News

Two Months of HST Sees Consumer Price Index Rise

Finance minister said businesses might pass on cost savings.

By Andrew MacLeod, 23 Sep 2010, TheTyee.ca

Dinner shot, around a table

Restaurant food prices jumped 6.7 per cent in August.

Related

On several occasions, B.C. Finance Minister Colin Hansen argued that any increase in costs to consumers caused by harmonizing the provincial and federal sales taxes might be balanced by businesses reducing the prices they charge for goods and services.

Statistics Canada has released two sets of consumer price index (CPI) figures since the HST went into place July 1. Neither showed a drop. What's more, a StatsCan analyst says it may never be possible to figure out the tax's net impact on what people pay.

As Hansen explained it in August 2009, the move to the HST would drop costs for businesses that had been paying provincial sales tax. Those businesses might pass their savings on by reducing prices, he said.

"Consumers are paying for that embedded PST, whether they're paying for it at the consumer level or whether they're paying for it in the price of those goods and services," Hansen said. "I know that's a complex concept. I know it's a difficult one to communicate to Fred and Mary."

Some, including people with low incomes and middle income seniors, would pay less with an HST, he said. "Costs do come out of the system."

CPI up slightly

If costs for businesses are coming down, that's yet to register in the consumer price index.

According to StatsCan's Sept. 21 release, prices rose by 1.5 per cent in B.C. during the 12-month period that ended in August. That's slightly below the average national increase of 1.7 per cent.

The provincial increase, StatsCan found, was largely driven by a 6.7 per cent jump in the price of food from restaurants and a 6.5 per cent hike in the price of gasoline.

Daniel Cheung, a StatsCan analyst, said the Sept. 21 report didn't look specifically at the effects of the HST, though amounts paid for the tax are included in the index.

However, the agency's report from August, based on July figures, did see impact from the HST. B.C. had a two per cent increase in its CPI from a year earlier, and StatsCan found as much as 1.2 per cent of the increase was from the tax.

Ontario, which also introduced an HST July 1, saw a 2.9 per cent increase in CPI. StatsCan said at most 1.3 per cent was attributable to the tax.

HST effect hard to isolate: analyst

Hansen was unavailable for comment. A statement from the Finance Ministry said the government was expecting the HST to cause a slight increase in the inflation rate for the first year it's in place. As business costs go down, a portion will likely be passed on to consumers, the statement said. The ministry has said previously that businesses will pay some $2 billion less a year in sales tax thanks to the change.

The HST will have a complex effect on prices, acknowledged StatsCan's Cheung. While there's no evidence of it happening yet, the fact that it reduces costs for businesses means it is possible some of that money will be reflected in lower prices.

"It takes time for those savings to trickle down to consumers," he said.

Asked how long he would expect it to take, he said, "It all depends on how the economy works. It doesn't go right away."

And as time goes on, it may be impossible to say what's caused by the tax and what would have happened anyway. "I don't think there's any way to figure that out," he said. "To be exact, nobody knows."

Or, put another way, "Isolating the net impact is not an easy exercise."

As for B.C.'s official position on what the HST will do to prices in the province, it has shifted somewhat. In a Sept. 2 response to a poll that found many British Columbians believe goods and services had become more expensive, the Finance Ministry had this to say: "In fact, they cost exactly the same now as they did under the old PST."  [Tyee]

47  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • crankypants

    1 year ago

    No surprises here

    Where to begin. On the trickle down effect, just look at the words used by Hansen "businesses MIGHT pass on savings", and from the Finance Ministry, "as business costs go down, a portion will LIKELY be passed on to consumers". Weasel words, nothing more.

    The bottom line is that successive Finance Ministers shunned the HST as if it was the plague for a reason. That is because it will not deliver what Campbell and Hansen want us to believe. It will bolster the bottom lines of select businesses, mostly owned offshore, and punish the taxpayers financially in the process. The rush to sign up was only based on one thing, the $1.599 billion bribe.

