wearing bandanas over their faces, one of them was carrying a rock, and the whole thing was captured on video. Although the ISU has taken a number of steps to accommodate civil liberties concerns during the planning process, it only committed to not use agent provocateurs after sustained pressure was applied by the B.C. Civil Liberties Association.

The authorities must not be allowed to ramp up their security machine in response to small or isolated illegalities. They need to hear -- from politicians and citizens -- that we expect them to exercise the utmost restraint. We castigate, with good reason, the treatment of protesters in Iran and other countries. It would be unfortunate if the activities of a few police or soldiers were to tar Canada with the same brush.

Again, protests are about far more than security. At their core, they are about the relationship between citizens and the state. Those who wish to protest peacefully must be allowed to do so, regardless of what others might do.  [Tyee]

88  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • Dan the socialist

    2 years ago

    I just hope the protesters

    I just hope the protesters do not lower themselves to the same level like many of the police in this province.

  • leftofcentre

    2 years ago

    Yet another apologist for violence...

    The ORN has been constantly preaching "Riot 2010". That's pretty straight forward. Virtually every anti-olympic gathering of any size has resulted in an assault or act of vandalism.

    Anyone who participates in these acts is encouraging them. Byers is just another apologist for anti-Olympic violence.

  • BC Mary

    2 years ago

    Let the truth be told

    .

    There's a dark, destructive under-side to life in British Columbia. Organized crime groups total 135 in B.C., and "legally" the province has been stripped of its most valued public assets beginning in 2003 with BC Rail, then the crippling of BC Hydro, the confusion over who owns BC Ferries ... while anybody with a few $$ to spare can buy one of our rivers or poison a lake ...

    If the protesters (whether they march, publish or blog) will shine a bright light into those dark corners, we'll all be better for it.

  • alive

    2 years ago

    "free enterprise" at work!

    What is happening is just another proof that whenever government sponsors anything, predators arise trying to make money off it!

    When energy saving devices were the hot item and subsidized we saw the most ridiculous ideas capitalized by our government because they managed to fit inside the guidelines; not because they had any merit!

    Likewise the Olympics have created a whole new slew of parasites who try to make money off the event.

    We are back to motherhood and applepie here, who dares to say that we do not need all this security, so the parasites keep finding new ways to tap the public purse.

    Thia is not about safety but greediness!

  • Takuan

    2 years ago

    any protest in the street

    will be primarily a protest against a criminal provincial government. The games circus is secondary.

  • Takuan

    2 years ago

    and make no mistake:

    the cops WANT violence. They prefer to be feared since it means not only is it easier for them to bully, it also means no sane citizen will ever call upon them in time of trouble. Not a bad racket: the top gang with control of the streets, a steady pay cheque, full benefits and vacations, you get to torture and kill people and you know you can lie in court with impunity. The only way to make it better would be to never leave the station. Watch for that next.

  • Takuan

    2 years ago

  • southdeltawalker

    2 years ago

    Be there Friday Feb. 12 Art Gallery 3 P.M.

    The "Take Back Our City March" is on this Friday Feb 12 3 pm starting at the Art Gallery. It is to take back our City from the Olympic Corporate agenda and the selling of the Olympic's as "green".
    Sposored by the "2010 Welcoming Committee"-a coalition of community groups and individuals.
    http://2010welcoming.wordpress.com/

    Still not convinced the Olympics are a bad deal and why we need to be in the streets? See this excellent made in Vacouver recent video with already over 8000 hits-"All Out Against The 2010 Winter Olympics!":
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DoLQ6ThezTk

  • superjudge

    2 years ago

    Policing the "Canadian Way"

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gvpZc2veKyk

  • W Laurier

    2 years ago

    Protesting and Law

    The CAVE people can protest all they want, that is their legal and constitutional right. However, there are laws regarding disruption of events and damage of property. If the CAVE people do not like those laws, the Canadians among them can contact their Members of Parliament and have those laws changed to allow them to hurt and destroy.

    The CAVEers are spoiling for a fight and want to get roughed up so they can cry among themselves and vindicate their causes, whatever they are. Then they can call mommy to bail them out.

    So what else is new. Some are professional protesters but most are just kids out having a revolution during reading break at UBC.

  • cboo44

    2 years ago

    Scary Police-State Security ???

    "Our luggage was x-rayed, we were sent through a metal detector and then checked again with a wand, patted down for good measure. A RCMP officer scrutinized the inside of the floatplane with a flashlight before we climbed on board."

    Funny, I went through EXACTLY the same process going from Abbotsford to Calgary and back, two weeks ago! INCLUDING the inspection of the aircraft.
    Funny what the "conspiracy theorists" can discover when they get out of their island cave, isn't it? Anyone who has flown commercially in the past couple of years knows what the process is. Welcome to 2008, wonder how long the author will take to catch up to reality and 2010 ?
    Sheesh !

  • G West

    2 years ago

    cboo44

    Guess YOU haven't flown from Victoria Harbour to Vancouver Harbour either.

    Some of us used to THAT all the time.

    In fact, these stupid and very costly security procedures are putting businesses OUT OF BUSINESS because they are so very different from what the usual practices in these small planes are.

    Nothing new about this - it's been in the press since 2009...you might care to have a little look around.

    Abbotsford and Calgary are both major airports - harbour to harbour services aren't.

    No conspiracy theory - just some expensive and unpleasant 'facts' my friend.

  • pender paul

    2 years ago

    always money for the police

    Every time an F18 takes to the skies over southern BC it costs tens of thousands of dollars; the navy has been on patrol in the southern Gulf Islands for weeks now, lurking like sharks waiting for the kill; local RCMP have been reassigned to Vancouver and all for what? Probably to protect the Yanks who are likely the only real targets. Security alone will cost more than $1 billion--that's $4000 for each of the expected 250,000 visitors. I cannot believe how irresponsible the three levels of government are with our money. Shelters are needed for the homeless, low cost housing is needed for thousands of BC citizens, libraries require funding, schools are underfunded, the health care system is short of funds, roads throughout the province go without maintenance but we've got money to lavish on the police and the military. A pox on both their houses. Yes, I realize that they're only following orders, but I'm sure they're in at the trough just like the rest of the Olympic swine.

  • Intention Pure

    2 years ago

    Laurier

    Right, and I suppose you either don't have children or are one yourself, because your mommy's phone will be ringing off the hook for her to bail you out of your stupor. For your information, a major demographic of those who will protest the Owelimpics are the elderly. A massive segment of the population is aware of this corporate scam and the underlying plan to give cause to institute our very own Canadian "Patriot Act". Those who do not investigate and learn the truth about the Sept 11th false flag "history" are doomed to NOT BE A PART OF THE AWAKENING OF THE GENERAL POPULATION, and to see protesters as "professionals", or "kids who need their mom to bail them out".

    Please: WAKE UP and realize that the protesters will be PROTESTING FOREVER. The protesters are all kinds of teachers, librarians, social workers, nurses, families, scientists, authors, politicians, ecological defenders, and human rights defenders. We are entering a new era of control exercised by the global controlling elite (New World Order). The Owelimpic protests are only the beginning of the protests that you will see, and likely join, if you do some studying.

  • W Laurier

    2 years ago

    Ohhhh

    I do have children and I highly doubt I will ever be CAVE. I am really looking forward to the revolution. Any schedule for the event?

