Vancouver Joins Towns Spooked by TILMA
Council wants more info on trade pact.
COPE's Cadman: pact 'lowers the bar'
Who really knows what will be the local impact of the Trade, Investment and Labour Mobility Agreement (TILMA)? Certainly not the Vancouver city council, which passed a motion to express its concerns yesterday.
By doing so, the biggest city in B.C. added its voice to 20 jurisdictions across the province who want to be consulted before being affected by the agreement.
"We're not opposed to TILMA. There could be some good advantages for businesses. But we would like consultation and we would like those issues to be addressed," said NPA Councillor Peter Ladner yesterday, when presenting the motion.
The motion passed yesterday asked the B.C. government to exempt municipalities from TILMA until it consults with local governments on the law's impact, and to address any specific issues unique to Vancouver.
Worried about hands tied
Critics of the agreement say it could prevent local elected officials from making laws their citizens want. Premier Campbell's green initiatives, some argue, might be endangered, because under TILMA, B.C. and Alberta are not allowed to discriminate by providing better treatment for goods, persons, services or investors within their borders versus comparable ones within their province.
NPA Councillor Suzanne Anton, expressed no concern yesterday. "People in Alberta are our friends. It's ridiculous that we'd have any fear about that," she said.
The special agreement between B.C. and Alberta came into force on April 1, 2007, and is strongly supported by the Harper government. The agreement expands upon the Agreement on Internal Trade (AIT), enacted across the country 20 years ago.
For now, municipalities are not fully subject to the pact, which aims at creating a new integrated economic zone between Alberta and B.C.
Once the agreement is fully in place, by 2009, no municipalities within those provinces can maintain or establish new measures restricting the economy, unless the province shows the restriction is justified under TILMA.
'Lower the bar'
The dispute resolution procedure it creates lets individuals or businesses challenge government measures and seek compensation of up to $5 million for each successful challenge.
TILMA supporters say a similar clause is contained in a number of other agreements, such as the AIT.
But COPE Councillor David Cadman described TILMA as "an attempt to lower the bar," with dangerous consequences for the municipality.
Once the plan is fully implemented at a municipal level, projects like eco-density, or view corridors might be subject to legal challenges, he said.
The pact could also make it difficult for Vancouver to meet its greenhouse gases reduction targets of 33 per cent by 2020 and 80 per cent by 2050, Cadman said.
Sullivan supports TILMA
Cadman worries TILMA will undermine democracy if "private sector corporations" are "able to challenge rules put in place by elected individuals for the benefits of the citizens who elected them."
But Mayor Sam Sullivan doesn't see it that way. "I was more surprised to realize there are more barriers between our provinces than there are between the countries of Europe," he told the council. "This is an opportunity to deal with the citizens of Calgary as we would with the citizens of Prince George."
Stay tuned for the next municipal discussion about TILMA, to be held in Vancouver during the annual meeting of the Union of B.C. municipalities (UBCM) this fall.
Related Tyee stories:
- Corporate Rights Deal to Make Us April Fools
TILMA will strip our ability to set local limits. - 'Very Big Teeth' Threaten Campbell's Green Ambitions
TILMA trade agreement would penalize his plans. - Trade Debate Libs Don't Want
Talk of TILMA deal censored in the leg. But not here.



11
Login or register to post comments
Isabella2
4 years ago
TILMA
Gordon Campbell thinks TILMA is a great idea? Then the deal bears a much closer look than it's received to date. But Council of the City of Vancouver should be looking much closer to home, if it truly has the interests of business at heart.
QUOTE: "There could be some good advantages for businesses. But we would like consultation and we would like those issues to be addressed," said NPA Councillor Peter Ladner yesterday, when presenting the motion."
Strange beasts these politicians; that's just what the owners of small-businesses on Cambie Street have been asking for as they go broke behind the Canada Line construction signs. All they've ever wanted is "consultation" and to "have their issues of compensation addressed". Guess there are businesses and businesses when it comes to Mr. Ladner.
Isabella2
4 years ago
TILMA vs CAMBIE STREET
Sorry, clicked the last message too soon. This is the rest of it:
QUOTE: "The [TILMA] dispute resolution procedure it creates lets individuals or businesses challenge government measures and seek compensation of up to $5 million for each successful challenge."
Says it all for Cambie businesses, doesn't it?
Cynic
4 years ago
Did anyone else guffaw at
Did anyone else guffaw at Susan Anton's incisive statement? And tilma is "strongly supported by the Harper government"? Therefore, be very suspicious. The Multilateral Agreement on Investment just keeps rearing its ugly head in new incarnations. The elite keep moving towards total control, incrementally and relentlessly. If we lived in a genuine democracy, this type of "agreement" would be unthinkable.
Fiat lux
4 years ago
All these so called
All these so called "agreements" are in reality treaties, and international treaties, designed to restrict the democratic rights of peoples to make their own decisions.
Originating with the US-Canada FTA, they've been using the word of "agreement" to bypass the 2/3 majority requirement by the US Senate to pass international treaties.
Agreements need only simple majority to pass.
The TILMA is the first step toward the SPP and one of its main requirement, the "free movement of workers".
This means that if the SPP is passed, corporations, especially in mining and other resource industries, will be able to import their own minimum wage labour force, and fire all Canadian labour .
The outgoing head of the Bank of Canada, David Dodge, made a speech in Chicago a few weeks ago, extolling the benefits of the "free movement of labour". Obviously, there are big money directorships and job waiting for him with the multinationals.