    The stupid thing is the BC LIberal Party outsmarted themselves by going the HST route. If they had been honest about their pre-election budget and admitted the pending deficit was going to be in the $2 billion range, the electorate would have accepted the situation and probably still elected them. Every province was bleeding red ink at the time and logic said that BC was in no better circumstances. But no, Campbell and Hansen stuck to their fantasy, and the rest as they say, is history.

    Even after the election they could have announced an increase in the PST from 7 to 8 percent, and they wouldn't have faced the pushback they are now facing.

    Their condescending attitude toward the electorate is not the most endearing tact either. Mr. Campbell, Mr. Hansen, we are not as stupid as you make us out to be. If only your tenure in office as the government were a country music record, we could play it backwards and get all the peoples' assets you have given to your friends, we'd be in a much better place going forward. Unfortunately, we can't, and that is a cross our children and grandchildren will be forced to bear.

    Thanks for nothing!

  • Toobad

    1 year ago

    Hansen also said.......

    That the HST would be forestry`s saviour....

    Yet Elk falls mill shut down, and now, clear lake mill just permanantly closed, another 200 workers jobless, another crushed rural town!

    Drop dead BC Liberals..RECALL!

    http://powellriverpersuader.blogspot.com/2010/09/another-bc-mill-is-being-mothballed.html

  • gomer

    1 year ago

    still waiting for the trickle

    maybe I don't understand the concept...perhaps "trickle down" means to stand at the base of a cliff until you feel the warm salty moisture.

  • DPL

    1 year ago

    Hansen believes in the tooth

    Hansen believes in the tooth ferry too. what a bunch of crooks. Business loves Hansen as his BS increases their bottom line. Time to leave town Hansen and take Gordo with you

  • Jeffrey J.

    1 year ago

    Recall ASAP

    Yup, these guys are chronic liars and they have to go. BC has perhaps one last chance at proving our democracy.

    THROW THE BUMS OUT.

    Start volunteering at your local committee level. If we all do that, we can succeed.

    If we do have a change in government, then we must remain vigilant and in charge. Democracy is about the majority of citizens directing those in government. Not the opposite.

    Great article.

  • Grania

    1 year ago

    RECALL

    Get this cretin out first...

  • jim1966

    1 year ago

    What?

    Trickle down effect, not much impact to low income people?, please gimme a break already Hansen. No business would pass on savings to the consumer, in fact prices have gone up. Campbell and Co are mistaken in thier assumption and arrogant. Once again Campbell and Co's facade has failed. Recall is the one viable solution to this issue and it is a reality.

  • Iwannajob

    1 year ago

    Toobad is right

    Toobad reminded us that Hansen said the HST would be the greatest thing for our ailing forest industry. The HST has a very minor effect compared to allowing the forest industry to remove their private land obligation from their TFL's plus their obligation to mill the wood within the region that the wood was grown. And we all know how those rule changes "saved" the forest industry. It certainly changed the industry across the line where some of our mills moved to and all our raw logs are now going. Any saving for the industry from the HST will stay in the pockets of big business and will NOT trickle down to the supporting businesses. Every time I hear a Ricola commercial yodelling through the TV I replace the word RECALL instead. Kind of has a nice ring to it!

  • Jerry Munro

    1 year ago

    On Playing An Old Record Again...

    I've said it here before of course, but issues and responses here often cycle and are repeated in one form or another.

    I've participated in a Recall that didn't work, and frankly, am not optimistic about its likely outcome. Still, IF the public mood is overwhelming, and this next round of Recalls will give us all a read on that, there is an outside chance that it will have some effect. So, while I would urge some realism about this process that was designed to fail on the part of the NDP that brought it to us, it is possible to be of some positive usefulness... if for no other reason than "the read" of the public mood it will afford us all.

