News

A Guest at the Alcoholics Anonymous Roundup

What the people of Esketemc know about battling addiction.

By Claude Adams, 12 Aug 2009, TheTyee.ca

roundupimglarger.jpg

The Round Dance that opens the Saturday session of the Roundup. Photo by Claude Adams.

Related

"We are only as sick as our secrets." If the people of Alkali Lake needed a slogan (and they don't), this would serve. I found it on a piece of paper pinned to the wall of the Pow-Wow Arbor, a wooden open-air structure where, every year for the past 33 years, the natives of Alkali Lake, B.C. have hosted an Alcoholics Anonymous Roundup.

Here, along with alcoholics from around the world, from as far away as Australia and Mexico and even China, the townspeople of Alkali Lake (or Esketemc, as they call it) gather to share 'secrets' of how alcohol almost destroyed them a half-century ago, and how they saved themselves. Both the secrets they relate in their stories -- brutally honest, confessional -- and the telling of them are parts of the healing, in a sobriety program that has caught the attention of problem drinkers everywhere.

Health director Irene Johnson, a small, squat woman who has her own history with booze, says this openness is key. "We've been in so much pain," she says, "that it's easier now to be honest about it rather than keep shoving it down, you know, getting sick and committing suicide."

'That's how easy it was to get alcohol'

The stories are pathetic, horrific and unnerving. Binge-drinking by children as young as eight, sexual abuse and physical assault, the despair of people dispossessed by residential schools and other agents of colonization. But this is not time or place for excuses or finger-pointing. Says Chief Charlene Belleau: "It's time to quit blaming the government, quit blaming the churches, quit blaming anybody for where we were at as people, if we're going to recover from 150 years of residential school policy and the pain that's been there for all of us."

The AA philosophy is to take responsibility. Still, it's hard not to apportion blame. One native woman tells of how as an eight-year-old girl, she and other children in Alkali Lake would steal money from their parents, mail it in an envelope to Williams Lake with instructions, and then wait for the white man's taxis to deliver bottles of wine promptly "at four-thirty on Tuesdays and Fridays, right to our door."

It was a modern variant of supplying firewater to the Indians, except this was wine, and these were adolescents, learning how to lose themselves in addiction even before their teens. "If you ever wonder why we because alcoholics in Esketemc, that's how easy it was to get alcohol," the woman said. "I was on Skid Row in my own home." Today, she is sober, has been for more than 20 years, but she still calls herself "an alcoholic." Dry or not, you’re an alcoholic for life. It's a burden that follows you to the grave.

At the AA Roundup

You don't get invited to the Alkali Lake Roundup unless you're an addict, or in the family of one, but two weeks ago I rented a car and went anyway, uninvited. I violated another rule by bringing recording equipment -- the tenets of AA, after all, emphasize anonymity. But I wanted to see (and record) the phenomenon of the Alkali Lake first-hand. Was it myth, or hard reality, or a little of both?

It's not hard to find the 'Powwow Arbor,' as they call the site of the annual AA Roundup. Just outside Williams Lake, you leave Highway 97 and exit on Dog Creek Road, and then you just follow the signs. You arrive at an open field, filled with teepees and RV's and small knots of people drinking coffee and soda. The focus of attention is the Arbor, a kind of open-air wooden corral with turf in the centre and elevated benches all around. Nearby is a sweat lodge, and a hill where alcoholics can fast and meditate.

I was an unexpected stranger, but I was not turned away. I told organizer Ken Johnson that I wanted to shoot video and record some audio tape, and he said okay. He pointed me to the coffee urn. What struck me immediately was how easily and effortlessly the natives and non-natives mixed, and how they shared the common candid language of addiction.

Mid-way through the afternoon, a pretty 16-year-old blonde girl from southern California takes the microphone and introduces herself. "I'm Helen and I'm an alcoholic/addict," she begins. The people sitting in the corral respond as one: "Hi Helen."

"I'm really really grateful to be here sober," Helen continues, with a confidence that belies her age. "I have 107 days today (APPLAUSE). It's the longest I've have been ever sober and it feels amazing... I should be dead right now. I always say I'm on borrowed time. I should be dead considering all the things I did. I'm so glad I'm alive, which is a huge change."