Major corporations have been using the deregulated money creation powers of the banks to take control of our and the world's resources and are now on the verge of causing a global depression, with the collapse of the worthless US dollar, which will give them the power to set up a worldwide corporate dictatorship, called "rules based trade agreements".
Note, that all the most vicious dictatorships of the 20th century have been the result of economic depressions, when people had no other choice, but to accept mass murderers to control them.
People will have to make the choice one of these days whether they want democracy, or live under the fascism of "trade rules" for the maximization of profits for a few.
Ed Deak, Big Lake.
Jeffrey J.
4 years ago
Time to Speak Out
Civic involvement in pollitical decision making is (finally) on the increase. Through conduits like the Tyee, Council of Canadians, rabble.ca and many other organizatons. If we wish to keep our democracy, we're going to all have to do more. Leaving things to the political/corporate elites was a catastrophic error. Great article!
BC Dude
4 years ago
If TILMA is so great for the
If TILMA is so great for the masses why is it so secret? TILMA, NAU, NWO not a mention in msm, Why?
If Gordo, R Klein and Harper are involved then we have to fight it for OUR kids! Harper is trying to pressure the rest of the country into this looney "21st Century of Slavery" by the http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8y06NSBBRtY Corporate Militarization of OUR planet by the likes of Wal-Mart, EXXON, RD Shell, Carlyle grp., and the rest of the vermin.
We the population of North America are stronger than the few hundred at the head of this serpent, "Let's Roll"
Big Banks
I just finished watching this short but very insightful documentary! We are being "royally" screwed, as we all in some way owe big banks money!
http://moneyasdebt.net
Big Five equals $19 billion just in Canada in obscene profits this is the biggest reason behind all world misery, poverty and wars!
http://www.50years.org/action/s26/factsheet2.html
http://www.thirdworldtraveler.com/Transnational_corps/TransnationalCorps.html
Isabella2
4 years ago
TILMA for the masses
BC Dude is on the right track and gives me an idea: The Supreme Court has just set the Campbellites back on their heels. Regardless of how one felt about the union deals, they were signed, negotiated, legal agreements. Does anyone remember any other BC Government just walking in and tearing up a legal contract? But look at what has happened here since May 2001 - CB reneges on its deals with pre-sale contracts with would-be homeowners. And today another developer thinks he can just walk out on some lot sales because the sub-division is going to cost him more than he'd figured. You think one of us would get away with that?
Then Mayor Young of PoCo, a self-confessed problem drinker, refuses to step aside from his taxpayer-funded job until the court decides whether he's guilty of assault. And just this morning, 'NW's Bill Good professed surprise that "while criminals are released onto the street, small-business people are behind bars, in vain attempts to prevent more break-ins."
The 'Best Place on Earth'? I don't think so. Sounds more like BC's going to the dogs. What's left of it, that is.
My question to Mr. Campbell is this: If we find out that TILMA is not good for us 'ordinary' British Columbians, can we break that agreement, too?
dgiVista.org
4 years ago
Some corrections and a comment on Peter Ladner
The Agreement on Internal Trade was signed in 1994 and came into effect in 1995.
Municipalities will become fully under TILMA in 2009, but until then, any new regulations or amendments that municipalities enact must be TILMA-compliant.
The AIT also was voluntary, so provinces could implement as much as they wanted with no binding force.
TILMA was designed to put teeth into the AIT by making its provisions binding. This is why there is the $5 million penalty. So if TILMA supporters claim similar penalties are in other agreements, that could be, but just not in the AIT.
Peter Ladner's efforts to spin and ridicule viable criticism of TILMA at Council that day were quite sad and disturbing. He mocked people warning about the dangers of TILMA by suggesting that the dark side of the agreement is "losing sovereignty or something". To be that dismissive is quite unnerving from a city councillor.
dgiVista.org
4 years ago
A Quick Critique of TILMA
A good summary of TILMA's nature and threats is here:
http://cupe.ca/updir/TILMA_Facts_%26_Implications.pdf
BC Dude
4 years ago
TILMA It's about time that
TILMA
It's about time that the cities in BC woke up to the Real Truth behind this total Corporate sponsored draconian secretly signed by Gordo and Ralphy, not democratically debated in OUR Houses of Parliament! "For The People By The People"! It is OUR money, through taxes that pays for these Corporate (jelly fish, no back bone) Puppets! Is there anyway WE can refuse to pay taxes especially for war/occupation in Afghanistan?
I know that through OUR SCC WE can win this through OUR Constitution http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Canada?
Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms http://laws.justice.gc.ca/en/const/annex_e.html
http://polisci.nelson.com/constitution.html
The Law is in the People's Rights to Freedom Speech
BC Dude
4 years ago
Tomorrow is "Canada Day" a
Tomorrow is "Canada Day" a great day to Peacefully show OUR total disgust at these so called politicians! Banners "Say No To TILMA" "Say No To NAU" "Say No To Corporate sponsored wars"! T-Shirts, placards, pamphlets, etc.
There has to be some real grass roots Attorneys with Integrity out there who are just as disgusted as WE are?
THIS MAY BE OUR LAST CHANCE TO SPEAK-UP I Gaurantee it will spread like the Good Wind!
http://polisci.nelson.com/constitution.html
Only the bad guys are scared of a public backlash against them as they are just a bunch of little boys who have been caught!
"Wait till your father gets home" is a great example!