- Ms Kaye is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Mary Carlisle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Prem Gill is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nancy Flight is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Justin Everett is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- John Westover is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nora Etches is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Edward Henderson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Bharadwaj Chandramouli is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Dean Chatterson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Marius Scurtescu is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Robert Parkes is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- James Murton is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Susan Doyle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Vincent Strgar is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Helen Spiegelman is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Subir Guin is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Kimball Finigan is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joanne Manley is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- David Leach is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
Teacher's Layoff Follows Olympic-sized Learning Experience
I taught children to question the Games, took heat, and gained insight.
Anti-Olympics mural on wall of the Crying Room Gallery. Photo courtesy of Blackbird from The Tyee's photo pool.
[Editor's note: This article is drawn from articles on the Vancouver Observer's education blog, 'School View.' Featuring ground-breaking stories from writers involved in the Vancouver public school system, School View is one of the city's best sources for developments parents and teachers need to know about. The Tyee is pleased to be running a 'Best of the Vancouver Observer' article weekly.]
Strathcona Elementary School, where I have been a teacher, is located in Vancouver's Downtown Eastside. This neighborhood, known as Canada's poorest postal code, has a history of community activism and is the neighbourhood that has been most affected by Vancouver winning the 2010 Olympic bid.
Anyone who traces the history of the International Olympic Committee can see similarities between what takes place in each city that hosts the Olympics. As is typical, the Olympic "economic cleansing" (better known as gentrification) began soon after Vancouver was declared winner of the Olympic bid. Some residents of the DTES were forced out of their housing units so the housing could be renovated or torn down to make room for condo development. Market housing development in the DTES rapidly outpaced the development of affordable housing. Promises that better social housing would be created were broken.
I was thrilled in September 2009 when I came into contact with a group of activists and teachers dedicated to providing an alternative to the pro-Olympic materials that had inundated our schools and classrooms. The Vancouver-based Olympic Resistance Network had created a workshop titled Teaching 2010 Resistance. I attended the first meeting where different lesson plans were shared in order to get feedback from other teachers.
An example of a lesson was using pie charts to track how much money had been put into the Olympics (an estimated $6.7 billion dollars) and what programs could have been put into place had this money been spent elsewhere (social housing, shelters, schools etc.). Unfortunately, the meeting did not attract very many people, and so I suggested that we host another one in my classroom.
Perhaps teachers would feel more comfortable if it were held in a familiar venue. The workshop would be held after school and would be an opportunity for teachers to browse through some lesson plans and give them some ideas of how to teach critically about the Olympics in their classrooms.
A few days before the workshop was to be held in my classroom, the media got ahold of one of the flyers. The Vancouver Sun ran a front-page article claiming that anarchists and radical politics were entering the school system and that students were being indoctrinated and brainwashed. Parents and the media frantically began calling our principal demanding answers, and an emergency meeting was called.
My colleagues were furious. People declared, "politics have no place in this school" and "you shouldn't be pushing your own agenda!" I asked them why supporting the Olympics was not political but not supporting them was political, but no one had a good answer for me. In their article "Shifting out of 'neutral': Beginning teachers' struggles with teaching for social justice," Kelly and Brandes discuss how many teachers feel that their role as an educator is to remain neutral or unbiased about issues. This was a recurring theme in our discussions that day; teachers felt that it was not appropriate to talk about their view or opinions on issues, especially controversial ones.
However, critical pedagogues agree that teaching is "inevitably political and that teachers cannot be value-neutral." In the end, my administrator did not allow me to host this workshop in my classroom, and the workshop was moved to another location. This, however, was only the beginning of a series of long, isolated months where I was given very little support and much trouble for my political views and opinions.
The corporatization of schools
Corporatization of schools has long been the subject of debate. Proponents such as Peter Cowley from the Fraser Institute argue that corporate sponsorship can benefit schools, especially those in low-income neighbourhoods, such as Strathcona, by providing enriched learning opportunities that they otherwise could not afford. The opposing side of the debate argues that increased commercialism in schools raises concerns such as loss of accountability and increases inequalities.
