Mediacheck

It Seems Harper's Bubble Is Twitterproof

He's still well ahead, immune to the constant deluge of terrible things tweeted about him.

By Steve Burgess, 21 Apr 2011, TheTyee.ca

Dead Twitter bird

Flipping the bird: Harper supporters inhabit a different branch.

Related

Sunday afternoon and a crowd is gathering for a candidate's debate. "Intact genitals are a human right," says the videographer's t-shirt. "I <3 my foreskin," proclaims two more shirts in the front row. On the podium, the assembled candidates include an enthusiastic young representative from the Pirate Party -- but not Conservative candidate Jennifer Clarke. Where else could we be but the West End?

Last Sunday's WERA-sponsored debate at the Empire Landmark Hotel was a lively exercise in democracy, at least for those Vancouver Centre candidates who bothered to show. Liberal MP Hedy Fry was there, as was Green candidate Adriane Carr, New Democrat Karen Shillington, Michael Huenefeld from the Canadian Progressive Party, Marxist-Leninist Mike Hill, and young Pirate swashbuckler Travis McCrea. Clarke's refusal to show left her open to criticism -- not to mention unchallenged suggestions that she will sacrifice newborn babies to appease the volcano gods -- but in purely cynical terms it probably made sense. When the official cameraman is rocking his line of "intact genital" wear and candidates are asked to state their positions on male circumcision as a human rights issue, it's a safe bet that an appearance by a Harper representative would be less than profitable.

Watching that debate was heartening, and instilled a new respect for the hoops a prospective MP must jump through. But the afternoon also reinforced a perception of the current political reality -- a sense of, at the very least, two Canadian solitudes. On the one hand are the Harper supporters. On the other side, almost everybody else. It's not surprising that the two groups don't mingle. But it often appears as though they are unaware of each other's existence.

Shannon Rupp recently wrote here about the many creative and often hilarious online attacks against Harper. ShitHarperDid has become a viral sensation. "This is why art matters," Rupp wrote.

Except that it doesn't, really -- not to Stephen Harper. His supporters are unlikely to be cruising web sites. An hour spent online might convince you that the prime minister is bound not only for defeat, but imprisonment. One online poll recently touted on Twitter showed Harper polling at 13 per cent. It's an enlightening survey, unless you're interested in actual electoral predictions. No, this poll is useful just for its neat illumination of the political bubble world that exists online. In spite of outrage over the G8 boondoggle and sleazebags in the PMO, Harper's poll numbers have barely budged throughout this campaign. Jack Layton's mid-campaign mini-boom has come at the expense of Ignatieff and Duceppe, not the PM.

Pirate power

At the WERA debate audience some questions focused on issues of downloading music (that from a Pirate supporter) in addition to the foreskin integrity issue. The Pirate Party's McCrea was a big hit, working the crowd like Oprah in his closing statement. But one attendee muttered angrily about the too-brief health care discussion. "All this nonsense," he said, "instead of the important stuff."

The WERA debate proved that there are certainly a handful of voters out there who can be won over with a carefully considered pro-foreskin position. More broadly, the Twitter and YouTube crowds will continue to vilify the Harper Government ™ in new and frequently hilarious ways. #RejectedConservativeSlogans was a wildly popular Twitter hashtag. But when May 2 rolls around, expect it to roll off the prime minister's back like so many spring raindrops.

Here's my #RejectedConservativeSlogan: "Bashing us on Twitter? Go ahead. We'll be at the hockey game."  [Tyee]

12  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • warbler

    1 year ago

    the political bubble world that exists online

    A sobering reminder that the virtual world is not as influential as it often thinks it is. The political bubble world you speak of offers a false sense of empowerment. You spend enough time among social media zealots, and you'd think the revolution is just a flash-mob away.

    Harper may be many things, but his strategists aren't stupid. If they felt the Twitterverse was worth harnessing or heeding, you can bet they'd be in there like there was no tomorrow.

    The bottom line is, ideas and votes win elections, tweets and FB wall posts do not. The later can aid the former, and understanding this distinction is vital.