    But change, any significant change, other than just a brand name change from Liberal to the NDP, or Social Credit, and their joint concern for "investors" as expressed by Carole, is not going to arrive as a consequence of any Recall. And that is because, though again, this MAY be a useful test, it is insufficiently "threatening" to The System to seriously change the DNA politics of any of these status quo parties to capitalism.

    For that, it is going to take a quite different development, of massive "alternative" public organization models, and taking to the streets, bypassing the NDP and trade unions, or old "corrupt" relic parties of capitalism. (Indeed, right now at least, all these latter must be seen as "part of" and "invested" as "investors" into The System.)

    To the degree that this Recall round IS NOT hijacked by the Old Social Credit Guard attempt however, to set itself up as a new "rallying flag" point for the Right, as its Liberal false front is discredited and goes down, and it succeeds at actually "organizing the public" alternatively, we MAY have a good thing.

    Given the Old Social Credit Guards successes at outflanking the NDP and Liberals both however, and taking the initiative AND the leadership of this new Recall round, I am not optimistic. A quite other agenda to that of the interests of the people has control of this enterprise right now.

    And we can't even yet get the NDP to commit to undoing the HST. And so long as that state of affairs exist, the Old Social Crediters can claim with considerable justification, ignoring Old Social Crediter ex-luminaries long ipso facto participation in the Liberal Party, that NDP MLAs should be subject to Recall as well. And they should.

    The sound and fury coming out of this one, is unlikely to be perfect, for sure. There's a lot of scratches and skips on this old record.

  • offended

    1 year ago

    Same cost as under the PST?

    Wrong.

    Services are fully taxed now; they weren't before.

  • Jerry Munro

    1 year ago

    A Tea Party?

    This Recall round, in fact, has a bit of an extremist Tea Party feel to it. About which I hope I am wrong.

    We shall see.

  • pianosaurus rex

    1 year ago

    no tricke down that I am aware of

    I have owned a small business for 38 years and I can state with a degree of certainty that never at anytime have I felt compelled to give any of my tax saving back to the customers.

    I have spoken to many colleagues and others in small business similar to mine and not one of them has even entertained this idea; that is such a dumb-assed assertion it could not possibly have been made by someone who actually owns or understands small business......

    This is not government for the people. This is not a reflection of the constituents’ desires and wishes. These are puppet/clowns directed by others for the benefit of a few at the top.

    Most of Campbell and crew are too stupid to be alive; one wonders how they got this far in life. It is the only reason they are in there. The puppet masters also realized that Campbell and crew can be manipulated because they are imbeciles. One does not have to look very far to see why they were chosen to run things for their masters..... you would not get people with actual intellect to do what Campbell et al have done.

    They are simply trained monkeys......

  • mary jane

    1 year ago

    watch for hst-gst+pst

    some people were getting all 3 charged.
    Lets ALL cheer for the recall people
    When you live on low income an added tax bites into your purchase power a lot me. hansen needs to go back to school and learn how to add and subtract

  • Spiritlifter

    1 year ago

    Oil price increases = Recession... Alternatives?

    What is going to happen to the CPI when the price of producing energy increases? We have to seriously evolve into a renewable energy nation,now. We must elect officials that can make that connection.

  • Umslopogaas

    1 year ago

    Recall

    Where do I sign up?

    Could the Tyee publish the "legitimate" contact names for each riding so that no Lieberal bastards can flimflam us by setting up any false recall organizations?

  • Toobad

    1 year ago

    For recall info....

    Go to.....fighthst.com

  • Skywalker

    1 year ago

    I've been trickled on...

    ..and I know it is costing me more. Keep em coming Andrew!

  • rantnic

    1 year ago

    HANSENS TRICLE DOWN EFFECT

    The effect may seem warm and reliving at first but soon it gets cold, starts to chafe and smells bad. You know that eventually you will have to start crying. "You big baby you".
    Does anyone think that Mr. Hansen will give you a tax break so that you can afford the new clean, un-trickled pants to carry what he thinks is his wallet in.