The loss of accountability is particularly worrisome as it does have serious implications with regard to decision-making, for example, regarding program funding. Much research has been done linking the activities of corporations in schools to building lifelong brand loyalty in consumer students. "Building brand loyalty while kids are at school has been known to be an effective long-term strategy since the 1960s, when psychologist Lester Guest showed that one quarter of consumers brand preferences were established in childhood."
So, under the pretext of providing students and educators with "a once-in-a-lifetime chance to experience the excitement of an international event held in in British Columbia," the Olympic Games proved to be a great cover for corporations to enter our schools. Coca-Cola, no stranger to school corporatization, the Royal Bank of Canada, and many other corporations were given access to our students under the guise of the Olympic Games. When the torch ran by our school, Coca-Cola representatives waltzed into our school grounds passing out flags and other freebies to the kids, and no one blinked an eye. The Royal Bank of Canada was also there, and nobody seemed too bothered by the fact that our students were being used as marketing agents for these companies.
When a wealthy businessman decided to give Olympic mittens to every child who attended an inner-city school in Vancouver, everyone was thrilled. No one asked questions about who this man was, what motives he might have, and why, if he really wanted to help inner-city children, had he not donated money for providing school supplies or much-needed food and clothing.
I talked to my staff about how the Olympic committee, VANOC and the IOC act as corporations just like Coca-Cola or McDonald's. They are in the business of "marketing" the Olympic brand, and their profits come from selling the rights to the five-ring logo to broadcasting companies, sponsors and companies like HBC (the maker of the mittens). The logo is such a moneymaker that they do not even let the Paralympics use it. Naomi Klein writes in her book No Logo about "the corporate shift from marketing products to marketing brand names." The IOC owns a very profitable brand: the Olympics. The Olympic mittens are selling a product (the Olympics) to children, and in turn, children are used to market that product without their full knowledge or consent.
The staff at my school were very defensive and not open to this line of argument at all. The Olympics are about fun and sports, they felt, and what was wrong with that?
Olympic rings as elementary school artwork
Schools, as they are currently set up, are based on a supposed system of meritocracy. There is no analysis of class, race, gender or any other category that might be a major factor in determining whether or not you succeed in school. The Olympics fit in perfectly with this idea that you can achieve anything if you just put your mind to it.
Athletes visiting our school always sent the message to the kids that, "as long as you work hard, you, too, could be an Olympic athlete." There was no mention, of course, that it takes money to be an Olympic athlete: economic privilege and commitment on the parents' part. In reality, not every family has the money to hire a coach and buy expensive equipment, and most parents do not have the time and the ability to dedicate their lives to making their child's dream come true.
I draw upon Paulo Freire's education philosphy known as Critical Pedagogy. This pedagogy is different from the current discourse around critical thinking in schools. The mainstream notion of critical thinking is that kids need to learn to think about various issues from different points of view.
The Critical Pedagogy philosophy, on the other hand, sees children as participants who can analyze unequal power structures that exist in our society and the groups that are most affected by them. Students draw from their own experiences and their life experience is seen as valuable to the learning process. By looking at the world critically, and questioning and challenging it, children are able to transform their world.
As a critical pedagogue, I am used to hearing repeated arguments about how kids are not capable of thinking critically at such a young age. One teacher suggested that perhaps in high school we should talk about these larger issues of gentrification, human rights violations, corporatization, environmental degradation, etc., but in Grade 1, children would not be able to understand such complex issues. One study showed that even though teachers claimed that age was not a barrier in teaching about social justice issues, teachers for the most part felt that young children were not developmentally ready to learn about social justice issues.
Another recurring theme is that of childhood innocence: the idea that it is better for children to be oblivious to the inequities that take place in the world and "enjoy their childhood." I have seen in my own classroom how this is truly impossible, especially with inner-city children. Oppression is part of my students' everyday lives, so how can someone say that they can't understand it?