  • Takuan

    2 years ago

  • bfearn

    2 years ago

    "leftofcentre"...

    tells us that, "The ORN has been constantly preaching "Riot 2010". That's pretty straight forward. Virtually every anti-olympic gathering of any size has resulted in an assault or act of vandalism."

    "leftofcentre" has got to be a RCMP agitator. As a 66 year old guy I attended an ORN meeting that was attended by 53 concerned citizens, mostly young people. They never asked me if I was a cop, they have no security and virtually no money. They went through their plans and there was nothing that even suggested violence. In fact the only violence that was briefly mentioned was police violence. The majority of them spoke of their concern that so much was being spent on games when there are so many more serious issues. For "leftofcentre" to suggest that the ORN is a violent group is manifestly wrong.

  • soleprobe

    2 years ago

    THE AWAKENING OF THE GENERAL POPULATION

    The elitists who are financing and controlling the takeover of Canada and enslavement of its citizenry along with the high ranking puppets are fairly hidden and/or well protected if a revolution really brakes out, I mean people are really angry on the ground, and anger that’s been developing for many years and the fat cats will be well protected from their wrath if it finally breaks out.

    As for the minions, those who promote their scams, cover up their crimes…. they know who they are… the media, the CEOs, executive directors, authors, editors, journalists, anchors, phony environmentalists and scientists, the so-called “experts” they throw in front of the citizens… all those lying smiley faces on the tube, all those lying voices on the radio, all those lying authors and editors of various publications…. If I were one of them I’d be startin to get a little nervous right now. I mean everybody knows their names, where they live, what they look like because they just love to put themselves in print, in front of cameras talking about themselves and even their families…. I sure wouldn’t want to be one of them if the masses of awakened citizens boiling with rabid rage start a revolution because there won’t be any place for them to hide.

  • carfreed

    2 years ago

    have fun

    music, creativity and joy in solidarity make for better protests.
    i have never enjoyed the presence of the black bloc.
    can't they just beat on drums,or dance out their feelings.?
    It's so disappointing when young men join up for the sake of confrontation.
    How about they hold their own resistance day.

  • demotto

    2 years ago

    Do ya think

    Do ya think he might know something http://abcnews.go.com/Sports/wirestory?id=9740761&page=2

  • morechatter

    2 years ago

    All will not go well with the Olympics

    I do believe you can count on it especially since the country is running around carrying the Calderon! It is personified evil where big corporations come in and take the life out of communities and cities with the help of corporate sponsored politicians hoping to cash in. I lite my Calderon each day with prayers to the Mighty Zeus, Ruler of Mount Olympus,
    Known by Many Names,
    Lord of the Sky,
    Rain-God, Cloud-Gatherer,
    And Zeus of the Thunderbolt.
    The Mighty Zeus, the Greek god known
    also as the Roman god Jupiter or Jove with the belief this event meets its demise as it takes the life out of cities and its people and leaves the young, sick and vulnerable for dead.
    BC, a cash strapped province that has turned over the public purse for the Olympic event while leaving citizens in crisis. It is a cold and callous event that is run on spin and public funds as big business takes hostage of a province and leaves it people for not. What will it take to stop the Olympics? Greece held the Olympics with hopes of getting out of a deficit and now they have gone bust. BC is next. How will the countries and their cities be able to justify selling out to big business as cities go belly up as Zeus puts a damper on the Olympics.

  • jimgde

    2 years ago

    a bit hyperbolic?

    "free society" vs. "the stifling grasp of a police state, where conformity is a survival skill"? this kind of exaggerated dichotomy is precisely the type of antagonism that leads to confrontation, used by both 'sides'. it also absolves the speaker from responsibility for what is more or less expected to happen, if the 'other side' doesn't tone it down.

  • mopled

    2 years ago

    All these troops are not about protestors

    FALSE FLAG VANCOUVER 2010 OLYMPICS

    "The Olympics is coming to town and is being used as a pretext to installing a complex, Orwellian-style big brother surveillance society that will endure long after the Olympics has left town with billions of dollars of Canadian taxpayer's money, regardless of whether the people that are paying for the big circus can afford to see the events, even live in the lower mainland where the events will be staged and whether or not they have anything to say about the removal of their most important rights."

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CPt89SBqBJA&feature=related

  • Frank

    2 years ago

    leftofcentre

    is an apologist for police brutality.

    In his world, Polish immigrants, illegally parked seniors, drunk kidss in northern BC and others deserve the torture and death they receive at the hands of the police.

  • Mia

    2 years ago

    Why is Canada's Olympics under occupation

    by 15,000 foreign troops, pray tell? This is not simply a police issue. Rights are usually not taken. They are often given away.

  • Mia

    2 years ago

    KATRINA DEJA VU? OLYMPIC CLEAN UP TIME?

    Is there anyone who might be able to research and find a list of those structures in Vancouver which are slated for demolition in the not too distant future? Just curious. Why? Well....
    There was such a list on hand before Katrina and before 9/11.
    It seems that the WTC towers were on it. That may be why owner Larry Silverstein, the guy who collected multi millions in insurance from the 9/11 event, slipped up when he said on that PBS show that "they" decided to "PULL" W7, a demo industry term, when they were talking about why tower W7 came down as well. And that must be why the demolition of W7 was announced as "news" by a BBC reporter while it still stood standing behind her, yet she stated this news as as fait accompli demolished tower, but bungled it when she announced 23 minutes before it even occurred, that it had been "destroyed".

  • Mia

    2 years ago

    Disaster Capitalism

    .... is Naomi Klein's theory, not mine.

  • OhCanada

    2 years ago

    Animal Farm in full view

    A true event of George Orwell's book "Animal Farm" with sport caught in the middle.

    If you haven’t read the book this one you must. His book Animal Farm is a critical view on how ideas and situations destroy the welfare of a free society. Couldn’t be better paralleled with the Olympics as it grew to be.

    The pigs (i.e. IOC, politicians, greedy corporations) use the dogs (police, military) to protect themselves and the sheep (gullible public) to pay for everything.
    I have never had the inclination to be a pig, a dog or a sheep although I have to pay as I’m a taxpayer like anybody else.

    I haven’t figured what I am but I tend to like the rabbits.

  • Mia

    2 years ago

    CAMERAS CAMERAS, EVERYWHERE:

    SUSPECT NATION
    Suspect Nation

    How is information being collected? Could new identity technology actually put at risk the very people it seeks to protect? Since Tony Blair's New Labour government came to power in 1997, the UK civil liberties landscape has changed dramatically. ASBOs were introduced by Section 1 of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 and first used in 1999. The right to remain silent is no longer universal. Our right to privacy, free from interception of communications has been severely curtailed. The ability to travel without surveillance (or those details of our journeys being retained) has disappeared. Indeed, as Henry Porter (the Observer journalist famous for his recent email clash with Tony Blair over the paring down of civil liberties) reveals in this unsettling film, our movements are being watched, and recorded, more than ever before.

    Suspect Nation HQ (Part 1/5)
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1gHsXZMWwVw

    Suspect Nation HQ (Part 2/5)
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5wybX5kWFgs

    Suspect Nation HQ (Part 3/5)
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Ts55FXwhXw

    Suspect Nation HQ (Part 4/5)
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wlQ7MB9LOuw

    Suspect Nation HQ (Part 5/5)
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ibCpDONbHmc

  • worldofplenty

    2 years ago

    is this the best protest article the tyee can do???

    i would expect something more. what is the opportunity cost of 6 to 10 billion dollars? what good we could have done with that and we let it all go down the toilet? i am in the level of journalism here, how about an article about the anti olympic protester that was not let into canada?

    these articles are so tame, almost proofread by vanoc to not be offensive.