  • CanadianLatitude

    1 year ago

    Recall would be great but it

    Recall would be great but it will never happen, you will never get enough signatures under the current requirements and in neocon areas like the Valley or Okanagon or western part of Vancouver the libs would just win the seats back anyway.

    Plus it does not help the NDP are basically leaderless..

  • Toobad

    1 year ago

    Canadian Latitude

    You said the same thing about the anti/HST petition...Strike I....

    Can`t wait to give you strike II...Strike III....

    And your outta here...Good riddens!

  • Driftwood

    1 year ago

    Yes they would!

    The NDP would scrap the HST. Carol James has called on the Premier to recall the legislature specifically to deal with this. Campbell, on the other hand, cancelled the fall sitting precisely because he doesn't want to deal with this. You don't have to belong to the NDP to go and sign this petition to recall the legislature for the specific purpose of mandating a fall vote on the HST referendum:
    http://www.bcndp.ca/moveupyourvote

    Vander Zalm et al have no intention of recalling this government. Unless they can replace it with another right wing Tea Party type government. The NDP on the other hand is the polar opposite of tea party. They would not only scrap the HST in a heartbeat, but they would give us sane and responsible government to get us through the tough years ahead - without giving away what little remains of our heritage. The wealth of BC is here for the people of BC, not for some neocons to give away to corporations while they draw us ever deeper into debt. http://thegallopingbeaver.blogspot.com/2010/09/gordo-appointee-cans-elections-bc.html

  • morechatter

    1 year ago

    Bring it on!

    The NDP says lets do the referendum right now as the people in the province are demanding it and Cambpell ignoring the people's requests isn't the answer. Instead the NDP wants Cambpell to open the legislature this fall and bring on the referendum in 2010and get the tax out of the way for the good of the economy and the people of BC.

  • morechatter

    1 year ago

    The recall will work

    And don't listen to the pessimists life has left in the no way. And just maybe the premier from Hell will do the right thing and let the people have their say but we all know the answer and so will the rest of the people making the recall something that will go all the way.

  • Jerry Munro

    1 year ago

    Past History Can Be Wrong In A New Time...

    "Recall would be great but it will never happen, you will never get enough signatures under the current requirements and in neocon areas like the Valley or Okanagon or western part of Vancouver the libs would just win the seats back anyway.

    Plus it does not help the NDP are basically leaderless.." Canadian Latitude.

    Well, I've certainly seen and been a part of this Recall optimism before... only to have it fall on its face. And the historical evidence is not good on the chances for success here. So I certainly understand where you are coming from, Canadian Latitude.

    That said, it is only "possible" that there is indeed and finally a new mood in the land, that will top it, and overcome the serious obstacles in the way of Recall success. I, for example, would not have thought that the HST petition would have succeeded either, frankly. (And I did sign it.) And it does indicate that there MAY indeed be a "new mood" finally arriving in the land and taking root. So I'm really not ready to throw cold water on it... just to strike a note of realism. (And make no mistake, a certain level of idealism is good... and we need it. But it always needs to be tempered with a sense of reality. Invest your total self in one tactical plan, holding nothing back in reserve, if it fails, your energy and élan bank is broke. One's fighting spirit needs to be spent wisely.)

    All which brings me to say, "Go for it!"

    Sometimes the ramparts have to be stormed again and again, before they are finally breached.

    Besides, in my tactical view, it will give us a very important reading on the extant state of the public mind. And we absolutely need to know that, for sure. (There is always too much guessing about this public mood thing, based on past history... until suddenly, it is wrong. The worm has turned.)

    So, if there is the idealism, the energy, and the numbers out there again, to get it off the ground, if it shows up here in my nearest town, I will work for it. And I urge others to do the same. (And we have an NDP MLA.)

    Until I hear a firm commitment from the NDP that, regardless, they will scrap the HST... NO MATTER HOW THIS RECALL GOES.