My students who are students of colour know what it is like to be made fun of because of your race. My students who are poor know what it is like not to have rights and privileges because of your economic class. The families of the students at our school were the ones directly being affected by the gentrification, the cost we paid to host the Olympics. Despite that, some parents were strongly opposed to their children hearing arguments against the Olympics.
The fallout
It cost the Canadian and B.C. taxpayers billions of dollars ($6 billion, by some estimates) to host the Olympic Games. A few weeks ago, I received a layoff notice. Due to the budget cuts, teachers with low seniority are getting laid off.
Teachers across the province are outraged, and parents are furious. There is no doubt that it will dramatically affect our classrooms. While the Vancouver School Board has to cut programs and lay off teachers and support staff because of a multi-million-dollar budget shortfall, the cost of the Olympic opening ceremonies alone was $38 million.
Now that the Olympics are over, I hope other cities will learn from the resistance movement that took place here in Vancouver. We need to work together with other cities and educate people so that they are aware of what could happen if the IOC uses their city to host the Olympic Games. Teachers here in Vancouver need to help teachers in other cities around the world to cope with the challenges that their schools will face leading up to, and during, the Games.
As a beginning teacher, I learned a lot from this experience. I felt disillusioned and isolated on too many occasions and I came to realize the importance of allies. I found one experienced teacher at my school who was very supportive and encouraged me to keep on fighting for what I believed in, even when I felt like I could not do it any more. I realized the importance of knowing school policies and what my rights were as a teacher. I learned that I should always ask questions and always demand answers. For months, I had feelings of disillusionment, hopelessness, and isolation, but I survived it.
It was all worth it, just listening to my six-year-old students discuss their feelings around the Olympics amongst themselves in the lunchroom or during class. "I wish we could give all that money and instead make sure everyone has a place to live and can eat lots of food," one student said.
"Yeah, not everyone loves the Olympics," another one added. ![]()




25
Login or register to post comments
alive
1 year ago
about Gordo
So, now you know the government priorities!
Children do not vote!
Chris Keam
1 year ago
mittens and workbooks
My kid's daily planner had pro-Olympic imagery on its cover. I've been looking at all year and shaking my head at the blatant propagandizing VANOC and gov'ts felt was appropriate in a school setting. The mitten hand out ticked me off too. We have plenty of mittens at our house. We don't need red ones with corporate (IOC) emblems on them thankyouverymuch, nor should they have been given out without asking for parental permission first. Would we allow a church to give out cross-emblazoned clothing, or a political party to hand out lapel buttons. The double standard, and corporate marketing to kids in an educational setting is offside IMO.
mary jane
1 year ago
No Idea
Most people had no idea how bad it was going to be. Many of BC'ers knew - they are the homeless etc
If a govdernment can leave people living on the street why would the bother to make sure kids have health care or an education. If we have dumb kids with no education - they will vote for duds like gordo. If gordo an dgang weren't greed or selfish this province would be a good place to live.
Many who saw the writing on the wall long ago tried to tell everyone but we were poo poo'ed
A nay say'er often have taken a deeper look at an issue.
snert
1 year ago
Whaaaaaa!
Give it up. Six-year-olds 'll believe just about anything you tell 'em or lead them into.
Chris_
1 year ago
No surprise................
We all knew, including the blind supporters, that the Olympic were going cost. This is why I did not support the games. They were just not a priority with the vast majority of citizens.
runner
1 year ago
re: Waaaaaaa!
snert, you're absolutely correct.
That's why 6-year olds will tell you:
"I love McDonalds!"
"I love Coca-Cola!"
"I love Miga"
This is, of course, the danger in allowing unquestioned corporate presence in schools. Thanks for pointing it out! :-)
khed67
1 year ago
re: snert's Whaaaaa!
I'm wondering what your point is, snert. Give what up?
Do you think teachers shouldn't be allowed to bring their own perspectives on issues into the classroom? (As a teacher, students often ask me what I think about topics we discuss.)
Do you think corporations shouldn't be allowed to market their brands in schools? ("Free" mittens and Canada flags don't appear through benevolence.)