  • VivianLea Doubt

    2 years ago

    careful!

    The rabbits are next...

  • Yammer

    2 years ago

    Insecurity is not a democratic value

    I don't mind the Security Games, as long as the security is relatively unobtrusive, permits peaceful protest, and actually works.

    Compared to the Insecurity Games (e.g. Munich) it would be vastly preferable, don't you think?

    This article makes other bizarre assertions:

    1) That the security is meant to protect heads of state and corporate leaders.

    Missing anyone there? How about the athletes and the audience?

    2) Vancouver does not have the cachet of cities like New York and London, to terrorists

    If the author can truly read the minds of terrorists, shouldn't he be offering his invaluable paranormal abilities to the police?

    3) Terrorists likely know about the $1B security budget and are therefore likely to strike elsewhere.

    So, we should spend only enough to ensure that the terrorists feel confident to strike here? What a fascinating theory.

  • make_up_another...

    2 years ago

    Better you than me!

    I'm just glad that, living in the GTA, Toronto never got the summer games. Traffic is bad enough here thank you.

    Of course we do have the misfortune...er privilege of hosting the Pan Am games in 2015. Oh well, perhaps by then we'll just be to broke to put them on.

    On a random note, did you ever notice the similarity between the Olympic opening ceremonies and Nazi pageantry? It's not a coincidence. That explains why despotic countries love the Olympics.

  • Mia

    2 years ago

    IN THE USA

    ...war is not permitted to be preemptive, under the Constitution. Hence there has been a historically recurring creation of the appearance of being attacked from without, used politically in order to justify all manner of profitable aggression against the enemy, any so called outsider pr domestic "enemy", invariably a government identified "enemy", albeit only after the fact. Few Canadians seem to be asking how our rights have been so easily preemptively removed BEFORE the Olympics. Maybe that is because Canada is a country defined by common sense, not paranoia. The catch is that Canadians tend to not ask soon enough the same kinds of questions about their most basic civil liberties & rights. Sure Canadians tend to see themselves as more realistic & less fear based than many Americans when it comes to any political orchestration of panic for political gain. Harper, in this sense, is more Texan than Canadian. However, when Canadian people are too docile & complacent, they can sometimes comply too soon or too readily, or ask too few questions. When any citizen becomes afraid of whatever they are told by the government to fear, while not fearing the power of government itself, they soon lose their rights. Do Canadians KNOW they have the right to not have the US military in our harbours % on our streets? That we have the right to not have Parliament prorogued during this kind of "occupation" by foreign troops?

  • Mia

    2 years ago

    PROPAGANDA AS "ENTERTAINMENT"

    Beyonce Grammy Performance 2010

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=773spHLUAsE

  • G West

    2 years ago

    Absurd waste of time and money - a prediction

    There is absolutely no potential for a major terrorist attack on Vancouver - only in the fevered minds of self-important politicians and their security lackeys - who, more and more, seem to suffer from a bizarre form of dissociative fugue state.

    This money, the forces' and police time, are being utterly wasted...as the event will no doubt prove.

  • interactive

    2 years ago

    Gimme a Break...

    For heaven's sake buddy Mr. Civil Liberties Michael Byers...
    You don't think that the history of the Olympics and the death and violence surounding them, are not cause to keep these international competitors safe!
    Cast your "blinders-on" mind back to Munich, Salt Lake City etc etc.
    ANYTHING can happen , even in your safe little Saltspring/Vancouver area backyard. Any idiot can come along, slip past security and cause serious trouble. Everyone enjoys the idea of rights but Civil liberties types to the far left only think of the small picture and how there little day was affected ie the float plane.
    Vancouver could most deffinately be a target. Why not?
    Stranger things have happened when you have humans running the earth. No one can be trusted. Not in this day and age or ever for that matter.

    BTW...Our health Care system is NOT UNDERFUNDED!!! Our SCHOOL SYSTEM is. Look up your stats before you frape up the left masses Michael. And Plight of indegionous people??? gimme a break. There is no PLIGHT. They have tons of money! Look at Park Royal Mall. Look at the large tracks of prime real estate all over this city. Look at the hideous digital signs gracing our bridges and the Sea to Sky Hwy. The problem is, the indegionous people don't take care of their own. They make tons of money in numerous ways, the least of which is gambling but they treat their brothers like dirt. They take and then take again, but forget their own.

  • Takuan

    2 years ago

    interesting..,

    judging by the manipulated presse's articles we have both VANOC and the Fiberals running scared.

  • biscotti

    2 years ago

    More tiramisu please!

    After reading the discussions following Bob Mackin’s “Why This Is Vancouver's Last Super Spectacle”, Geoff Dembicki’s “Who Are the 2010 Protesters?” & “Olympics Well Worth It: Harcourt” and now Michael Byers’ “Brace for the Security Games”, I’m left wondering what these protests will achieve.

    As someone living in BC's boonies where school closures and the withdrawal of services are the painful counterpoint to the big fiesta going on at the coast, and someone who’s been active resisting BC Liberal policies, I deplore the lavish overspending, hoopla and security arrangements. Obscene. However, I am skeptical of some aspects of the Games protests. (Maybe I’m missing some brilliant organizing details because I live too far north.)

    Steve Burgess made an interesting comment following the “Who Are the 2010 Protesters?” piece:

    ‘So really, the objection isn't just to the Olympics--it's to any activity at all. Hypothetically it could be "No new Prince George post office on stolen native land;" or "No new traffic light in Kitimat on stolen native land:" etc.’

    Too funny! If someone picked up on this, I missed it. But I long for a rigorous critique of the sloganeering and romanticism of the Left.

    I appreciate Zalm’s honesty in naming revenge as an ingredient: “...revenge tastes sweet, and this cold revenge sweeter than tiramisu with an Amaretto chaser!” And while I share Zalm’s fondness for tiramisu, I want to hear more ideas about what comes after revenge.

    (Not that this is Zalm’s only motivation, and he or she is one of the few posters to document in detail their critique of the games. And if I did all the volunteering that they do for the benefit of others while the government slashed funding, I’d want to march with you on Friday.)

    However, I worry that much of the Left (whatever that is) is stuck reacting to the elite agenda instead of writing its own script.

    No doubt the authorities are anticipating many of the protest actions with their high security, infiltration, eavesdropping, etc. Perhaps they will aim for containment; hopefully they won’t go nuts. But no doubt they plan to ride it out, just like they ride out day-long protests at the Legislature. People get bored or tired or go home and give up. The authorities carry on with their plans.

    Is trying to counteract a big TV spectacle with an alternative TV spectacle just playing the Liberal-VANOC-IOC-Harper game? Sure, symbolic protests and disruption have their place, and it’s nice to let off steam, but isn’t the system is more vulnerable to economic action, like strikes, economic blockades and occupations? And if so, what's needed to organize, build and exert that kind of pressure on the government?

    This is a debate I would like to see at the Tyee.

  • samuidave (not verified)

    2 years ago

    The impetus of ignorance

    is there anything more to say?

  • dorothy

    2 years ago

    To the operator

    This is not an entry into this blog, but I don't know where else to put it!

