- Ms Kaye is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Mary Carlisle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Prem Gill is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nancy Flight is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Justin Everett is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- John Westover is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nora Etches is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Edward Henderson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Bharadwaj Chandramouli is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Dean Chatterson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Marius Scurtescu is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Robert Parkes is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- James Murton is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Susan Doyle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Vincent Strgar is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Helen Spiegelman is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Subir Guin is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Kimball Finigan is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joanne Manley is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- David Leach is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
Call to Investigate Forest Camp 'Nightmare'
Workers tell of ordeal as BC Fed demands probe into why protections weren't enforced.
'Like hostages': Workers near Golden given spoiled food, no drinking water. Photo: BC Fed
On July 21, 28 workers from a forestry camp near Golden were rescued from brutal working conditions.
Now the B.C. Federation of Labour is calling for an investigation into how the camp's conditions managed to escape detection. Surrey-based Khaira Enterprises operated the camp under a government contract with a safety certificate through B.C. Timber Sales.
"It's clear that these people were not protected, it's clear that enforcement failed," Federation of Labour president Jim Sinclair said. "Now we have to find the answer of how to fix that so that no other worker has to go through this experience."
Since the camp seems to have operated entirely under the radar, Sinclair said, there's no way to be certain how long these conditions had existed in Khaira Enterprises' camps, nor if there are others out there with similar conditions.
"It was sanctioned by the government because there was no enforcement to change it, and it went on for years," Sinclair said after the press conference. "Now we have a chance to change it and shame on us if we don't. Shame on this government and shame on British Columbia if we don't now find out how this happened and stop it from happening again."
The camp, located on Bluewater Creek about 40 kilometres from Golden, had no drinking water or toilet facilities. The workers slept in a pair of shipping containers and cleared brush seven days a week for ten to 14 hours, plus hours of travel time, with minimal breaks.
'We felt as though we were held hostage'
"We were very lucky to run into creeks in some of our blocks," said one worker, 24-year-old Christine Barker, a single mother. "It was a relief for us because we were not allowed to leave the block, the workplace. . . We'd literally sip from the creek so we'd have at least water."
Workers were given breakfasts of peanut butter and jam and dinners of unrefrigerated chicken and rice, with no meals in between. Much of the food they did receive was spoiled, said another worker, Jean-Claude Nabulizi of Winnipeg.
"The food itself was not sufficient," Nabulizi said. "But when we complained that we were not satisfied, the boss said 'there's nothing else I can do, let's call it a day, we're gonna see about tomorrow.' You can't complain that much because if they kick you out of the camp you're on your own. You've got nowhere to go."
Khaira Enterprises charged them a daily $25 camp fee. Barker said the camp's boss and supervisors lived separately and had their own cook.
"I've never heard of anything like it. To be honest with you, I've never heard these kind of outright gross working conditions anywhere. And in a camp funded by the government," Sinclair said.
Where workers slept: mats crammed into box-like quarters. Photo: BC Fed.
The workers, most of whom are citizens or permanent residents from Burundi or the Republic of Congo, say they were mostly or in some cases entirely unpaid. When they were issued partial paycheques on July 17, they were refused transportation from the site to cash them. And when they stopped working to protest their treatment, they were denied food.
"We felt as though we were being held as hostages," said Barker.
RCMP failed to connect: worker
Another worker contacted the RCMP, said Barker, but the officer he spoke to misheard him when he gave their location. The camp's on-site manager simply didn't answer his phone when the police called him, she said.
Barker walked into town to call for help, but it was a group of recreational fishers who ultimately drew the authorities to the camp. The fishers contacted the Ministry of Forests on July 21 when they saw that the camp was burning garbage, and the workers were moved out shortly thereafter.
The rescued workers were fed by a church in Golden and lodged in a local motel before traveling home on bus tickets provided by the province. Without that help, Barker said, many of them wouldn't have had the money to get home.
Ban firm from province says BC Fed
The ministry has taken away Khaira Enterprises' license for a year, but the Federation of Labour is demanding that the company be permanently banned from operating in British Columbia. Sinclair said that they are also asking for full back-pay for the workers, amounting to tens of thousands of dollars overall. He said that if Khaira Enterprises can't pay, the province should step up.
"They were working for British Columbians, in their forests, under a government contract," Sinclair said.
Khaira Enterprises has also filed records of employment that indicate that the workers quit, which Sinclair said must be amended so that the workers will qualify for unemployment insurance.
At present, most of the workers are broke. Barker said she has about $40 to her name and is looking into social assistance to help her family.
Though the Tyee attempted them to contact them, Khaira Enterprises had not returned a request for comment by press time. ![]()




19
Login or register to post comments
Camero409
1 year ago
Must be a LIbARal supporter
to get away with that.
Bailey
1 year ago
Serfs and slaves
I'm a fan of the BC Federation of Labour, but in my view their response is entirely inadequate. These people ought not to be merely banned from the province, they should be banned from walking around free anywhere.