Procession of teen recovering alcoholics

One by one, a procession of native teens then take the microphone. Trevor, in training with the Armed Forces and leaving soon for Afghanistan, says he will miss his parents. Irvin, in his teens and sober for six years (more applause), says "it's an awesome experience to see what life is really about instead of waking up in a ditch, or in somebody's car." Another young woman, her four-year-daughter standing next to her, can't stop crying as she talks about her frequent alcohol relapses. But with the help of the people around her, she says, better days are coming.

Listening to the stories is Patrick Haggerson, a therapist with the Betty Ford Institute in California, famous as the addiction treatment centre-of-choice for Hollywood celebrities. Haggerson comes to Alkali Lake once a month, both to teach and to learn. He's intrigued by how the community has integrated the 12-step program of Alcoholics Anonymous with a number of native practices.

"Alkali Lake is an example of how they kind of blended the two paths, and that's of great interest to us... Even though it's a small community they have regular AA meetings every week, they have support services and social services, and they've eliminated a great many of their social problems or at least reduced them. They are able to get funding and bring in outside support like me. I mean, that to me is huge success."

Alkali Lake first came to the world's attention in the mid-1980s, with the release of a documentary called The Honour of All. In the natives' own voices, and with re-enactments of their own experiences, the film tells how the Reserve went from a nearly 100 per cent alcoholic rate to nearly 100 per cent sobriety, in a decade. They did it with hard-core social action, and relentless social pressure. Bootleggers were tracked down and their operations closed, alcoholics were given food vouchers instead of their social assistance cheques, and problem drinkers were told to go into treatment, or go to jail.

It was rough social engineering, and the two pioneers of the program, Andy and Phyllis Chelsea, met a lot of local resistance from their neighbors. But they prevailed and, bolstered by the international publicity generated by The Honour of All, the Chelseas toured the world and told the Alkali Lake story. They, and the town, became the poster children of the sobriety movement.

"It's never gonna go away"

Today, Andy Chelsea has given up his leading role in the program, and he's dismayed at the number of teenaged addicts on the Reserve. He believes that as the sobriety program became professionalized, it focused too much on individual addicts, instead of families. In short, he says, they forgot about the kids. When I ask if addiction is still a problem on the Reserve, it provokes a sardonic laugh. "Oh yeah, every kind of addiction... and it always will be. It's never gonna go away. If you want miracles I think Jesus better come down from up there and tell everybody you're not gonna drink ever again in your life. That's the only way it's gonna happen. But He's not gonna do that."

Chelsea guesses that the addiction rate in Alkali Lake today is "around 40 percent" but then quickly adds that this number includes drugs, and that the reserve's population has doubled in the last 30 years to about 700 people. He doesn't want to be seen as a nay-sayer. "No, it's not a magic formula. But it works. If it's going to save the lives of 10 people... it's worth it."

Patrick Haggerson says it's a mistake to play the percentages game where native addiction is concerned. "It's ridiculous. Go to Williams Lake and ask what is your percentage of alcoholism. They'd laugh at you... I don't think that is a realistic model to use for (measuring) success. It's better to look at the resources that are active in a community that supports sobriety."

What Alkali Lake offers is not only resources, but also continuity. Keith, a 62-year-old non-native man from Fraser Lake, says he has been coming here for the last ten years "to recharge my batteries and get my life in perspective." His friend Marty, from Kamloops, has been coming since 1978, and he talks with the vivid imagery used by many recovering alcoholics. "The door of heaven didn't open and bring me in; the door of hell opened and let me out... I hear on the inside now, and I'm very busy listening to myself."

The program is also inclusive. Recovering alcoholics are encouraged to bring their kids, even very young ones. It's important, say community leaders, that children not be shielded from the realities of addiction. "We always invite families," says Health Director Irene Johnson. "When I was growing up I felt there was no hope, nothing would ever get better, so the option was either suicide or stay drunk, because sooner or later i would die from it anyway. I don't want my granddaughter to have that hopeless feeling. So we invited whoever and they come here and they're part of us. We need to bring hope to our children."

Secrets and healing

It's important not to over-idealize Alkali Lake, however. The Reserve, like the rest of Canada's native population, has issues that are as serious as alcohol. Irene Johnson summarized the dilemma this way: "Okay, I'm sober. Now what?" There's still abuse, child abandonment, violence, poverty, alienation. Those problems are still there when the hangover passes and, if left unresolved, they can undermine the most rigorous sobriety programs.