    I just sat and wrote a letter to another blog, put a lot of thought and work into it, and found, when I was done, that it did not get posted, because the discussion had been ended while I was typing. I see this as a serious shortfall in the code. It should not be possible to get an open text field and then not get your letter posted. Gives a nasty feeling of being burned. I will not again trust enough to type into a text field and run the risk of losing my work, but will always cut and paste from word. You can put up with the weird code differences that will result. You asked for it.

  • robertjb2

    2 years ago

    " The security games"

    A terrorist incident is unlikely. The likelihood of the RCMP screwing up yet one more time is imminent. Let's hope these turkeys don't embarrass us yet another time. Their presence at these games is probationary if they screw up they don't get a new contract. Send them back to Ottawa.

  • John Greg

    2 years ago

    dorothy, try Notepad

    Try writing your comment in Notepad, and then pasting it in place. It works just fine, and you don't have to worry about bogus MS code fritzing up the works.

  • BC Boy

    2 years ago

    What stupid attitude from the protestors!!

    "You know if we have a day where we're being beaten back by the police when we're simply trying to march, people's tempers can get high."

    Well if the protestors see a barricade, it means that's as far as they are allowed to go. Try to accept the fact that the majority of citizens want to enjoy the Games Events in peace, not have to put up with disruptions.

    If the protestors thik they are above the law and represent the majority of all citizens they are seriously wrong.

    W.Laurier is right. The protsters are spoiling for a fight, will try to pas through police lines because they want to, not because the police are provocative. Remember, who was it that rocked the fence and tried to go through it at APEC at UBC? It was not the cops.

    Take the energy in protesting and put it to good use. Protest the drug dealing vermin in the downtown east side and do what you can to get rid of them. The protestors would earn alot more credibility if they did.

  • Frank

    2 years ago

    BC Boy

    Beats the same drum over and over, too bad he's not willing to do himself what he thinks others should do.

    After all, according to him it takes only a few dozen people of limited means to cure poverty in BC. Too bad he doesn't want to be one of them.

  • Takuan

    2 years ago

  • zalm

    2 years ago

    Biscotti

    "Is trying to counteract a big TV spectacle with an alternative TV spectacle just playing the Liberal-VANOC-IOC-Harper game?"

    Yes. But it's what Maurice Cardinal has always encouraged us to do. He's insisted that we have definite aims and goals, and not everyone can be said to have definite aims and goals that will make sense to the media, but that's no reason not to try. None of us is perfect. (My emphasis different than Wilth's and self-of-centred's.)

    The important thing is not to be manipulated by that spectacle into doing things you hadn't planned on doing, such as crashing security fences at the Owe-limp-ics. So after the obligatory marches for the media, I'll be pushing around my dirty shopping cart filled with bottles and plastic bags in by grubbiest clothes and Charlie Chaplin shoes accompanied by one other friend with a cart, and a third friend with a video camera to keep us safe, or put our fates on the 11 o'clock news, whichever. I'll help make my own street theatre wherever the tourists and the athletes are. And yes, they are starting to arrive in my end of town, west Mt. Pleasant.

    "Welcome, world! Have we ever got a surprise for you tonight! Show 'em what we have for our guests tonight, Vanna....."

  • BC Boy

    2 years ago

    Well Frank..its the protestors that are complaining.

    Well Frank, nice comments bud, but it is the protestors that are complaining and equating the Olypmics to homelessness. So, the protestors would win over alot more support if they put their energies where their complaining is. And just how many of these disruptive protestors actually do get out there to clean out the downtown east side of the drug dealers? Not many, because the drug dealers are still there.

    If the protestors are complaining about homelessness and so forth, why not have them fix the problem themselves??

  • margot

    2 years ago

    security issues

    So millions will never be found again, lost on bogus event tickets, and then there's the Norwegian Star, with no news on refunds. And only one report of thousands paid to rent a house that doesn't exist.

    Stay tuned. More, more, more, for sure.

    Mia, the Beyonce video was outrageous, thank you, I couldn't watch more than a few seconds, but how spot on.

    Mouthies, hoodies, people in planes, seem to be the chosen enemies. People who eat garlic. This is a billion plus well spent.

    Coca Cola is the perfect sponsor, check out David
    Rovics singing Coke is the drink of the death squads.

    The press seems to have stopped mention of Mt Washington as the perfect place to hold the Cypress events, for lack of snow. But there's the welcome addition of information suggesting that dry ice is being used instead of chemicals, read ammonium nitrate --- not because two tonnes are missing and it's the explosive of choice for "cheap" people, but because of its ultra fertilizing effect on streams and creeks, really worrying.

    Is anyone documenting the ticket and accommodation scams? Is "security" doing anything about this?

    In the same vein, Athens was blackmailed. Get the Nov 17th gang or no Olympics, after most of the money had been spent. (Nov 17 73, massacre of students, by US backed military gov't installed at the expense of thousands of people, to get military bases and a port in Greece.) Greek people were furious but broke, even more broke now.

    Amazing movie about prep for the Chinese Olympics, The old Barber. Terrible, beautiful, terrible, three hankies.

    The greedy are so fun to drink with at the club.

  • zalm

    2 years ago

    LOL!!!

    "Try to accept the fact that the majority of citizens want to enjoy the Games Events in peace, not have to put up with disruptions."

    Peace? Peace? BCBoy smoking too much BCBud?

    If I had my sense of humour left after today's nonsense, I'd be ROTFLMAO at this nonsense, what with a foreign film crew shutting the valve on a noisy condensate line at the hospital yesterday without notice or permission, blowing pump seals and plugging off the heat to three buildings overnight until we finally found it and figured out what happened this morning. Sirens everywhere from downtown to 41st, from noon til 9:00 pm. Helicopters and jet overflights pretty much steady all day, and then continuously in the evening to the accompanying explosions. Some bimbo with the IQ of a house plant shining his toy laser off the windows of the Tower. Confused patients in CP demanding to know what's going on and wondering why they can't keep their window vents open without the sound of WW III assaulting them from without.

    ...and the Owe-limp-ics haven't even started yet!

    All that with news of three more positions lost on Friday as the health authorities continue to reorganize.

    And we operations people can't escape "because we're needed in case of emergency", even while maintenance takes whatever holiday they can.

    GOD: You get a choice today - hard times or bubble gum.
    ZALM: Bubble gum.
    GOD: I'm fresh out. Bend over.

    ...sigh.

  • biscotti

    2 years ago

    your own street theatre

    ...sounds great - nice idea to do Chaplin ;-)
    What's the film where he waves his handkerchief (probably red) and a crowd of rabble rousers starts to form behind him?

  • margot

    2 years ago

    hey Michael,

    And Michael, speaking of security, I'd really like to know if you still don't think Caspian Sea oil and gas, and the TAPI pipeline, are why Canadian troops are involved in the Afghanistan debacle.

    On Almanac, a few years ago, you dismissed this idea on the grounds that the region where Canadians were handing pencils to children is much too unstable for any such pipeline. So it was all about pencils?

    Do you remember exactly what you said? And what's your take on this now?

  • Frank

    2 years ago

    BC Boy

    "it is the protestors that are complaining and equating the Olypmics to homelessness."

    You're confused, the protesters don't think the Olympics and homelessness is the same thing at all.

    "So, the protestors would win over alot more support if they put their energies where their complaining is."

    And YOU and Campbell would win over a lot more support if over the last 9 years you had put your energy into fixing real problems instead of blowing the excess wealth of the province on a party that most can't afford to even attend.

    "And just how many of these disruptive protestors actually do get out there to clean out the downtown east side of the drug dealers? Not many, because the drug dealers are still there."