Slavery is a crime. Not only here, but everywhere. A crime against humanity. Wage slavery should be no different. To say, 'well, we pretended to pay them" should be no defense against so serious a crime.
This company should be confiscated and its principals and managers should be arrested and tried publically. And whichever fool minister let the contract in the first place, along with whoever removed the oversight of contracts in the first place, need to be lined up and asked some very tough questions. They re certainly accomplices.
I think the unscathed success of the Skytrain fiasco, where Latin American workers were imported to dig up Cambie Street, kept in camps and paid almost nothing has encouraged those powerful interests who clearly believe that power is enough to protect them from the most horrible abuses.
As long as they can keep their freedom, and even keep the money, they will continue. If we rely on heir personal values or their consiences we lose and they win.
They don't have any, you see.
Global Citizen
1 year ago
"BC, The Best Place on
"BC, The Best Place on Earth'?
alive
1 year ago
same old, same old
So that company is banned for a year, nothing wil stop them from setting up another dummy front and start bidding all over again on government contracts!
I bet their names are well hidden and protected under some fancy lawyers banner.
Bailey
1 year ago
A good question
Camero409 above makes a point.
Someone should check to see what contributions the principals of this outfit have made to the political campaigns and the Party. That's a pattern we've seen a lot recently.
Van Isle
1 year ago
This sort of crap has been
This sort of crap has been going on since I can remember. The forestry industry has more than their fair share of scam-artists who take advantage of people when the economy goes for a nose dive. What protects them? 1)they work in isolated areas. 2)workers are threatened with being fired and lose wages. 3)workers will be blacklisted and won't find another job. 4) Boss promises the worker the world but has some form of excuse of why he can't pay right now, but if you hang in there he'll make good in 2 weeks, which doesn't happen and the worker finally quits. I remember working for an outfit back in the early 70's who wouldn't pay me. I finally threatened the employer with legal action. The owner came after me and promised to do some physical action on me, but gave me cash, which wasn't the full amount owing, and told me to take it or leave it.
puppyg
1 year ago
Charges and ultimately, jail
Charges and ultimately, jail time are what I would like to see come out of this investigation. Expose the people behind Khaira Enterprises. I see this as a natural consequence of Gordon Campbell's core values at work.
AHHA
1 year ago
Van Isle is correct
I went through the same abuse when brushing that Van Isle reports. This stuff is not uncommon folks, lowest bidder and all that in part creates these conditions. Along with little to no oversight by WorkSafe BC and the (ghost of) the Employment Standards Branch. I also experienced this crap when I went logging and after two years I just couldn't face it anymore and left. Similar things occur in Construction mostly around safety where workers must compromise or face what Van Isle has described. There are few reputable Construction firms the majority are OSH deficient. Most companies get there COR or SAFE accreditation and flaunt the rules anyway (getting that accreditation is very easy, and the people who run these accreditation "partners of WorkSafe BC" SAFE and COR scenario's are empire and nepotism purveyors). WorkSafeBC is one of the most hypocritical org's going, but struts around like a righteous mf all the while turning a blind eye, hardly ever laying criminal charges, and screwing injured workers with alarming regularity. Hey WorkSafe BC when your call display reads Victoria Legislature calling, don't answer the phone!
How do these 'people' sleep?
Phay
1 year ago
Campaign Funds
The government of the day has seen fit to make sure the public's access to campaign funds information is as difficult and time consuming as possible. The data is in jpg format and is therefore unsearchable. One must painstakingly plod through it page by page. That said, I have no doubt they are a contributor.
the real ODB
1 year ago
had enough yet?
This is what you get when you elect a ideologically driven, laissez-faire free market capitalist cabal to govern. It's big tax cuts (which only benefit corporations, big business and the wealthy), downloading of service costs on to the rest of us, and de-regulation which aids and abets scum bags like this outfit. All of the above comments are right on the money. De-regulation of industry and business is akin to letting a pedophile run a youth camp. So BC, had enough yet?
Luck
1 year ago
Call to Investigate Forest Camp 'Nightmare'
Another great exposure article by the Tyee. Good work.
Now were is the NDP on this one???
Or is it too politically sensitive or not sensitive enough yet!!
