BC's Political Blogosphere
Sean Holman spills the dirt and URLs.
[Editor's note: Sean Holman ferrets out political stories 12-14 hours a day, "working my trapline."
Three years ago, he created Public Eye
to put them all in. He wanted to cover provincial politics and help hold government and opposition to account. But because it's "extraordinarily difficult" to break in to political journalism, he simply created his own blog.
Before it went to blog form, he was writing and publishing Public Eye as a 30-page PDF magazine but "it was somewhat challenging ... there are never problems in journalism or politics, just challenges," he says. And he's run the blog daily since then except for a brief stint at the Sun in 2005. Although he broke several election stories there (and won a Webster, the highest award in B.C. journalism), he left after only a few months and resurrected the blog.
He traded in the resources and readers of the Sun for Public Eye, which makes little money and has few readers in comparison. On a normal day, it gets around 1,500-4,000 unique readers and on a "major mover" day (like when Minister for Mining Bill Bennett resigned and Holman was the first to break the story) he gets about 5,000.
Holman has since rejoined mainstream media as the legislative reporter for 24 Hours newspaper and the host of Public Eye Radio on C-FAX, but still maintains his blog daily, which he describes as a "daily journal covering the backrooms of provincial and federal politics in British Columbia, breaking headlining stories before they become headlines. Our voice is neither conservative nor progressive. It is independent and irreverent, biased only against pomposity and hypocrisy."]
In the 1994 Ron Howard movie The Paper, fictional New York newspaper editor-in-chief Bernie White -- played by a curmudgeonly Robert Duvall -- declared, "I hate columnists! Why do I have all of these columnists? I've got political columnists, guest columnists, celebrity columnists. The only thing I don't have is a dead columnist. And that's the kind I could really use. We reek of opinions.... You know what every columnist at this paper needs to do is to shut the *%# up." I often feel that way about Canada's political blogosphere -- which has tended to be more about rants than muckraking. That being said though, there are some exceptions in this province.
I've recently been intrigued by the work of Kevin Quinlan, who does communications and policy research work for Vision Vancouver. It's usually not advisable for political staffers to run their own blogs. In fact, back in June, one got in trouble for doing just that. But, writing as Vancouver Kid, Quinlan got a scoop covering the Coalition of Progressive Electors annual general meeting. And, just last week, he wrote an entertaining editorial on an eyebrow-raising Non-Partisan Association resolution promoting free-range chicken eggs. That's a story any blogger (or columnist) in Vancouver could have had done. After all, the resolution is readily available via the Internet. But for some reason, no else did.
Indeed, former provincial New Democrat legislator David Schreck is one of the few scribblers who routinely flips through such public records. And I'm not even sure if he -- like me -- would describe himself as a blogger. Regardless, since 2001 Schreck has been doing an admirable job of looking for the devil in the details -- combining his number-crunching skills with freedom of information requests to afflict the comfortable in both government and, from time to time, his own party. It's a public service he's done without any remuneration. And Schreck should be applauded for it.
Langley Councillor Jordan Bateman, a Liberal constituency association vice-president, also occasionally breaks news rather than following it -- in part, I think, because of his background as a journalist. But I still wonder why more British Columbian bloggers aren't pouring over budget documents, checking donation records and fact-checking political news releases. Perhaps it's because I'm one of the few who thinks that sounds like a fun Friday night?
Sean Holman's must-read blogs:
Finally, I would be remiss if I didn't mention the work done by my 24 hours' colleague Bill Tieleman and The Times Colonist's Paul Willcocks, who is among the most reasoned voices in British Columbia public life. Much of their writing appears in print. But Tieleman, who marries a considerable journalistic talent with one of the smartest political minds in the province, has been writing more web-exclusive material. And his coverage of the Basi-Virk trial is a must-read -- whether you're an insider or an outsider.
Just like during an award acceptance speech, I'm sure I'm forgetting a few deserving blogs. The contributors at North Vancouver Politics deserve mention, as does interim Green leader Christopher Ian Bennett whose ruminations, while not helpful to his party, have been a source of much amusement. And it's encouraging to see voices like former CKNW broadcaster David Berner joining the online debate. But I still wish the blogosphere reeked of more of news than opinions.
Related Tyee stories:
- To the Sun and Back Again
Sean Holman, at 29 a decorated political reporter, walked away from money and prestige to remain in charge of his agenda. - Best of the New Blogosphere
Thom Wong's current must-reads. - Big BC Blogger Bares All
Darren Barefoot reveals his sources, secrets and next steps.



Working Memory
30-07-2007
Market is Too Small
The job market for "real" mainstream news journalists in BC is way too small.
Criticize your boss's opinion (editor, publisher, owner etc.,) in a truly meaningful way and you're out of a job in Vancouver for a very long time, maybe forever. I'm not talking about a "one-up" kick at the can in the name of what Chomsky describes as "necessary illusion." I'm talking about a series of stories that impact how the public thinks.
Vivian Smith at the Times Colonist is an exception. The only reason she got her gig back was because since 2003, there is a global spotlight shining on the province all the way from Switzerland, and CanWest could not afford the controversy as they negotiated with Olympic organizations.
I'm sure Smith knew a lot more about the tourism fiasco than she revealed to the public.
If a journalist is to command any respect, he or she has to report all sides of a story in a nonpartisan manner, but it ain't happening here by a long shot.
Journalists in BC lack backbone because they have almost zero options.
Thankfully we have publications like TheTYEE.ca, and also news networking hubs like NowPublic.com, which means we need mainstream news media less and less every day.
The same thing that happened to the music industry is happening to the news industry.
People can talk to each other and cut out the middle person. Smart people now go directly to the source, while the elderly and less sophisticated still read newspapers and watch the 6 & 11.
gaulois
31-07-2007
Good promo
Nice to see The Tyee handling stories that promote an independent BC blogosphere. Chapeau.
Jeffrey J.
31-07-2007
Pubic Eye is Great
Excellent article! At the top of my Firefox browser, next to the Tyee, Gush Shalom and Aljazeera bookmarks is Public Eye. This is an excellent resource for those interested in news, rather than the manicured infotainment coming from CanWestGlobal and Canada's other media monopolies. Thanks so much to Sean Holman, David Beers and the other few who continue to give BC citizens real news.
BC Mary
01-08-2007
All the news that's printed to fit
Public Eye Online is one of my first stops, each day, when cruising for news.
Big thanks to Sean Holman for that, as well as for his cheery OK whenever I request permission to reprint one of his items on my own blog.
In fact, there's a surprising collegiality amongst the real journalists toward someone who is making the effort to bring hard-to-find news (such as my blog's focus on the B.C. Rail affair) together.
Bill Tieleman has been outstanding. Paul Willcocks also extremely kind.
The fact remains, however, that there's a huge enormous story underlying much of British Columbia's news that nobody has yet dared to write about ... not even an opinion.
Skywalker
01-08-2007
Serious question.
My eyebrows raised when I saw Paul Willcocks' name in the same discussion with Bill in Holman's piece above. Then BC Mary said "Paul Willcocks also extremely kind." and I wondered if that was like, damming with faint praise. Maybe somebody could clarify this for me. Has Paul had an epiphany that I missed or have I misjudged him?
Eleanor Gregory
01-08-2007
political blogs
Thanks, Sean, for sharing your trapline. I know I'm not alone in acknowledging that I check out publiceyeonline.com several times a day. Paul Willcocks said in a recent Victoria Times column that anyone in B.C. serious about politics has to read your blog. I agree.