    Hopefully, the public has indeed had enough of all this bullshit, on both sides of the aisle, as they say.

  • morechatter

    1 year ago

    Never say never

    It is an old saying but it is a word that has haunted its users throught out time.

  • Jerry Munro

    1 year ago

    Never Say Never...

    "It is an old saying but it is a word that has haunted its users throught out time." morechatter

    Indeed morechatter. This is true.

  • mariner

    1 year ago

    No HST ?

    For all the rhetoric that has happen the last three months, it appears that the government has no real idea what is happening in the real world.

    I have been doing renovations at my place and yesterday had some materials delivered. When presented with the bill, I was told that if I paid cash - there would be no tax (HST). If I paid by cheque then I would be charged tax (HST) !!!

    It seems that a growing number of medium and small businesses are opting for the cash payment scenario. This suits the customers who can pay cash and the businesses get cash flow with no real records - saves them taxes too.

    So what we have now is an idiotic government that seems unable to understand what is happening in the real world. Hello - is anyone at home in Victoria ??

    Needless to say I took advantage of the cash offer - to me that is a double wammy against the government of Gordon Campbell. I don't pay HST and the supplier gets a non recorded and non taxed cash flow !

    So, only big businesses gain from the HST - off of the backs of everyday working folk. The government needs to either cancel the HST or they will themselves be cancelled, by the voters over the next twelve months.

    Thank you

  • crankypants

    1 year ago

    Recall

    As I see it, recall has much bigger implications than dislodging the current government. Trading one side of the spectrum for the other solves nothing in the grand scheme of things. We will still be stuck with the same system that got us to where we are. We have no real tools to change the system in the short term, but we can certainly rock the boat which may lead to change in the long term.

    Swaping one dictator for another solves nothing. Unfortunately whenever one side or the other gains a majority, we install a dictator.

    That being said, recall gives the electorate the only real power we will ever have. Only then can we really impose our true power. An election campaign is really nothing more than a popularity contest which in most cases delivers the flavour of the day as our representative. There is no relation between competence and electability under our current system. And sadly there is no reason that anyting will change going forward.

    The way I look at it is that if we can actually have some successful recalls, we will serve notice that we are only willing to elect those that will be a representative of their constituents rather than become sycophants to the political parties they currently pledge allegiance to.

    This is our time, and we must not screw it up.

  • Skywalker

    1 year ago

    Mariner.

    I too have noticed this as a real trend. I now always carry enough cash on hand or ask what they prefer before agreeing to the "deal".

  • Jerry Munro

    1 year ago

    Crankypants

    I really do think you have gotten smarter over the years I've known you here. Have you noticed that there is a "kind of" convergence of viewpoints been going on here... excluding the rwingnuts of course. (Though even there, there are one or two that seem to have got smarter as well. Snert, seems actually to have "evolved", unless this is not the same one of "an earlier time".)

    What I find most interesting about the current period is, that there has been a dawning realization that all the parties to current capitalism are more fundamentally alike, than unalike... and I mean, that goes for them all, without exception, including the so-called Greens. They all think WITHIN the box. Never, never OUTSIDE it. And I think folks have actually come to realize this.

    This so-called democracy is bullshit. Plain and simple. It has no real content of any heft, any real substantivity. The best we get to do is elect, as crankypants says, our own dictatorship for the next X number of years. And whatever our choice, they all produce essentially the same policies and practise result... that leave the ruling class and their power untouched and unthreatened,.

    A way has to be evolved of wiggling and squirming, threatening and cajoling our way out The Box we are all caught up as wage slaves in.

  • Driftwood

    1 year ago

    Do you have to have big tits too?

    To qualify under the Vander Zalm plan to start a recall campaign. Just wondering because with all the seats just waiting to fall right now, only three are going to be targetted and that won't even begin until Jan 1.
    http://www.elections.bc.ca/index.php/referenda-recall-initiative/recall/faqs/

  • Jerry Munro

    1 year ago

    Driftwood....