    Are you demanding the protesters assault drug dealers? Calling for violent acts on the Tyee is verboten, check your commenting guidelines.

    Anyway, fact is, its your side that has decided to spend a billion dollars on police so why is it all of those police can't do what you want protesters to do?

    I mean seriously, think of how illogical that is. You just spent a billion dollars on police yet you don't have the money to do any policing in the downtown eastside and so instead you call for left-wing citizens to take the law into their own hands and attack people that have not been convicted or even accused of a crime. Gee, I wonder if the citizens being attacked might sue? You think?

    "If the protestors are complaining about homelessness and so forth, why not have them fix the problem themselves??"

    Because maybe the problem is far bigger than their meager resources could possibly fix? After all, your side does claim there's very few of them and that they should get a job.

    Here's a thought, send all the police home and give the billion dollars to the protesters to give out to poor people in BC. I bet they'd be so busy helping people they wouldn't protest.

    But I know you'd rather spend the money on police than the poor.

  • dehav

    2 years ago

    why not have security games at same time?

    Vanoc should have arranged to have the canadian police games in vancouver as well. With all the cops standing around these days the activities would keep the police on their game.

  • BC Boy

    2 years ago

    Still doesn;t get it.

    "You're confused, the protesters don't think the Olympics and homelessness is the same thing at all. "

    Intersting - so why all the whining and complaining that the Olympics are taking away from the homeless?? It's been a major issue on the protestor side. Read their positions, it's a basic
    position of the ORN.

    "And YOU and Campbell would win over a lot more support if over the last 9 years you had put your energy into fixing real problems instead of blowing the excess wealth of the province on a party that most can't afford to even attend"

    Sure and where was the NDP for the 10 years of 1991 to 2001 where they had a much easier chance to
    fix the problems and they did not? As a party for not afford to even attend, there are many events for free.

    Are you demanding the protesters assault drug dealers? Calling for violent acts on the Tyee is verboten, check your commenting guidelines.

    Well is it equally right to disrupt events? Calling for violent acts (disrupting events) is
    verboten. Check your commenting guidelines.

    "Anyway, fact is, its your side that has decided to spend a billion dollars on police so why is it all of those police can't do what you want protesters to do?"

    and that is?

    I mean seriously, think of how illogical that is. You just spent a billion dollars on police yet you don't have the money to do any policing in the downtown eastside and so instead you call for left-wing citizens to take the law into their own hands and attack people that have not been convicted or even accused of a crime. "

    The last time anyone looked, drug dealing on the street is a crime. It's called trafficing.

  • Dr Alexander

    2 years ago

    False Flag operation for Vancouver

    I had thought about that also, as have a few posters here. The problem is that Vancouver is still small potatoes in the world and the only benefit of a false flag would be to scare Canadians into accepting a North American Security Perimeter.

    After having lived in Europe and elsewhere for a number of years, Vancouver is quite insignificant. Heck, it is insignificant to most Canadians east of the Rockies. Those agencies that have historically been involved in false flag activities don't want to dip into the well too often as the nature of the operation becomes obvious (e.g. Madrid bombings) and dragging out the spectre of a guy who has been dead for years (bin Laden) only adds ridicule to the intended massaging of public opinion. On top of that, Vancouver and Canada has no real enemies and I have not seen or heard the usual propaganda required to prime people to identify with the chosen enemy. So, the usual agencies are keeping their powder dry for the real gem. London 2012.

    After all, they already had a practice for it with 7/7.

  • Frank

    2 years ago

    BC Boy

    Surely to god you can't be this bad at comprehending the written word?

    I will "sesame-street" it for you :

    For the fifth time, the NDP record on combating homelessness and poverty is better than the BC Liberal record. The BC Libs have led the country on child poverty for seven years in a row. There have been more homeless on the streets of BC in the last 9 years than there were under the NDP.

    "and that is?"

    You don't recall what you said in your last post? Since your memory is failing you could try going back to your last post and re-reading it. What you asked for was that protesters be used on drug dealers.

    "The last time anyone looked, drug dealing on the street is a crime. It's called trafficing."

    Then why do you need protesters? Why not use the billion dollars you just spent on police to arrest them? How much do you need to arrest drug dealers? Two billion? Three billion?

    "Intersting - so why all the whining and complaining that the Olympics are taking away from the homeless??"

    Because the money spent on security alone for the Games would have done a lot more good if spent on social priorities.

    "As a party for not afford to even attend, there are many events for free."

    (sigh) I have trouble believing your claim you're the head of a corporation when your grammar and spelling (not to mention your memory and reading comprehension) are this atrocious.

  • realisticman

    2 years ago

    We need some very large mental hospitals

    The Province
    May 6, 2009

    They are psychotic, they are drug-addicted and they are homeless.

    Doctors, scientists, advocates and those working the streets and hotel rooms of the Downtown Eastside say those are the people falling through a large and widening crack in a mental-health system that is not able to serve the people who need the care the most.

    Mark Smith, executive director of RainCity Housing and Support Society, figures almost the entire homeless population in the Downtown Eastside -- which he believes numbers between 600 and 1,100 -- have mental-health issues and use drugs.

    "Those are the ones. Those are the ones gesticulating. Those are the ones that motorists slow down to look at. Those are the ones that wander into traffic. Those are the visible homeless," said Smith.

  • Jerry Munro

    2 years ago

    Where the blame really lies...

    All the Rightist inferences here, oblique and otherwise, to the 911 world reality as justification for the security regime increasingly being installed in this country as well, by their ruling class masters, they are in largely to blame for as themselves. It is they who have sought, and continue, to place this country in harms way by standing as too close and intimately to the US militarism that has long been seeking world domination, particularly in the Middle East. They have by so doing, taken on Amerika's well deserved enemies as our own.

    It is this same US militarism and its Empire ambitions that brought 9-11 down upon themselves in the first place. ( Of which there is growing recognition.) It was/is to be expected, no less than did the early "colonial Americans" against the British, that the Arab peoples would resist foreign attempts, by any means possible to them, to impose US imperialist controls and regimes upon them.

    And then our own militarists and political/economic US Empire Loyalists, failing to understand this fundamental fly in the ointment of the modern world and its geopolitics, or not giving a rat's ass, picked this very moment to drop their drawers and take up the US inspired notion of an "economic union" with them. And as part of this Americanization vision for Canada's future, to join, serve and ingratiate themselves to the US Empire cause in the Middle East, especially Afghanistan.

    This post 911 world of which they speak so much, in justifying this security regime's imposition on all of us, they are themselves to blame for. Just as they are as well, the decision of late capitalist provincial and national governments, Liberal and Conservative (fascist) to spend billions of dollars on a touristy sports extravaganza. over the needs of "the people" and the nation. Better they had chosen instead affordable housing construction jobs of more lasting benefit, (and stricter immigration controls) and recovering our natural resources from foreign control as part of a more rounded economic and truly "green" development of this country.

    Did you not think that people would notice? And begin to hunt you down and harass you?

    It is just beginning you wingnuts, and it is yourselves you have to thank/blame for this.

  • Jerry Munro

    2 years ago

    The end logic of its natural development...

