News

Mi'kmaq Chief Wants an Apology from Gordon Campbell

Chief says BC premier reneged on promise to have children's choir in Games opening ceremonies.

By Andrew MacLeod, 23 Oct 2009, TheTyee.ca

campbell-medals.jpg

Gordon Campbell poses with recently unveiled Olympic medals.

Mi'kmaq Chief Misel Joe said the children in his community need an apology from British Columbia Premier Gordon Campbell after an invitation to sing at the opening ceremonies of the 2010 Olympic Winter Games in Vancouver was rescinded.

"There's no shame in making a mistake, even for a premier," Joe said.

Two years ago, Campbell heard the Se't A'newey First Nation Choir, which is based in Conne River, Newfoundland, sing at the National Aboriginal Women's Summit in Corner Brook.

Campbell, according to various reports, attended the event with Newfoundland Premier Danny Williams and was so impressed by the choir that he invited them to sing at the opening ceremonies for the 2010 Winter Olympic Games in Vancouver.

Joe said, "I was floored when Campbell said, 'I want you to perform at the Olympic Games in 2010' and then invited them."

There was never an official invitation, but the children in the choir and the people in the community took Campbell seriously, said Joe. "You don't make those kinds of promises to children and not have them take you serious."

'Your talent has to be known'

Others, including Newfoundland Premier Danny Williams, appear to have also taken Campbell seriously.

A 2007 article in The Coaster, a newspaper serving a region of southern Newfoundland known as the Coast of Bays, quoted Williams saying, "It's great, it's not only national exposure, it's international exposure at probably the single most important event that's going to take place in this country in the next four years."

The Olympic performance would be good for the community, he said. "Every time I speak nationally at aboriginal functions and other functions I always speak about Conne River and what a model it is for the rest of the country. Now they'll be able to see some of the children and young people who have been produced in that great community."

The same article quoted the choir's conductor, Brenda Jeddore, saying Premier Campbell assured her that he was serious and said "Your talent has to be known to the world."

The invitation was an honour and a blessing and "did so much for the children's self-esteem," she said.

Two years preparing

The choir, which has performed as far away as Japan and is scheduled to sing for Prince Charles and Camilla, the Duchess of Cornwall, during the royal couple's November visit to Canada, spent two years preparing and raising money for the trip.

Then this week, four months before the Games, Joe learned through Newfoundland officials that despite Campbell's invitation, the choir was not welcome to sing at the opening ceremonies.

"He had no authority to make that promise or invitation," said Joe. It's up to Olympic officials, not the premier, who sings at the Games, he said. The message was clear that Campbell's promise was worthless, he said.

As a chief, Joe said he knows politicians sometimes make promises they can't keep. "Aboriginal people, we know that. We've been living that for 600 years." For children though, it is harder to accept, he said. "To make that promise and not follow through in some way, that's something our children will live with all their lives."

Campbell was returning today from Greece, where he attended a ceremony to light the Olympic torch, and was unavailable for comment.

'Dealing with the hurt'

A spokesperson in Premier Williams' office said Williams was campaigning in a byelection and was unavailable. Questions on the matter should go to VANOC, the committee organizing the Winter Games, she said.

VANOC media officials did not respond to queries by posting time.

CBC Newfoundland interviewed choir member Shannon Jo Hinks, a Grade 12 student. She and other choir members had been preparing traditional songs and clothes for the performance, she said, and couldn't believe the performance was cancelled. "I was really, really upset," she said. "A lot of us ... just looked at each other and we're like, 'What, we're not going now? Why would they do that to us?' "

The St. John's Telegram quoted an e-mail from a community member: "A part of each and every one of these children died last night."

Joe said he is writing a letter to Campbell and would encourage Williams to do the same. "We're just dealing with the hurt that's taken place right now," he said. "We are trying to deal with it as best we can in our community."  [Tyee]

24  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • G West

    2 years ago

    Hmm!

    Guess there aren't any Mi'kmaq treaty land claims in BC that the CEO can pander to.