    There is certainly nothing written in stone or law anywhere that says only the Vander Zalm plan can proceed. That's just the Old Socred Guard attempting to set the agenda and control outcomes. Otherwise, it's pretty much up to folks in local communities, as to whether or not they can take it on and organize effectively.

    Indeed, I would encourage, that "wherever" a Recall can effectively proceed, it be done, regardless who hold the given seat... Liberal or NDP. All deserve to fall.

    The Old Socred Guard has thus far pretty effectively taken control of the issue for their own purposes of course (to become the new flag bearing rallying point for the Corporatist Right, as its hereto Liberal banner goe down.)... And eh, all's fair in love, war and politics. ...but they can certainly be outflanked and/or absorbed into something larger as MAY evolve no less.

    I have doubts that The Left and Progressive forces are that sufficiently organized right now, but ehhh, I've been wrong before. (Once 8-) And if its true that the public mood has changed that much in mass, then all things become suddenly possible.

  • Jerry Munro

    1 year ago

    A Big Problem...

    The indicators of a collapse of confidence within and about the NDP (and trade unions), into which The Left and Progressives have been much invested for a long time now, has created even more disarray on The Left than has, as I say, long been normal... since at least the early 80s, when it became obvious... though actually even longer, I would contend.

    Hopefully, and I actually think, this is temporary, while these folks struggle with what to do with themselves, and where and if to go. They have "issues" they need to sort out.

    Again, we shall see.

  • happy

    1 year ago

    Your point MacLeod?

    So the CPI increased in BC since the HST was introduced.
    Yes. It also increased in all provinces at that same time, more so in some cases.
    A large portion of the increase was higher gas prices. Gas is HST excempt in BC.
    Whether or not the HST will do what its proponents say, lead to lower prices in SOME cases can not possibly be ruled on after a bare two months. Thats ludicrous to try to state MacLeod. Business 101 for you.
    (back off people, I support the anti HST program, but this article is so grasping it does nothing)

    http://www.statcan.gc.ca/subjects-sujets/cpi-ipc/cpi-ipc-eng.htm

  • Jerry Munro

    1 year ago

    Fatally Flawed...

    I'm on the Daily KOS mailing list, out of the, in a US context, "left and progressive" faction within the their US Democratic Party. And when you read Vaughn Palmer's column in this weekends West Coast Section of the Vancouver Sun, on Carole James' leadership of the NDP, it is hard not to realize that Carole, as has actually been going on since the first selection of the "New Democratic Party" name, after abandoning the old CCF (Co-operative Commonwealth Federation) with its "leftwing" ring, continues to be positioning that party to in fact be an "echo party" of the US Democratic Party. (And I appreciate that at least the Federal Liberal's are seeking likewise.) Her leadership direction, and this tradition within "The Centre" position of Canadian politics, which she states in no uncertain terms is where the NDP leadership wants to go, I would contend, is itself, in these times, but another of those manifestations of the "Amerikanization" of Canadian politics, no less than the Conservatives. Which underlying political reality in turn is a reflection of the Amerikanization of the Canadian economy.

    Where the economy goes, the politics is destined to quickly follow.

    I urge you all to read this article by Vaugn Palmer. It helps make clear the intentions of James and, I think, separately, the advanced stage of the Amerikanization of this country, reaching into our very ruling class dominant "democratic" institutions themselves, including ALL the parties to it.

    You want to be even a bit player in that cathedral, unless you are part of something much larger and pretty overwhelming itself, sooner or later you are going to have to play completely by their rules. This, the NDP, along with much of our trade union leadership, has pretty much clearly decided to do... holus bolus... entirely.

    Sooner or later, if they have not already, the so-called "Left" within the NDP, has a choice to make... about whether to commit to a sovereign Canada, implacably opposed to this Amerikanization process, or to become a part of the Amerikanization and its NDP face as well.