    "They are psychotic, they are drug-addicted and they are homeless.
    Doctors, scientists, advocates and those working the streets and hotel rooms of the Downtown Eastside say those are the people falling through a large and widening crack in a mental-health system that is not able to serve the people who need the care the most." realisticman

    And this as well, is the world these same Rightists and their Liberal-Conservative (fascist/corporatist) Regimes have brought down upon us, as a consequence of the "Restraint Budget Regimes" of the late 70s and since, with their closing of mental and other hospitals. It is they who have led the gutting of the medical system, which they now use as their justification for creating a new "privatized" care system, so-called. Which system is to be based on affordability, and/or instead of subsidizing a "publicly owned" medical system such as was, to now "subsidize", as in provide corporate welfare support to a "private owned" system instead.

    They have found a way, again, around an enviable public owned and serviced system, to make it just another trough at which the pigs of the corporate establishment can feed further their fill, at the public's expense. It is another one of their many hands going through our collective wallet.

    It's called capitalism kiddies, and is the end logic of its natural development.

  • Takuan

    2 years ago

    "cold , aggressive and over-competitive"

    and just wait to see what they are saying after a few visitors get beaten by out-of-control cops.

  • Takuan

    2 years ago

  • mopled

    2 years ago

    Dr. Alexander, I agree

    I have been worried about a false flag incident, but I realized that the security apparatus that has already been installed will just be continued after everybody goes home. An incident would be unnecessary. Between 9/11 and the crotch bomber, they have all the justification needed to keep and enlarge police state measures already in place.
    http://www.nextgov.com/nextgov/ng_20100125_6457.php

    Coyote...capitalism is just one of the tools used by the gangsters who run the world.They are always playing both ends against the middle.

  • lemonheart

    2 years ago

    BCBoy- Believing your own propaganda ....

    ...is what I see happening. Paranoid politicos.

    I give it 3 days until some overzealous Ron Zalko cromag cop loses it and kills someone. Between all the different security apparatus going they can't NOT mess up horrifically. It is truly what they do.

    Any grown "adult" that cannot see the inherent value of protests AND civil disobedience} should have their civil rights taken away {... ironically and unknowingly they will anyways} in concert with having their vocal chords removed. Swine!

    The problem is civil obedience. Period.

    What if I don't pay taxes or like how I'm being treated by a cop? What awaits me?
    The MAN with a big stick { ...or taser}.

    And what is the appropriate response to the stick from above, huh? Someone please enlighten me on standing up to downward violence. Sh*t, as does violence, runs downhill in this society.

    Just how much sh*t must be eaten whilst standing beneath the stick? Someone tell me.
    Or should I just shut up and be "peaceful"?.

  • Takuan

    2 years ago

    the appropriate response?

    do whatever it takes to get rid of the government that tolerates and gives the orders to the cops. The cops are just robots that blindly follow orders. Smashing them is satisfying but not really addressing the real problem.

  • Gerlib

    2 years ago

    The big problem for protesters

    isn't the police. IMO it's the ordinary hard working people who are looking for a bit of fun in their life.

    My tip to the protesters is "don't put youself in the way of good hard working citizens, trying to enjoy themselves" .

    Even better do something positive to help our great society, we find you useless protesters a pain in the a--.

  • dorothy

    2 years ago

    John Greg

    Thanks for the tip!

  • BC Boy

    2 years ago

    Still beyond comprehension

    "For the fifth time, the NDP record on combating homelessness and poverty is better than the BC Liberal record. The BC Libs have led the country on child poverty for seven years in a row. There have been more homeless on the streets of BC in the last 9 years than there were under the NDP. "

    For the sixth time, the NDP despite having endless
    resolutions in their convention books during the 1980's did not entirely eliminate poverty. Also consider it was the NDP that closed Essondale and
    put mentally challenged people out on the strees.

    The NDP was supposed to eliminate poverty and did not.

    "What you asked for was that protesters be used on drug dealers."

    and why not? Why not have the energies of the protest against The Games be used against the drug dealers in the downtown east side? Protest them out of the neighbourhood. The locals will thank you for it.

    "The last time anyone looked, drug dealing on the street is a crime. It's called trafficing."

    "Then why do you need protesters?"

    Geezus -- To shame them out of the downtown east side and get them out of the neighbourhood down there so that the downtown east side can be made more livable. What's wrong with that??

    "Why not use the billion dollars you just spent on police to arrest them?"

    If there was protests against the drug dealers being there there wouldn't be any need to spend money on policing in a huge way.

    How much do you need to arrest drug dealers? Two billion? Three billion?"

    Don't need much if the protestors would focus their efforts to picket in front of them, and get them out of the neighbourhood by protesting them being there.

    "Intersting - so why all the whining and complaining that the Olympics are taking away from the homeless??"
    "As a party for not afford to even attend, there are many events for free."

    (sigh) I have trouble believing your claim you're the head of a corporation when your grammar and spelling (not to mention your memory and reading comprehension) are this atrocious.

    (sigh), and one has to wonder about occupation that respondent has. Must be tough working at the
    bottle depot on Hastings Street for him.

  • dorothy

    2 years ago

    It's fake...

    Now I get this business with the torch. They're not going to actually light the olympic fire with the torch that's come from Greece, been run across the country and all over the province. Its going to be allowed to fizzle out somewhere in a 'community cauldron', and then they're going to light a match and set it to the big one in the center, just like that, no ceremony. That's why we won't be seeing anyone carrying it in and lighting the big one with it, which used to be the most solemn moment in years gone by, the moment everything leads up to.

    I have been trying to figure out why. I think I know. They are afraid of doing the acutal Olympic ritual, seeing that that might be invoking some real magic, and who knows whom it might hit and where it might go, considering all the lies and breaking of oaths and promises they have perpetrated. Let's not forget that our own Dick Pound wasn't hired for the IOC leadership because of too much integrity. That's spelling it out pretty clearly right there, eh?

    I think the miserable sots are afraid of the revenge the Gods may take if they mock them.

  • Frank

    2 years ago

    BC Boy

    "For the sixth time, the NDP despite having endless
    resolutions in their convention books during the 1980's did not entirely eliminate poverty"

    LOL! Whatever.

    As for using protesters against drug dealers instead of the police force we're paying billions for... good lordy.

    "and one has to wonder about occupation that respondent has."

    If English isn't your first language let me know and I'll stop bugging you about your writing.

    "Must be tough working at the
    bottle depot on Hastings Street for him."

    At least its honest work. And unlike being a CEO such as yourself, we Hastings Street bottle depot guys had to pass grade 12 English. Now show some initiative and start attending a night school.

  • BC Boy

    2 years ago

    Still doesn't get it after several attempts

    For the sixth time, the NDP despite having endless
    resolutions in their convention books during the 1980's did not entirely eliminate poverty"

    LOL! Whatever.

    El oh el.. The NDP had "eliminate poverty" on their resolution books during the 1980's at every
    convention and there were a few so-called advocates
    for poverty striken people that ran as NDP candidates and failed to achieve the goals, just
    like the party.

    The NDP was playing the eliminate poverty song over and over like a cheap cassette tape back then.

    "As for using protesters against drug dealers instead of the police force we're paying billions for... good lordy."

    Well, why not? Are they afraid to confront the drug dealers who are themselves causing the problem in the downtown east side with their pushing of the drugs they are selling? Shame them
    out of the neigbourhood and there would be a change. The huge security effort is not just
    the local yellers. It's also to prevent a repeat
    of what happened at the 1972 Munich Games.

    Also worth noting, the NDP didn't redirect the millions they spent on the 1994 Commonwealth Games and the Fastcats to eliminate poverty did they?

    "and one has to wonder about occupation that respondent has."

