News

Labour Strife Hits BC Roads

Hundreds off the job in highways dispute.

By Francis Plourde, 7 Jun 2007, TheTyee.ca

Highway worker with stop sign

Almost 400 workers on strike.

Five years after the B.C. Liberals slashed road maintenance funding and nearly 20 years since the Social Credit government privatized highway repairs, highway workers across the province are off the job, protesting what they claim are deteriorating wages and road conditions.

Workers in the North Okanagan became the latest to shoulder their shovels late last month when they started a rotating strike. Similar job actions are also ongoing in South Vancouver Island and the Gulf Islands, as well as in the Prince George area. Maintenance workers in Merritt, Lytton and Logan Lake are locked out and have been off the job since April 23rd.

In total, there are almost 400 workers on strike across the province with others expected to join soon. And while workers are negotiating with different local employers, the purpose of their conflict -- wages, benefits and what the union says is rising discomfort about the state of B.C.'s roads -- remains the same.

'Overworked, underpaid and dwindling'

The B.C. government cut highway maintenance funding by $30 million a year in 2002. Since then, according to the B.C. Government Employees' Union (BCGEU), the highways workforce has been cut in half. Remaining workers, meanwhile, have had to accept wage cuts of between six and eight per cent.

According to the BCGEU, the crews are now overworked, underpaid and dwindling in numbers. The province-wide union claims that members in some areas were called to work up to 300 overtime hours over the past winter.

The Ministry of Transportation, however, denies that funding is an issue. The road maintenance budget, they say, has actually gone up in recent years, from $299 million in 2000-2001 to $342-million in 2007-2008.

But that money hasn't trickled down to the workers, according to the Union.

Mainroad South Island Contracting, for example, recently offered their workers an increase of 0.27 per cent for 2007, something BCGEU president George Heyman called "an insult."

"The contractors seem to think they've come to the table to get more concessions than they achieved in the last round of bargaining, when these workers were told by the Campbell Liberal government that if they didn't save the government some money, they'd be out of a job," Heymans said. "The contractors have to realize we're in a different climate now."

In the North Okanagan, workers have been asking for a six percent increase per year over the next three years. Their employer, Argo Road Maintenance, says they are waiting for an independent cost of living analysis before settling. Indeed, while many negotiations have occurred across the province, there have been no recent settlements.

Private workers, public union

According to the Transportation Ministry's Jeff Knight, that's not the government's responsibility. "We are not directly involved with the wages of the employees," Knight said.

While the highway workers are in the public union, they have, since the Social Credit government privatized highway maintenance in 1988, worked for individual contractors, such as Argo. The government awards maintenance contracts to Argo and others every 10 years. The contractors then negotiate wages with the union.

"The current 10-year contracts have all been awarded in the last few years," Knight says, adding that there are no plans to renegotiate anytime soon.

For contractors who were recently awarded contracts, like Argo Road Maintenance, the negotiation can be tricky. "We weren't in operation in 2002," when the government cut funding said Les Townsend, Argo's road maintenance manager. "We inherited this contract in 2004, so we didn't negotiate the previous agreement."

To deal with the growing situation, the Labour Relations Board asked mediator Vince Ready to help the parties reach an agreement. Ready hadn't called The Tyee back at the time of the publication.

Roads deteriorating?

According to the BCGEU, the problem is with the now 20-year-old privatization. Not only are wages stagnant, they say, but the quality of the roads has deteriorated too. As proof, they say complaints about road maintenance have skyrocketed.

"Highways contractors are now in an untenable position," said Mike Nuyens, chair of BCGEU's Operational Services. "They now get to regulate themselves. With one eye on the bottom line, they decide if a road is safe, and decide if and when repair work gets done."

But that's just not true, according to the government. "The ministry has managers who monitor the roads in each of the contract areas to meet the standards," said Knight. "In cases where possible issues are monitored, there will be a follow up with the contractors to ensure that they act on it."

What's more, the ministry denies that the public thinks the roads are deteriorating. "There hasn't been any change in the amount of complaints throughout the years," Knight said. "It stayed consistent."

Growing strife

The problem, though, is growing. Last Friday, 82 Kootenay Boundary region highway workers endorsed strike actions and might soon join the growing movement.

Despite the strike, essential services remain. "They are required to provide essential services as designated by the Labour Relations Board," said Les Townsend.

There are about 2000 highway workers across the province. Half of them are full time employees and half of them are auxiliary workers, according to BCGEU. The Lower Mainland area, where municipalities are in charge of road maintenance, won't be affected.

Related Tyee stories:

 [Tyee]

12  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • DPL

    4 years ago

    Wonder if there is any

    Wonder if there is any problems with the road to the Olympics being rebuilt up to whistler?At what eventual cost?

  • munroe

    4 years ago

    Disingenuous

    The article is good, but it misses, in certain crucial ways, both the depth of the problem and the regressive role played by the Liberal government. As a general statement, I believe it is fair to say that privatisation has proven the same failure we have seen in services such as garbage collection (problems in the Tricity area are well known locally, but never reported by our friendly provincial media). The answer provided by the Province that there has been no increase in complaints about quality may be true. The dissatisfaction has been thunderous (ask anyone in, say, Kitimat) and the volume has not decreased.