We need a political party with balls to address the insane things happening these days under our governement rule and prevention is the key here.
dorothy
1 year ago
We all contribute
to the culture of the 'lowest bidder'. I just had some major renovation done on my dwelling, and have had more than a dozen people I know, most of whom themselves work in decently paid and safe union-jobs tell me I was wet behind the ears, because the company from whom I bought the services wasn't dirt cheap, partly because they do quality work and accordingly enjoy a good reputation, but also because they give a damn about the folks who work with them and do not piss on safety rules and provisions. This was not mild-mannered in all case. There were a couple of people who told me, with discernible;e anger that 'they could have gotten me a better deal', as if I had broken some important social rule I never bought into in the first place. I was taken aback by the strength of that peer pressure and so I think we must acknowledge that as part of the culture of a LOT of people out there. Walmart is getting us in the back!
maudiebones
1 year ago
Google listing for Khaira
I just googled for Khaira Enterprises and found this listing:
Khaira Enterprises Ltd. - Home
Khaira Enterprises Ltd. Surrey, BC. There is a pleasure in the pathless woods, There is a rapture on the lonely shore, There is society, where none intrudes ...
www.khaira-reforestation.com/default.html - Cached
The Khaira website is basically empty, with this message in bold type:
"This website is being currently updated,
we thank you for your patience."
Bailey
1 year ago
If I was king of the world
What our increasingly corrupt situation seems to need more and more in these days of increasing technologically supported secrecy is some serious truth.
Lots and lots of it.
We see lobbyists and corrupted government types going to draconian lengths to prevent people from knowing the truth.
I've always believed that lies are the most profound kind of truth. They cast a shadow of deceit, and inside that shadow is the thing they most fear to have you know. Truth.
From time to time on this site there have been conversations about the nature of revolution, and the need for reform, and the ways to oppose corrupt power.
We see this need increasingly at conferences and meetings where the powerful display their fear of the people and of the truth by billion dollar security bills.
I think back to the revolutions of the past, the ones that worked and the ones that failed, and I think that the difference seems to be in the way they are carried forward. All revolutions start with high intentions and principles, and some even proceed by them. When they don't, failure ensues.
Examples are many. The French Revolution vs. the American offer good contrasts, since they were in so many respects different sides of the same story.
The French held mass executions of Aristocrats and their families, mostly innocent of crime. The executions were murders, and corrupted the noble cause fatally right at its infancy. The American did not, simply expelled the enemy and then opened trade.
France got Napoleon, America got a trade empire that prospered and fed the world until the Second World War, before it was in it's turn betrayed by the immoral powerful we see there today.
Same thing happened to the Russian one. It fell into the hands of monstrous murderers, and never recovered.
To succeed, I think, a movement for change must abide by the high principles it espouses, and punish properly all crimes committed, even by themselves and even for high reasons. It must abide by the principles it hopes to establish.
I think, if I were a revolutionary today, which I'm almost sorry to say I'm not, I believe I would become a network of hidden hackers, ferreting out all he secrets crouching in the shadows of all the big lies, and expose them without fear or favour.
Shout them out loud, with names and addresses intact, and dollar amounts and banking information would be my favourites. I cannot believe that this slavery could exist in Canada, a country of decent people in a decent society, unless money had changed hands.
Any information regarding the secret accounts of those whose duty is to protect that decency, and fail utterly to do so should be found and shouted out. All minutes of all secret meetings in every secret corner of our world should be made visible for all to see.
Only then will we have a chance to restore the decency for which we and our forebears have paid so dearly.
VivianLea Doubt
1 year ago
thanks for that post, Bailey
I enjoyed it. Just one thing I want to point out, and that is that we do not need the 'network of hidden hackers'. There is you and me, and all the other ordinary citizens out there with the tools and the will to carry on the public conversation...and make no mistake, the public conversation is making a difference. Aside from the hype about the internet age, there truly is the potential to reinvigorate democracy simply by begining to have this conversation.
I think you are so right, Dorothy, about the pervasivness of the Wal-Mart ideology ...I find it difficult to understand that someone would crow about getting the 'cheapest'...but perhaps it is also a measure of the hard times workers' face in making ends meet. What is so difficult about this story, is as someone else pointed out, that shoddy working conditions and dangerous lack of safety considerations and outright cheating of employees are going on in industry, and small business, and work places of every description across the entire spectrum of work. Think it isn't happening at your local restaurant? Think again.
I cannot say it better than Bailey: we need to bring decency back as something we endeavour to live up in all aspects of our lives.
RickW
1 year ago
There migh well be a case made......
......for hate crime, and criminal prosecution of the company and it's principals.
Bailey
1 year ago
By the way...
Just an aside to the author, Ryan Elias.
Very nice work for your practicum piece. Well done.
Be proud.
lynn
1 year ago
Yes.... Well Done, Ryan Elias
Bailey wrote:
"Shout them out loud, with names and addresses intact, and dollar amounts and banking information would be my favourites. I cannot believe that this slavery could exist in Canada, a country of decent people in a decent society, unless money had changed hands.
Any information regarding the secret accounts of those whose duty is to protect that decency, and fail utterly to do so should be found and shouted out. All minutes of all secret meetings in every secret corner of our world should be made visible for all to see.
Only then will we have a chance to restore the decency for which we and our forebears have paid so dearly."
Yes, very much agree with VivianLea, thanks so much for that post, Bailey.
http://www.wikileaks.org/wiki/Category:Canada
Frank
1 year ago
Bailey
Well said