Healing is hard. The next challenge for the natives of Alkali Lake, as with other native Canadians, is to reveal the deeply-held "secrets" of their residential school experience, as the Truth and Reconciliation Commission begins its work of truth-telling. There is more there to recover from than sexual abuse by white priests and nuns -- the toxic legacy of the schools is permeating through the generations, and the stories are not easy to tell. Native leaders warn that communities need to be ready to deal with the consequences of disclosures of native-on-native abuse.

But Alkali Lake has taken the first important steps -- driving home the message that addiction, and the despair that comes with it, is a shared communal experience, as is the healing. Mildred, a native woman in her 40s, carried her own secret belief while she was drinking. "For a long time," she says, "I thought it (alcoholism) was only happening to me." Now she knows better.  [Tyee]

8  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • appalbarry

    2 years ago

    AA may not be all that is advertised.

    Several years ago Penn and Teller took on AA, and presented a pretty interesting analysis. In a nutshell AA's success rate would seem to be no better than just going it alone.

    I know lots of people who swear by AA, but it's always good to be little skeptical, especially of religious groups.

    http://www.sho.com/site/ptbs/episodes.do?episodeid=121067&ep=210

    "There's no proof that AA or any other 12-Step program is any more effective than going cold turkey, doing things in moderation or getting medical help. And there's a debate raging whether alcoholism is even a disease! The quasi-religious 12-step groups have America brainwashed into believing that a higher power will take care of everything."

  • leftofcentre

    2 years ago

    AA is about taking responsibility for yourself...

    First off, AA is not a religious organization. It's a community of local groups that try to support each other in conquering addiction. The groups may have things in common, whether it be their job, their nationality, hobbies or activities they enjoy, and yes...even religion. But AA groups come from all walks of life. I'm sure you could probably find an AA group of Atheists if you tried. And people are more likely to kick addictions when they have the support of others.

    As for Alcoholism being a disease? I'm sure it must be better to get your medical information from comedians such as Penn & Teller than trained professionals.

  • Booker

    2 years ago

    Religious

    AA arose out of a particular Christian tradition and much of its teaching relies on the belief in a deity or "higher power" (with the disclaimer that the higher power can be anything you want, but if you REALLY want to recover you know what to believe in...). Some people think there is too much of a reliance on magical thinking. There are atheist and freethinkers AA groups in some cities. The success rate of AA is unknown and may never be known because of the anonymity and no record keeping.

  • granthams

    2 years ago

    Grateful Member of Alcoholics Anonymous

    I am alive today because of AA. I sobered up about twenty years ago and still go to AA regularly, It is not religious but it is spiritual. I am an atheist and find inspiration from the human spirit. I listen to the stories in AA and am awed by the ability of humans to rebuild their lives and redeem themselves after sinking to depths of despair and hopelessness that are beyond description and by the honest manner in which members are able to articulate their stories and their feelings.
    'The only requirement for AA membership is a desire to stop drinking'. In the early days of AA they said 'an honest desire to stop drinking' but that was changed as many AAs (like me) do not come into the program with honest intentions but rather to get someone off their backs. I came, I came to, I came to believe.

  • macsasquatch

    2 years ago

    disease? or dis-ease?

    Disease? Maybe! I figured that I had to go to AA back then. I forced myself to every meeting, but, oddly, after every meeting was glad that I had made it there. I don't think that I would have been alive more than a few months more had I not gone to AA.
    One aspect of disease:I did come across soemething a few decades ago about some alkies metabolizing alcohol differently so that it produced a toxin, the antidote for which is alcohol. I remember the sick feeling after a drink or two if I did not follow up quickly with more drinks. I remember tht once drinking almost everything else was background to ensuring the next drink. ( I had the happy capacity oto go on long sleepless binges)
    So...disease? Maybe. Even if disease here is a metaphor, or ' dis-ease',treating oneself as if having a disease can work, so why not!
    Religious? Some took it that way. I always see some aspects of various religious traditions in it. Again, if it works, what's the beef? I've had pals who said that it is not a disease, really, that AA pretends religion but has no depth, that it is a shallow philosophy, that there are pills and training that one can take to learn to drink responsibly, (I thought the slogans and such a tad puerile, until I started trying to live by them)...and so on. Those pals...well, it's their stories.
    And if AA, under the scrutiny of science and reason and such turns out to be just a non drug and alcohol social group, that's ok too.
    Actually, one of the reasons I got to AA was because someone had written a story like this in our local newspaper. So maybe this story will help someone too.