Or do you want teachers to just babysit the gullible six-year-olds until they are old enough NOT to "believe just about anything you tell 'em or lead them into"? (I know a lot of 40-year-olds who believe just about anything you tell 'em!)
edward01ca
1 year ago
Teachers are Conservative
After 33 years of teaching, I retired from the job. I always found teachers to be very conservative on just about any topic unless it was an apple pie issue like child poverty. I learned about Paolo Friere mnay years ago in a master's degree class and I used his thoughts when teaching my classes. But, teachers, by and large, do not want to rock the boat since they live in fear of the principal and the parents. Many school boards live in fear of parents as well. We don't provide an education unless we discuss all of the sides. Children can make decisions, even in grade 1. Otherwise, why do they want to go to McDonalds and wear Nike shoes?
sunshine coast girl
1 year ago
We need a whole lot more teachers like Myriam
to teach our kids to think and not blindly accept the blatant brainwashing by our government and huge corporations (including the IOC).
It's beyond insulting to assume that because little kids aren't as articulate as adults that their brains can't process just as well. I mean, aren't the Libs using some of those kinds of arguments right now to justify all day kindergarten?
CHAOTICORDER
1 year ago
Your strength is admirable
Your strength is admirable Myriam, it is good to see somebody hold fast to their ideals and have the ability to create a balance for our youth that is sadly needed in this overcommercialized world. We live in giant shopping malls and ourselves have basically degenerated into the debit cards we carry. That you have encountered so much opposition is unsurprising as most unenlightened people continue on their day to day activities caught up in the general apathetic nature that predominates our society. It is unfortunate that you have been a victim of the recent budget cuts as we need more Teachers such as yourself to ensure the proper balance is struck and to undue the damage that so many feel is acceptable to enodw on our youth. Likewise it is also unfortunate that there is not very much in the way of solutions for this epidemic other than to acknowledge those willing to take the road less travelled.
I leave you with 2 of my favorite quotes which also strike a chord of balance due to who stated them.
"Great Spirits have always encountered violent opposition from mediocre minds" - Einstein
"Thou shalt not follow a multitude to do evil." - Moses
Birch
1 year ago
Courage
Courage like that of this author should be nearly credential enough for continued employment in the public schools.
On the issue of speaking about controversial issues in the classroom:
1) Students who are engaged are not stupid. Although they may be inexperienced, they are able to judge rationally.
2) Students' learning often results from trust in the character and honesty of their teachers. Teachers whom they dislike or mistrust will often be unsuccessful at teaching them much, whatever their efforts. Students want honest answers from their teachers. Insofar as their questions are of the "What do YOU think?" type, to be dishonest or cowardly about answering does not help.
3) Teachers should not crudely (or even smoothly) attempt to brainwash their children into specific points of view. Stating honestly a point of view (and having the right to such a viewpoint as any citizen does) is not brainwashing.
Ms. Dumont's commitment to social justice, especially when teaching those who most seriously experience its lack, is commendable. Educational administrations too cowardly or co-opted to realize this commitment as the value it is need to re-examine their own suitability for their jobs.
snert
1 year ago
khed67
For six-year-olds teachers should just stick to the curriculum.
RickW
1 year ago
snert - bronx cheer for U!
The curriculum is what kills curiosity.
http://www.globaloutdoors.co.uk/outdoor-class.html
RickW
1 year ago
edward01ca
It's been my expeience that teachers do not rock the boat because they do not want anything to affect their pensions.
snert
1 year ago
RickW
Well, you appear to have a limited understanding of the word curriculum. It can include whatever but for this argument, not politics, at least for six-year-olds.
zalm
1 year ago
She did
For six-year-olds teachers should just stick to the curriculum."
She did, snert. See for yourself
http://www.bced.gov.bc.ca/irp/ss_1.pdf
Page 11, "Goals for Social Studies K-7"
Page 12, "Intro"
Page 14, "Topics"
Page 19, "Addressing Local Contexts"
Page 20 "Establishing a Positive Classroom Climate" including mechanics of same.