    (And there is a chance, if the recent polls are to be believed, that the NDP could win on this strategy in the next BC election. Unless the Old Socred Guard pulls off a stunner upset. Just keep in mind, that said, it is a minority of the eligible electorate that will decide this, with no other option even being available to those of us not prepared to support any of these parties to capitalism AND the Amerikanization of the province and the country.)

    It is a flawed democracy indeed... fatally flawed.

  • Driftwood

    1 year ago

    Coyoteman

    I did read the article you recommended and the only thing it made clear was the brand of journalism practiced by Vaughn Palmer. Take out his negative comments and what do you have left? The Carol James who believes in health, education, innovation for business in BC. Frankly, she's the broom we need to sweep corruption form the halls of power in Victoria. What's wrong with that? Especially compared to the Lieberals have already demonstrated their complete distain for the average BCer by cutting health care, education, and the right to a decent life in general.
    No, what all this NDP bashing is about it the realization by the right wing that the Liberal party is about to implode; and they want to stick us with some other self-interest only right wing party before we discover that good education and health care only come from people who care about the ordinary BCer.
    Carol James would give us a sane and honest government. Haven't you had enough of lies and a constantly lowered standard of living?

  • Jerry Munro

    1 year ago

    Driftwood...

    Actually, I am bashing ALL the parties to capitalism and Americanization... which includes the Liberals and NDP... no less than the Conservatives. They are ALL at the heart of the problems to the period, including...

    "Haven't you had enough of lies and a constantly lowered standard of living?" Driftwood.

    Haven't you? 8-)

  • Driftwood

    1 year ago

    Coyoteman

    My point is that we're not going to get a perfect government - now or ever - so it's much better to work with one which, if elected, will scrap the HST.
    And the NDP initiative to recall the legislature and hold a referendum ASAP is much more hopeful than giving the liberals another year to schmooze us into paying more taxes because it's 'good for us.'
    Dumping the liberals for the NDP would certainly be a step in the right direction. Holding the recall now would help us do that. It's a slim window because the dominant media; as we are all realizing, has long been slanted towards the interests of its owners and the corporations and right wing governments which butter its bread with advertising dollars. My guess is that the NDP should get into election mode right away and start building that platform and redesign their website so we can examine said platform and have access to all their latest speeches. That information is needed to debate the NDP's critics.
    I share your concerns that most of the political parties are tweedledum and tweedledee and wish the NDP would do something to prove me wrong:
    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/ellen-brown/job-losses-not-in-north-d_b_341131.html
    ... and stop sending 3 billion dollars a year in interest payments to private banks and corporations when that money could be used much more advantageously right here in BC. The Government of Canada used a very similar model when it used the Bank of Canada to fund medicare. Until they stopped doing it in 1974 and now we find ourselves up to our necks in bankers.

  • RickW

    1 year ago

    coyoteman

    Quote:
    The indicators of a collapse of confidence within and about the NDP (and trade unions), into which The Left and Progressives have been much invested for a long time now, has created even more disarray on The Left

    It certainly doesn't help that a recent survey found out that the Average Canuck is living paycheque to paycheque (like this is something new?). What it does mean though is that the prospect of a general strike grows more remote if Average Canuck is afraid to lose even one pay packet. And business (and the Lib government) would be well aware of this, so can push the proverbial envelope with little chance of repercussions.

    Were I in a union, I would push for the dismissal of the present union leadership. It may not do anything, but it would make me feel good, getting rid of the bums.

  • Jerry Munro

    1 year ago

    Rick and Driftwood...

    This is indeed a rather depressing time. Unless, of course, I am the only one. 8-D lol

    I don't share your confidence in the good intentions of the NDP Driftwood, though I wish I could. Seriously. It makes the prospects for meaningful social change and re-securing the self-reliant sovereignty of the country so much more difficult, that there is nothing currently out there, from my perspective, to serve as a vehicle for that.