    If English isn't your first language let me know and I'll stop bugging you about your writing.

    Well save it. I'll keep my formal writing for those who use it.

    "Must be tough working at the
    bottle depot on Hastings Street for him."

    At least its honest work. And unlike being a CEO such as yourself,

    CEO is honest work. As is president. I doubt you have ever run a small business and keep the books
    balanced, keep the customers and employees happy.

    "we Hastings Street bottle depot guys had to pass grade 12 English."

    Probably meant you ended up putting the bottles
    in the boxes, not doing the difficult task of
    paying out the money to those who brought the bottles in, right.

    Actually did better than that, Sherlock. Won a
    B in Second year Business English at university.

    "Now show some initiative and start attending a night school."

    Sure. Whatever. LOL...

  • Chris Keam

    2 years ago

    kind of dumb idea

    "If there was protests against the drug dealers being there there wouldn't be any need to spend money on policing in a huge way."

    Hard to believe vigilantism is being condoned, putting aside that silliness, suggesting citizens should put themselves at risk of death or injury by trying to run (probably) armed drug dealers out of their neighbourhood is a ludicrous suggestion. That's clearly an idea that needs its proponent to lead by example IMO, if they think it's a sensible reaction to criminal activity run and financed by organized crime syndicates.

  • BC Boy

    2 years ago

    Not so dumb

    So according to CK, it's okay for protestors to physically disrupt events that are being enjoyed by others, and yet not protest against the heavy drug dealing that goes on in the Downtown Eastside.

    Again to repeat the protestors do not have any rights amongst themselves to disrupt events. They can protest as long as it is peaceful and does not disrupt.

    If the protestors want to lead by example and really mean what they say in regards to homelessness and the misery in the downtown east side then they should get busy and act to help in a big way to fix the problem if they are really all that concerned about it.

    otherwise it jsut turns into a dog and phoney show for the media.

    and guess what? After all those marches, and the signs are put away, the homelessness will still be there and the drug dealing will still take place,
    and none of the protestors are really all that
    concerned about fixing the problem.

    So it makes the marches and disruptions nothing more than a show for the media.

    and nothing really gets fixed, and the protestors
    don't really care all that much about the downtown east side.

    Nothing is ever going to get fixed in the downtown east side unless these protestors actually are true to their whining and complaining and actually get busy and do something about it, rather than bothering people who want to enjoy events and the Games.

  • Chris Keam

    2 years ago

    Sorry, but that's bullshit

    "So according to CK, it's okay for protestors to physically disrupt events that are being enjoyed by others, and yet not protest against the heavy drug dealing that goes on in the Downtown Eastside."

    Nowhere did I suggest any such thing or make any such somparison. I just pointed out that your idea of confronting drug dealers was stupid. You might ask a policeman or 15,000 what they think of such a hare-brained scheme before you misrepresent my remarks in a feeble attempt to deflect attention from your nonsense. Frankly, you should apologize asap.

  • Chris Keam

    2 years ago

    spelling error

    "Nowhere did I suggest any such thing or make any such somparison." should be 'comparison'

  • Chris Keam

    2 years ago

    More junk opinion

    "Nothing is ever going to get fixed in the downtown east side unless these protestors actually are true to their whining and complaining and actually get busy and do something about it, rather than bothering people who want to enjoy events and the Games."

    To generalize, most of the organization and individuals involved in Olympic criticism do exactly that. But, since it doesn't suit your narrative, you're ignoring reality. Since, I have a sneaking suspicion I've already discounted your fantasy-world in another forum, to no effect, I'll leave you to your misinformation campaign.

  • BC Boy

    2 years ago

    Again. don't get it. But go ahead anyway

    Obviously don't get the idea to get going and reduce homelessness by actually getting out there and doing something about it rather than complain and whine all the time.

    I doubt most of the ORN actually has done anything tangible (do they run a shelter? Assist in rehab of drug addicts? Proably not. Many are ignoring reality. In other words if the ORN was really all that hell bent about homelessness and poverty they would actually do something about it, perhaps something they could have started two or three years ago and showcased it to the world, rather than getting into the silly notion of supporting tactics to disrupt events and not really getting into civil peaceful protests.

    A solid workable programme working with the social structure and the addicts themselves to get them off that junk would actually "get rid of the drug dealers". Cut off the market and the sellers will be out of there fast.

    and CK - sorry pal. No apologies from me just yet.
    I want to see absolutely no disruption of events, no disruption of the games, and no interference with the enjoyment of the games first.

    and get goin' on actually doing something for the downtown east side if you really care about the issue that much.

    If not, well then just take a hike.

  • Frank

    2 years ago

    BC Boy

    "The NDP had "eliminate poverty" on their resolution books during the 1980's"

    And although they didn't eliminate it they did a better job combating it than the BC Liberals. And that's in spite of Harcourt being there for half the time.

    Regardless, I'm sure you won't bring up the litany of broken BC Liberal promises will you? BC Rail? Raid on the legislature? Most transparent government in history? 5 Great Goals for a Golden Decade? Literacy? The list is long...

    "Well, why not? Are they afraid to confront the drug dealers who are themselves causing the problem in the downtown east side with their pushing of the drugs they are selling?"

    Wouldn't you be? If not, why don't you go down there yourself and "shame the drug dealers"? No one is stopping you. Please go and be a hero.

    And take your billion dollars worth of police with you, they're not doing anything else.

    "The huge security effort is not just
    the local yellers. It's also to prevent a repeat
    of what happened at the 1972 Munich Games."

    Really? A billion dollars in security to protect 3 Israeli athletes? You just never get tired of making things up do you?

    "Also worth noting, the NDP didn't redirect the millions they spent on the 1994 Commonwealth Games and the Fastcats to eliminate poverty did they?"

    I assume you were a big fan of the 1994 Commonwealth Games? The cost was $142 million. Although not a huge sum I believe the money could have been better spent.

    As for the ferries. BC is not next to North Korea as you seem to believe, we're next to a large body of water. Ferries are required to cross that body of water now and then so as to link communities. Its a necessary cost.

    "Well save it. I'll keep my formal writing for those who use it."

    You can instantly switch between good writing and bad writing can you? Whatever.

    "Actually did better than that, Sherlock. Won a
    B in Second year Business English at university."

    Either you're making things up again or our education system has truly fallen apart. I'm sure your teachers are hiding their heads in shame every time you post.

  • OilbertaRedTory

    2 years ago

    Winning B

    "Won a B in Second year Business English at university."

    Gosh - who knew you could win grades from Crackerjack boxes ?

  • BC Boy

    2 years ago

    Not really getting it.

    "And although they didn't eliminate it they did a better job combating it than the BC Liberals."

    Oh? Was there a massive reduction in poverty? Ask End Legislative Poverty. The concept was to eliminate poverty, something they did not do. It is interesting that the drug problem was still very much manifesting itself when the NDP
    was in power. They did nothing to eliminate it.

    "And that's in spite of Harcourt being there for half the time."

    Sure. His Party was helping itself to charity funds which went to the provincial office and local ridings courtesy of David Stupich and his Commonwealth Holding Society.

    and "shame the drug dealers"? No one is stopping you. Please go and be a hero.

    and what's stopping you from doing the same thing?

    Now you're talking Sherlock. Let's get the entire
    ORN out there to do exactly that. Finally you've
    rung the bell on what I am getting at. Congratulations. Take a chocolate bar out of the glass bowl as a prize.