Page 24, "Debate" and "Media Analysis"
and Particularly
Page 30 "Prescribed Learning Outcomes - Grade 1"
Everything I see in her article directly addresses the items in the curriculum. You may not like the emphasis. Tough. Someone has to raise the next generation of questioners. The rest are already reaching for the blue pill.
RickW
1 year ago
snert
And it appears you are phishing for a reaction - and you got one.
Or do you really believe that children should be seen and not heard?
islander10
1 year ago
Well Said!
It is great to know that there are other new teachers (besides myself) out there who feel the same about critical pedagogy and advocating for social justice in our classrooms. Education is truly the only way we can see positive change over time, but not if students remain passive recipients of whatever information floats their way. It is critical, ESPECIALLY for those children just entering the school system, that they are aware of what is happening in BC schools. Budget deficiencies and cuts affect these kids more than anyone. Why would we withhold this information from them? Hopefully our future generations will be long-term, critical thinkers and not corporate automatons. Way to go!
morechatter
1 year ago
Children just don't matter to the Liberals
What kids eat
What kids drink
When kids get beat
When kids gets sexually abused
When kids are negelected
What kinda education kids get
Whet kinda street corner kids sleep on
And the list goes on as province of BC children are coustantly on the Liberal hit list when it comes to funding as worst of in the land yet have some of the riches residents as often BC boasts.
When the NDP campagin said BC Liberals hated kids its a certain party members certainly have no use for BC kids because just look at the treatment speaks volumes. Ask a kid down and out if child believes anyone cares and there you will find the answer.
crh
1 year ago
curriculum
Are free red mittens, ala corp logo, in the curriculum?
John Greg
1 year ago
morechatter ...
I think it's not just the liberals though. If we look around the world we can see these kinds of issues arising everywhere, in every country, and I would argue that Fiat Lux is bascially right that at the core of this global miasma is the big lie of the corporation, capitalist greed, and the uncaring elite 5% of the world who hold 90% of the planetary wealth, property, adnd resources.
But back on topic, this is a good article, and yes we sure do need more teachers with strength of character enough to stand up to the bureaucratic monster machine. We are sliding into a truly dreadful state fort education when it becomes all about money, not about young minds.
morechatter
1 year ago
And What Did We All Learn From the Olympics?
That no matter how much education people have when you get a hockey puck and a room full of Canadians cheeped up on their Canadian beer the men become hypnotized as their eyeballs turn into little hockey pucks.
And so its okay British Colombians don't have the money for necessities like education as many had a heck of a good time there for a week or two and didn't you get to see the hockey game?
And what else was there to learn? Well having a big party during a time when the province should have been putting tax payers money to better use may not have been the smart thing to do as most parties the memories are in the clean up. Only problem is the Olympics cleaned up real good leaving BC residents with a bare boned budget leaving out the necessities.
I wonder now that BC is out of the recession if Ministers are going to roll back their pay you know for being over budget?
morechatter
1 year ago
John Greg
I not talking about the world but Canada and in Canada BC children are the worst off and that is a fact of their lives and thankfully not yours.
Because its he3l to young and that vulnerable its a certain as Liberals aren't ignorant of the treatment just the care. What do BC children have in common with abused African children BC's Mary, Mary quite the nasty b&#$h as Minister for BC children gets the biggest payoff of them all for ensuring BC kids go without.
CHAOTICORDER
1 year ago
On a somewhat related
On a somewhat related footnote today is Coke day at work, they walked around and handed out the new smaller sized bottle of Coca-cola with the following message
"The *** and Coke want to help you welcome the first weekend of summer with a nice refreshment!
Coke was kind enough to give us enough pop for everyone to enjoy!"
The marketing needs to be reinforced at every age I guess.
dave49
1 year ago
Free mittens?
My son goes to school in Vancouver and received free red Olympic mittens. The story the kids were given is that a benefactor, a woman, paid for mittens to be given to every child in a VSB school.