    And for sure I know precisely the hack scumbag that Vaughn Palmer is, along with most of the official propaganda media in this country, but.... what is most startling about this article of his, to which I refer, is that he is quoting directly from Carole's speech notes, publicly given. He is using her own words to hoist her upon her own petard, and the NDP.

    I have always tended to hold out some hope that the NDP would re-discover its early Co-operative Commonwealth roots, but frankly, by now, out of their own mouths, I fear even this wan hope too is dashed completely.

    As for the country, being as all the at least "official" parties to it it are fundamentally agreed (and trade unions), openly or by their complicit silence, as well as for reasons indicated by RickW, of the ignorance,fear and vulnerability of the mass of the Canadian populace, my worst fear is that the country as well is fundamentally lost. And this is a very real enough danger. It would take a sudden and massive turn around in public awareness, sentiment and willingness to act, to save the country from Amerika now, I strongly think. And I don't see that happening, or even likely to happen, anywhere on the scale that there needs to be. (It is starting from scratch, back at the beginning, and late in the game, if the NDP is not even on board as a thin hope.)

    Now, hopefully, this is one of those things that I will turn out to be wrong on. I desperately hope so.

    It is appearing more and more to me though, that the writing MAY just be on the wall. If true, in which case, all those of us outside this process and opposed to it, may have a bitter pill indeed to swallow, coming up here in relatively short historical order.

    It would be comforting at least, to be able to be a true believer like Driftwood. 8-)

  • jnewcomb

    1 year ago

    need higher prices

    Good to have higher prices for consumer crap. People have too much stuff, eat and drink too much. Higher prices, maybe people won't be buying and eating so much. Got to stop unions from wage incrreases because that just makes higher cpi in a death-spiral. If we don't buy so much, companies go bust and private sector workers fired, which helps keep cpi down. Downsize government so those government workers get fired too and that will keep public wages down. Need to stop so much consuming NOW! Its better for the planet.

  • MortimerSnerd

    1 year ago

    ...a bridge for sale

    If anyone really beleives that business will pass on savings accrued by the HST... well I have a bridge I want to sell you... It simply isn't going to happen...savings will always be incorporated into the boittome line anbd the savings will then be used to fund occasional 'sales' or promotional advertising specials.

    Kiddies... the iron mantra of busisnbess is to NEVER reduce msrp prces for any reason... use the savings for marketing.

  • warp

    1 year ago

    Job creation

    One of the companies that is supposedly saving money because of the HST would be the LOG EXPORTING company, Timberwest. I fully expect to hear that they will be building a multitude of new mills on the Island, and return to life as a LUMBER company.

    They will be able to employ some of the thousands that lost their jobs through the Liberal/Big Business attack on unions over the past several years.

    Mind you, I will not hold my breath while I wait. Blue doesn't look good on me.

  • warp

    1 year ago

    New Party

    How do I copywrite a name for a middle-of-the-road political party?

    Middle
    Of
    THE
    Road
    Party

    The MOTHER (gotta love acronyms) of all parties, and if we form this party, and win an election, we will have the MOTHER of all parties - on the taxpayers back - same as any other party parties.

  • Jerry Munro

    1 year ago

    Motherhood...

    "The MOTHER (gotta love acronyms) of all parties, and if we form this party, and win an election, we will have the MOTHER of all parties - on the taxpayers back - same as any other party parties." Warped. 8-)

    Yup.

    Which is why I primarily advocate for a movement of the citizenry outside of all Party loyalties That said, it MAY prove useful over the course of that struggle to take back the economy and the country, and infuse both with a significant new model of democry, to have a political party on the "inside", helping to throw monkey wrenches into the gears of the status quo. It could advocate for and as well, create laws that facilitate the people outside taking power over the economy, and in the suppression of capitalist power.

  • Driftwood

    1 year ago

    Excuse me...

    The truth about neocons


    Alice in Wonderland
    Thanks, just seeing if the links will work :)

  • Driftwood

    1 year ago

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.