  • seth

    1 year ago

    Mandatory voting

    With a bunch of of traitorous halfwits for Canadian voters, results so far show that the only successful political technique is
    20 second attack ad on America's Greatest Weight Loss Contest in the fascist media that controls the half-wits big screen teevee. All those who died in the World War's so fascism would stay over there, are crying so much in despair that their tears are extending La Nina.

    Perhaps the Aussie's policy of forcing people to vote, extended with a 10 minute voters test with a massive fine as a penalty for failure, and mandatory 1 hour a day in the middle of prime time TV all channels all politics would be the approach needed.

    The uninformed "they are all a buncha crooks" drooling voter is just another soldier for fascism.

  • P. Markunas

    1 year ago

    Good Article

    And a reminder that while it is entertaining to surf for new lines on Harper sins, unless we volunteer to get on the phones or do a foot canvass (even better) for our preferred flavour of "not Harper" we've contributed nothing to solving the problem. Even worse if we are so busy surfing we forget to vote.

  • jwstewart

    1 year ago

    Seth, you must be one of

    Seth, you must be one of those half-wits, if you really beleive political re-education will eliminate fascism.

    The know-it-all holier-than-thou pseudo-intellectuals like yourself are the Field Marshals of facism.

    It just happens to be true that every single Canadians' vote is just as important as yours.

  • snert

    1 year ago

    The Tyee Tea Party

    "It Seems Harper's Bubble Is Twitterproof"

    It's probably because they all sound like comments made by the Tyee 'Tea Party'.

    None of them would be caught dead voting for the GOP in the US but their rhetoric manages to sound just like that of the Republican flaky extreme right-wing Tea Party.

    Everybody just stops listening, after a while.

  • Frank

    1 year ago

    Stephen Harper

    Anyone else read this article on Harper once being a member of the Northern Foundation? And I thought his being a member of the NCC was bad, geez.

    http://www.agoracosmopolitan.com/home/Frontpage/2007/11/05/01929.html

  • VivianLea Doubt

    1 year ago

    the bubble...

    Steve, you are right about Harper's bubble in some respects: not only do his supporters not spend much of their time cruising the web, most of them still have rotary dial phones. Harper and strategists have always been aware that their only task is to get out their base vote, because the other parties have been so fragmented...and their voters have not been showing up at the polls.

    To my mind, the overriding goal in this election is to get out the vote of the younger electorate: whether they vote Liberal, NDP, or Bloc, they can stop Harper getting a majority. And quite frankly, the way to reach those voters is indeed the twitterverse and the rest of the social media world. If Harper ignores it, so much the better. And when Kenny says he is disconcerted by vote mobs...well, we are on the right track.

  • G West

    1 year ago

    Oh, some Harper fanatics come out of the bubble

    If only momentarily (and then they decline to confirm they've done it)....

    http://pacificgazette.blogspot.com/2011/04/photos-michael-sona-did-not-tweet-up.html

  • Rolf Auer

    1 year ago

    What's the surprise?

    He has the mainstream media on his side. Please vote!--@Rolf_Auer

  • EcoCollectivist

    1 year ago

    Burned Babies and Raped Grandmothers

    I think Harper represents the psychopathy of a political cult. This man could seriously burn babies and rape grandmothers and his supporters would still kneel before him in worship. Harper would be able to manipulate their reality through clever language control. The psycopathy lies in the Harper bubble he, and his corporate aristocratic media barrons at Quebecor, have created. This mirrors the USA which is in an even worse spot with complete media, and thus reality, centralization. The cult of Harper bolsters the argument for a reconfiguration and decentralization of media, power and politics. It is not that the left is in the bubble. We all read and listen to Haper's incessant "talking points" to the point that we could do his job. The bubble is within the cult of Harper which does not view dessenting opinions or critically engage in dialogue. Yet what else would you expect. They have been raised by the media to be mindless drone of production and consumption for the corporate capitalist empire of greed and centralization.

  • bontano

    1 year ago

    Steven Harper?

    Or would that be Stephen Harper?

  • David Beers

    1 year ago

    Administrator

    good catch Bontano

    we'll fix that

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.