    Really? A billion dollars in security to protect 3 Israeli athletes? You just never get tired of making things up do you?

    You never tire of twisting things around do you?
    It's to prevent such situations from occuring.

    I assume you were a big fan of the 1994 Commonwealth Games? The cost was $142 million. Although not a huge sum I believe the money could have been better spent.

    Sure, and the close to a billion dollars in accrued costs for the Fastcats (not just the project cost, but the cost of the loans needed.

    As for the ferries. BC is not next to North Korea as you seem to believe, we're next to a large body of water. Ferries are required to cross that body of water now and then so as to link communities. Its a necessary cost.

    "Well save it. I'll keep my formal writing for those who use it."

    You can instantly switch between good writing and bad writing can you? Whatever.
    Either you're making things up again or our education system has truly fallen apart. I'm sure your teachers are hiding their heads in shame every time you post.

    Guess you know all about that, don't you.

    Enjoy your day, and try not to get too worked up over the games and the events.

    Also try to think of how you're actually going to help the people in the downtown east side that your
    friends are using (literally) in protest against the games.

  • BC Boy

    2 years ago

    Free B

    Winning B
    "Won a B in Second year Business English at university."

    Gosh - who knew you could win grades from Crackerjack boxes ?

    Makes a person wonder that how you could win grades simply because the teacher decided to just give an F level student a C+ because she felt sorry for you.

  • Chris Keam

    2 years ago

    apology

    "and CK - sorry pal. No apologies from me just yet."

    I actually meant you should apologize for the way you misrepresented what I said. If you got a B in English, then one can assume you can read and comprehend what I wrote.

    "A solid workable programme working with the social structure and the addicts themselves to get them off that junk would actually "get rid of the drug dealers". Cut off the market and the sellers will be out of there fast."

    And will they be paying for these programmes with fairy dust? The gov't itself claims poverty w/r/t to these initiatives and you think a wave of a wand addresses drug addiction? Jeezus, the ignorance, mindless boosterism, and knee-jerk stupidity of your position on this is actually painful to read. I sincerely hope that you ARE volunteering for the Olympics given your love for the spectacle.

  • Frank

    2 years ago

    BC Boy

    "They did nothing"

    Actually they did. You were probably thinking of the Liberal record on poverty but even there you're wrong because they did do something, they increased it.

    "Sure. His Party was helping itself to charity funds which went to the provincial office and local ridings courtesy of David Stupich and his Commonwealth Holding Society."

    And your party is so corrupt that the police raided the legislature and arrested a few of your buddies. But of course unlike Harcourt, Campbell doesn't think corruption (or drunk driving) is a real crime.

    "and what's stopping you from doing the same thing?"

    I have never expressed a desire to whereas its the only thing you talk about. So by all means stand behind your words and go do it. I'll watch for you on the news.

    "Sure, and the close to a billion dollars in accrued costs for the Fastcats (not just the project cost, but the cost of the loans needed."

    Nice try, but no serious commenter has ever put the cost above even half of that. And of course its necessary to subtract all the economic benefits that came from spending that money in the province. I'm sure Germany was happy to have ferries built over there because doing so provides work and the money stays in their economy creating even more wealth. You can look up it in any first year economic text.

    "Also try to think of how you're actually going to help the people in the downtown east side that your
    friends are using (literally) in protest against the games."

    Best thing I can do to help them is work to convince the 75% that didn't vote for Campbell to show up on election day.

    Other than that, when government actively works to increase poverty there is little any individual or even group of charities can do to alleviate all the poverty in BC.

  • Jerry Munro

    2 years ago

    Appearance and Content...

    "Coyote...capitalism is just one of the tools used by the gangsters who run the world.They are always playing both ends against the middle." Mopled

    I certainly agree that, " They are always playing both ends against the middle." Which is one of the identifiable features of capitalism, of course.

    From the time of its early victory over feudalism in the English Civil War and the subsequent Industrial Revolution, reacting to the threats of the attendant early class struggles and other threats to it existence that followed its early creation, capitalism has evolved to become the slippery, slimy, shape shifting entity it is today. Indeed, it has proved admirably capable of flying any flag to hide its one true face; be the flag National Socialism (Nazi), Communism (Stalinism to modern Capitalist China), and Free Enterprise etc. etc..

    It is not the particular flag that it flies, and behind which it hides however, that determines its still, from the time of the Industrial Revolution "capitalism" critical character, but its always "elitist/vanguard" serving content, and oppression of the people, from the ruthless to the highly sophisticated forms of the advanced "capitalist" countries.

    Judge not a thing by its appearance, or its claims of itself, but by its content... That is, what it does.

    In the end, I have always said, the best antidote to all these various shape shifting forms is going to be a deeply rooted, manifold, and insistent "democratic practise" at all levels of socio-political and economic life. This, and a healthy and critical scepticism of all Alpha and Beta manifestations by the Omega masses. (Stalinism, Hitlerism, Maoism, Reganism, and Thatcherism etc. Beware all the "uncontrolled" manifestations of the Cult of the Personality, and claims of vanguardism etc..)

    Of these however, a manifold "democracy" at all levels of, and throughout all the structures of society, including the economy, is the key element. For it is there, in the economy especially, that capitalism in all its many shape shifting forms really arises and roots itself.

  • Yammer

    2 years ago

    So easy!

    Whew! All we have to do is repudiate capitalism and "democracy"! Thanks man.

    Hey I just thought of a good promo for the Tyee comments section -- post at the Tyee, get a free tinfoil hat.

  • Jerry Munro

    2 years ago

    Tinfoil hats and Brownshirts...

    And here is your tinfoil hat. Ot would you rather it was a brown shirt?

    To the degree one can tell the difference.

  • Jerry Munro

    2 years ago

    Tin foil hats and drag queens...

    Hmmm, actually, the tinfoil hat and the brownshirt are but two parts of the same identifiable neoconazi uniform.

    Here, ever shape shifting, they are a Liberal, there a Conservative, and yet there again a Wildrose Party goose stepper, there the gasping and dying Reform Party, snd then like a metamorphosing butterfly of many faces, here the Saskatchewan Party. They change many times, wearing different faces and makeup, over the course of playing their many Drag Queen roles, seeking to appeal to every fantasy.

    Tinfoil hats, indeed. Real little Herman Gorings.

  • sicntired

    2 years ago

    Just exactly what part of Amerika did I wake up in this morning?

    I know that a lot of what is going on is a display to please our neighbors to the south who's paranoia knows no bounds.The increased security on seaplanes where the pilot and passengers have known each other for years is just another waste of money.The insane and overblown efforts that are now admittedly being aimed at locals who want to exercise their right to protest is despicable.I saw young people with backpacks who were playing with electronic devices and no one even noticed.If there is and riot in Vancouver it,like every riot this city has ever seen will be the result of agents provocateurs employed by either the RCMP(my bet)or the locals raising the bar on police misconduct with their riot gear.I have been on the receiving end of their clubs and have been arrested for assaulting a police officer.I guess I must have messed up the finish on the club he was whacking me with all the way up Davie street.Freedom of speech is dead when the police are speaking of illegal protests by protesters speaking during the torch run???I guess our streets are a no talking zone unless you have nice things to say about the Olympiks.People are so willing to lie down whenever they are told it is positively frightening.Canadians obviously believe in doing what they're told and shutting up without a whimper.No thought as to the where's and the why's.1984 has truly come and found a willing home here.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.