  • demotto

    2 years ago

    Screech

    Must have had one too many that day eh. At least the young folks got first hand education on the fact that when a politicians lips are moving they are lying.

  • circle A

    2 years ago

    Campbell and vanoc

    and the ioc are not worthy of the of the presence of such honourable souls.First nation elders will know how to console these children,They have much experience with sleazy liars.

  • wstander

    2 years ago

    He should be forgiven

    "He had no authority to make that promise or invitation," said Joe. It's up to Olympic officials, not the premier, who sings at the Games, he said. The message was clear that Campbell's promise was worthless, he said.

    You can't really fault Campbell. He thought he was dealing with something unimportant like the BC legislature where his out of the legislature pronouncements are accepted as authoritative.

    Of course, the net result is the same- his promises are worthless in any event.

  • ME2

    2 years ago

    Lapsus linguae

    Maybe he forgot he wasn't at an election rally.

  • monty

    2 years ago

    no wonder the natives are restless

    In August a friend and I went to an event at the Museum of Anthropology in Vancouver. There was a young native man there doing wonderful carvings. We asked if he would be at the Olympics? He said he and his friend had a contract to be there but had received notice the day before that it was cancelled.

    At the Aboriginal Festival celebrating Indian Summer at Robson Square(Sept. 26/27)I asked an elder if Campbell had been there. He said "He sent some young guy. None of us knew who he was. Campbell is hiding." No mention of Strahl who is supposed to be the Aboriginal Minister but rarely meets with any of the local chiefs most notably the ones who last summer wanted their road (which leads to Pemberton) repaired and some help for the homes under blue tarps. Strahl refused to meet with that chief even though Stephen Hume wrote a wonderful story about their plight in the Sun.
    If repaired their road is the logical way to reach Whistler when the Sea to Sky falls apart.

    Little wonder that the natives are selling T-shirts labelled Canada, our home and native land, with 5 ancestors across the shirt or Homeland Security Department and a picture of a native holding a gun.

    Expect to see protests along the route of the flaming torch as the natives feel very disabused as no one ever consulted them in this continuing bunch of nonsense. Current level of debt $7.2 billion and rising.

    Then today, a new roof for BC Place to satisfy soccer fans or those testerone-steroid-filled fools who fight while a beer swilling crowd
    becomes more and more aggressive. It's lunacy!

    Noticed Podmore of Concert Properties say the contract has "a fixed price."
    What a novel idea! What a change! Will it last?

    This native is restless, too. Cheers.

  • Karen D.

    2 years ago

    Stand by invitation VANOC

    VANOC would do this province proud if they were to make a space at the opening ceremonies for these talented kids. Campbell can redeem himself by renewing the offer, when he oppologizes, and making a donation to help get them here. It is not only the right thing to do but would be a performance that would be appreciated internationally.

  • wayfarer

    2 years ago

    Reconciliation (of sweater designs)

    I think on the day that VANOC was finalizing its artist set list for the Games, John Furlong and Gordon Campbell were off in the Cowichan Valley, trying on native sweaters, to see which design they liked best.

    So much for aboriginal relations and reconciliation.

  • Chris H

    2 years ago

    Was there any doubt?

    Now they know what every British Columbian knows: "The message was clear that Campbell's promise was worthless."

  • mikev

    2 years ago

    VANOC

    Heh. Nice Inukshuk, might as well be a Tiki, they both come from about as far away from Vancouver. And yeah way to go with the sweater rip off. This just tops it off. What do you expect from a bunch of marketing droids? Have you seen the mascots? At least it looks like they got the medals right. Ridiculous circus.

  • samuidave (not verified)

    2 years ago

    Sad on a couple fronts

    First, it is sad he coins Campbell's behaviour in reneging as a mistake. Mistakes happen by accident, not through a deficit in honour and character as Gordon Campbell clearly illustrates repeatedly with the citizens of BC.

    Second, it is sad that Campbell has not bent over backwards to apologize to the children, but should we honestly expect anything more?