  • wayfarer

    2 years ago

    pragmatic, yet critical

    I think we need to respect people whose lives have been helped by such programs. The last think I want to do is dissuade someone from pursuing what works for them. Good for them, and all power to them. But the data also can't be ignored. The dominant therapy model for addiction in North America is the 12-step model, and fewer than half who attempt it, succeed. One stat has it around the 17% mark for success rate.

    This issue of addiction dovetails into the dominent mental health paradigm, which views mental disorders as diseases, reducing the question to biology, brain chemistry and genetic code. What does this fallacy lead to? Well, the kind of pharmaceutical industrial complex nightmares we currently see. Aside from the obvious capitalist motives behind big pharma, there's a significant cultural component to the issue. Like addiction, there is absolutely no objective test for depression, bipolar or ADHD, yet our disease model approach has believing otherwise. Forget about Generation X; amend that to Generation Rx. How is any of this about addiction? The same disease paradigm that underlies psychiatry underlies thinking about addiction and our almost blind faith in AA – which in addition to presupposing addiction as disease, also has a few Christian evangelical (sorry.. I mean ‘spiritual’) sprinkles on top for added measure.

    The fact is this: there is absolutely no biological test, be it a blood test, an MRI scan or what have you, to determine addiction or other mental illnesses in the way that there are tests to determine biological diseases. None. So if there is no test, how can it be a disease in any diagnostic sense? It can't. Which is why the success rate for a disease model approach to addiction has been a statistical failure.

    With addiction, unlike true disease, there is still a significant element of choice. The addict makes a number of choices prior to indulging (how am I going to get my booze, what am I gonna drink, where am gonna drink it, who shall I drink with, etc...). The cancer patient or diabetic does not make any such choice. If you really think about it, addiction as disease is quite a ludicrous idea and untenable in any diagnostic sense.

    Once we arrive at this distinction, we may begin to open up to alternative treatments a bit more, such as those based on harm reduction or behaviour therapy (CBT), or models used in other cultures that we don't even know much about. As for the First Nations in above article, my opinion is pragmatic - whatever works, go for it. I do find it a bit ironic that the same Christian missionary, colonialist dogma that cast these people out as pagans and animals needing to be tamed in residential schools (and turning them on to booze) is the same dogma at the root of AA. If they can develop a hybrid therapy model that incorporates their own traditions, I suspect they'll enjoy far greater long-term success than if it were simply left to AA.

  • Booker

    2 years ago

    Wayfarer

    You make many good points. I disagree that if you can't lab-test something it's not a disease. Diagnoses are based on many factors and can't always be exact or definitive. As technology progresses there are more and more ways to do physical tests for mental disorders/illnesses. I don't think people should really get hung-up on whether addiction is a disease or not (I know there is a new and controversial book out now that says addiction is primarily a choice.) Whatever addiction is, it's a problem, and it can be treated. Some people find AA helpful for that and others don't.

    One thing I do find objectionable is when courts mandate that people attend AA. It should not receive that sort of endorsement.

  • Bob Watts

    2 years ago

    AA Member for life.

    My last drink was June of 1982, am I that old now? So many of my friends died from drinking related things like oops I froze to death, and oops I hit a tree, or oops no life jacket. To me AA members are all nuts, whatever drove us to drinking, is all about Mental Illness. I have not been to an AA meeting in 14 years, due to a very toxic person at these local meetings, everyone thinks this person is the greatest, and I know the truth. Yes Mental isn't it. In my first 10 years I went to meetings every day and roundups to. The meetings filled the Void left by not drinking, and lots of good things for a sick mind. Yes AA is a form of religion, but the twist is you find the God of your choice. Sad to think I know I'm nuts, but thats OK, it's better than being nuts and not knowing it. If your in AA it's for life, because you can't run away from yourself. AA is also about finding yourself, just look in the mirror and remember what your looking at is backwards to whatever other people see when viewing you, just hold up a book next to your face while looking in the mirror and notice the words showup backwards. Ah the wisdom of an AA member, it's all pointless but hey I'm sober and alive. This BS 101 course can be found at any AA meeting tonight. It's a catch 22 you must be nuts to drink and therefor your also nuts to be sober, or some crap like that.........

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.