    There has been a huge impact on quality especially since the Province forced major concessions on workers early in the Liberal's term. One area of particular concern was the attack on auxiliary workers who year after year ensured maintenance in the peak winter seasons. These workers have been all but eliminated. If they have been replaced (not always possible), it has been by inexperienced contractors.

    The contractors are now "self-regulating". The public employees who were responsible and investigated complaints were laid off. The few "managers" do not have the primary responsibility, each contractor "reports" on how well they are doing in complying with their responsibilities.

    With highways, we can see EXACTLY why the private delivery of public services is wrong headed. It allows the politicos to claim no responsibility while meddling to achieve political goals. It always leads to deterioration. Profits trump quality.

    As I said the article is good, but there is much more to this tale.

  • Fiat lux

    4 years ago

    The roads in the Interior

    The roads in the Interior are in despicable shape, especially around the mines, where the overloaded ore trucks are making deep dents and breaking them up, exempted even during breakup closures.

    The lines on our Likely road haven't been painted until Sept. last year and are hardly visible now. There has been some roadside slash clearing 3 or 4 years ago, with the slash still lined up on the roadside for miles, dry and ready to burst into flames, in areas covered with dead, bugkilled trees.

    The winter snow clearing and maintenance is atrocious, while the jerks are giving big tax breaks to the offenders.

    Ed Deak.

  • DPL

    4 years ago

    I lived in Vancouver and

    I lived in Vancouver and drove a truck up into the North shore. The roads were usually cleared and the upper levels was always good. privAtization of the road crews doing snow removal showed up. Nobody complained. Then it snowed quite heavily and suddenly the folks started taking about those guys on the snow plows etc etc. Things that don't affect you personally, don't mean a thing but when it does the spit hits the fan. Travel between ottawa and Montreal used to be weird in winter as different contractors plowed different parts of the highway. Not uncommon to find a stretch of road bare and a few miles farther a snow bank.

    I have a brilliant idea that started in the USA. down in California they are talking of contracting out George Bushe's job to a guy in Pakistan who will work much cheaper. Maybe we could contract out our beloved Premier who has caused us so much grief. Or unelect him .

  • BC Dude

    4 years ago

    Union Busting Corporations

    Union Busting Corporations don't like Unions for the simple reason they have power and the Corporate World fears all Organized People! Their motto "Divide and Conquer" Private for profit in all P3's as we the lowly taxpayer's hard earned dollars are their profits and we are the only losers.
    One example of Divide and Conquer I think
    http://www.cbc.ca/canada/british-columbia/story/2007/06/01/bc-bctf-lockout.html
    Writing snail-mail letters gets at most "will look into this" or email as I've tried gets a computer generated "recieved" response.
    So what's left?

  • Bucky

    4 years ago

    Taxpayer $

    The Campbell government has no problem in giving hundreds of millions of dollars to their contracting buddies to build new roads but doesn't want to spend any money ensuring the existing roads are maintained. My guess is they want to existing roads to deteriorate so they can pay their buddies to rebuild them too.

  • BC Dude

    4 years ago

    www.nupge.ca/news_2006/n23ap0

    http://www.nupge.ca/news_2006/n23ap06a.htm
    http://www.nupge.ca/privatization/privatization.htm
    http://www.labourstart.org/tv/
    All Unions should be very worried about the 450 firings and a possibility of backing up this dispicable act of a treasonous Fiberal government who are in bed with Sodexho (known in the world as vultures) for the turn over of $700,000,000. taxpayer dollar health care services! Sodexho has a dismal record in Europe and the United States, where it has been called on
    the carpet for many safety and cleanliness violations as well as cost overruns. In Canada the
    company has also come under fire for the quality of their service. Sodexho
    "DO NOT KEEP SILENT when your own ideas and values are being attacked. ...If a dictatorship ever comes to this country, (Province) it will be by the default of those who keep silent. We are still free enough to speak. Do we have time? No one can tell." -- Ayn Rand, Philosophy

  • BC Dude

    4 years ago

  • BC Dude

    4 years ago

  • BC Dude

    4 years ago

    "As nightfall does not come

    "As nightfall does not come at once, neither does oppression. In both instances, there's a twilight where everything remains seemingly unchanged, and it is in such twilight that we all must be aware of change in the air, however slight, lest we become victims of the darkness." Justice William O. Douglas
    =Deep Integration

  • skumeek

    4 years ago

    let the roads get bad so

    let the roads get bad so they canbe sold off and the new owners will need to put a toll on it to pay for the upkeep

  • Marysue

    4 years ago

    "labour" strife?

    Oh my dear Editor!

    Please, please be more politically correct--or at least correct. The conflict is not "labour" caused!

    Quit using corporate-speak to describe a "management-labour" dispute. Using such terms always makes it seem that the party responsible for the strife is "labour" when nothing could be further from the truth, in most cases!

    Please endeavor not to fall into the handy habit of corporate anti-union propaganda! We get enough of that crap in the mainstream media.

    Thanks!

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.