  • Norman Farrell

    2 years ago

    Encana? Plutonic? Marine Harvest? Your friend needs help.

    Campbell should ask one of his wealthy corporate friends to put up enough cash to give the choir a trip to the Olympics. He could ask any of a number of different companies. Surely, given the billions in tax breaks provided to these big guys, they could cough up 50 grand to save their boy from further embarrassment. How about it Encana? Plutonic? Marine Harvest

  • SharingIsGood

    2 years ago

    apology for Mi'kmaq Chief Misel Joe

    On behalf of the people of BC, I offer heartfelt condolences and my humble apologies to Mi'kmaq Chief Misel Joe and his people for the rudeness of our premier.

  • SharingIsGood

    2 years ago

    notes about Premier Campbell for Chief Misel Joe

    I am afraid that even if our premier were to apologise, it would mean very little. He apologised to the people of BC for drinking and driving; and since then, he has increased alcohol sales, increased the number of venues alcohol can be sold and increased the number of hours in a day it can be sold. He has also increased gambling. Violence has increased by a substantial amount under his leadership. Further, he has made deep cuts to alcohol and gambling addictions treatment programs following his apology.

    Chief Misel Joe, your people are not alone in being fooled by this man. Campbell's very own people have been led to believe that he is the best choice through three elections; and, after every election, things have gotten worse for all but the very rich. Even though we have a very beautiful province that is blessed with abundant natural resources, BC has led the nation in child poverty for the last 6 years. Mi'kmaq Chief Misel Joe, Gordon Campbell also mistreats the children of BC. I apologise to you and your people that I have not done enough to stop our province from electing a leader who has such little honour. It is a continuing disgrace for me and the people of BC to be represented by a person of such weak character.

  • lynn

    2 years ago

    Caption for photo with this article:

    Double Trouble:

    Yikes!...an Albatross wearing an Albatross around his neck!

    "Ah ! well a-day ! what evil looks
    Had I from old and young !
    Instead of the cross, the Albatross
    About my neck was hung."

  • Skywalker

    2 years ago

    I could have done without...

    ... that grinning mug. That it followed the one of Falcon on another column was too much for me today.

  • freebear

    2 years ago

    Gag me with an owelimpic torch!

    Listen!

    Is that the sound of sheeple waking up?

    No, just owelimpic orgy boosters!

  • Skywalker

    2 years ago

    Photo caption?

    "I'll be gone suckers, but you'll be paying for decades! Fun eh?"

  • RickW

    2 years ago

    For What Good It May Do........

    .....I wrote to Danny Williams, urging him to pursue this issue to the Nth degree.

  • RickW

    2 years ago

    The Choir Will Perform Now!

    Just not at the opening ceremonies...........

  • Tahsis Tattler

    2 years ago

    All is not well with olympic promises

    After seeing the exposition of the Olympic dress ware and the THEFT of the Cowachin Sweater by the Bay, I went to Duncan and bought the real thing and hope that the store chokes on what they have.

  • hawklie

    2 years ago

    Mik`maq Chief & Campbell

    In 1960 I watched a Western movie. The Indian chief said,"White man speaks with fork tongue."

    Oh to G West: one does not pander to a treaty. One may invoke such and such paragraph in a treaty. One panders, as I am doing, to your rather poor English.

    Hawk

  • G West

    2 years ago

    Hawk: Clearly, you can't read.

    Guess there aren't any Mi'kmaq treaty land claims in BC that the CEO can pander to.

    Obviously, 'pander' refers not to the treaty but to the 'land claims' that are part of the treaty negotiations. Treaty, in that sentence is functioning as an adjective. Not all that difficult to understand, I would have thought.

  • Mary Billy

    2 years ago

    Campbell and the Mi'kmaq kids choir

    This was probably yet one more case of Campbell saying something and then immediately forgetting about it, as though it had automatically happened. How many times have we had him do that locally, but in this instance it was a bunch of kids who thought they had a personal invitation from the premier. I agree that their own people should have been in contact in the meantime at some point, but all the same it's the same old same old with poor old Gordo.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.