Life

The Future of Farmed Salmon

Podcast: Proposed salmon farm expansion shaping up to be hot election issue.

By Jon Steinman, 19 Jan 2009, TheTyee.ca

Deconstructing Dinner

Listen to this:

[Editor's note: This is a summary of a podcast you can download or listen to from this page.]

In 2006, Deconstructing Dinner aired an episode on salmon farming off the coast of B.C. Three years later, public opposition to this type of aquaculture is going strong. Catherine Stewart of the Living Oceans Society believes this opposition has been pivotal in keeping growth of the industry at bay.

With proposals currently before the province to triple production at some facilities, the potential expansion of salmon farming is shaping up to be a big election issue. In this episode, Deconstructing Dinner explores expansion plans at one hatchery owned by Marine Harvest Canada -- the largest aquaculture company in B.C.

This broadcast will also discuss the infectious salmon anemia (ISA) outbreak in Chile that has caused massive restructuring in that country's salmon farming industry. This month, the virus appeared in Scotland's farmed fish. Will B.C. be hit next?

Guests

Catherine Stewart, salmon farming campaign manager, Living Oceans Society (Vancouver, BC) -- Living Oceans Society is Canada's largest organization focused exclusively on marine conservation issues. It is based in Sointula, a small fishing village on the central coast of British Columbia. Prior to her role with Living Oceans, Catherine worked with Greenpeace for seventeen years, holding the positions of regional director and oceans and forests campaigner.

Clare Backman, environmental compliance and community relations, Marine Harvest Canada (Campbell River, BC) -- Marine Harvest is one of the world's largest aquaculture companies and is based in Norway. It's Canadian division is the largest aquaculture company operating in British Columbia. With 75 farm licenses, the company produces more than half (55%) of all the farmed salmon in B.C.

Barb Addison, manager, Big Tree Creek Hatchery, Marine Harvest Canada (Sayward, BC) -- Big Tree Creek is one of five hatcheries currently being managed by the company. It's in the process of a $3-million expansion.

Other Voices

Jay Ritchlin, director of marine and freshwater conservation, David Suzuki Foundation (Vancouver, BC)

Ian Roberts, communications, Marine Harvest Canada (Campbell River, BC)

Bill Harrower, manager of regional operations for aquaculture development, Ministry of Agriculture and Lands (Courtenay, BC)

Related Tyee stories:

 [Tyee]

6  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • snert

    3 years ago

    Nothing wrong with salmon farming.

    Quit all the whining against it and put all that negative energy into making sure it is done properly. Environmentally secure pens and proper disposal of waste products is not too much to ask.

  • ME2

    3 years ago

    snert

    Tell that to Campbell, snert.

  • Dan the socialist

    3 years ago

    i think it will be here to

    i think it will be here to stay for a while.

    I just hope Gordo will change things but i doubt that will happen.

    According to a Mustal Poll on Global yesterday the Libs lead the NDP in Polling....

    Libs- 47% (+3)

    NDP- 33% (-9)

    Grn - 16% (+4)

    Amazing how many complain about El Gordo and I can not stand him but it looks like he will win again...

  • quarry bay

    3 years ago

    Dan [DISRESPECTFUL COMMENT REMOVED. -MODERATOR.] socialist

    Do you really believe the Mustel poll?

    750 random phone calls to SOMEWHERE IN BC

    Perhaps you would like to look at the diffrence in polls Dan?

    http://www.mustelgroup.com/pdf/20081125.pdf

    http://www.mustelgroup.com/pdf/20081125.pdf

    Those are the last 2 Mustel polls,Dan know go find out how they arrived at their numbers

    Here is a real poll,with questions,methadology,regional breakdown,and with no added political commentary!

    http://www.angus-reid.com/uppdf/2008.11.15_BCPolitics_1.PDF

    I would imagine we are due for a poll from the innovative group(Greg Lyle)Campbell`s marketing/polling firm on howe street!

  • quarry bay

    3 years ago

    Dan

    I posted the same Mustel poll twice,here is the other Mustel poll.

    http://www.mustelgroup.com/pdf/20090119.pdf

    You will notice there is no difference in the polls-Check out the second graph,42% against 40% as the percentage who deem the economy as the main issue,the point I am trying to impress upon you SOCIALIST DAN? --- is, the Mustel poll is a blank cheque, 750 random phone calls to where? The island,west van, east van, fort nelson,port alberni,hmmm--Do you really think people are yo yo`s or bend to the wind like switch grass?
    Mustel doesn`t breakdown anything, female,male,educated,unemployed, anyways,I have a feel for the public perception, perhaps you are like Rman and Luke who have their mind made up by a poll! Even if the poll is skewed.

  • Toddtomorrow

    3 years ago

    Nothing wrong with salmon farming?

    First of all, investigative journalism that does not concur with your view isn't whining. And in fact, there's plenty wrong with fish farming. I think I have a pretty good idea as I worked on one.
    Pens are about as secure as they can be. If your concerned about farmed fish escaping and messing up wild stocks(Atlantic salmon) or their medicated flesh being consumed by predators, there will always be escapes or intentional releases of unwanted fish (old jacks). Pen technology is not the problem.
    Disease problems like sea lice are a problem that aquaculture companies are trying to avoid dealing with.
    Polluting sea floors with fish waste and excess feed that kills all life below a farm.
    These are just a few of the profound problems with fish farming.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.