Make Whoopee, Not Carbon!
Earth Hour could have been sold so much better.
Baby boomlet in nine months?
Reading about this Saturday's international Earth Hour in the Globe and Mail leads me to one conclusion: it's time to invest in Saskatchewan prairie, because it's bound to be waterfront.
Am I alone in thinking the environmental movement is doomed to fail because it just doesn't understand that most people are not interested in donning hair-shirts for carbon reduction?
When the World Wildlife Fund asks us to turn out the lights for an hour on Sat., March 29 at 8 p.m. local time, what do they propose we do instead? Other than virtuously calculate the impact our actions will have on the collective carbon footprint, that is.
They suggest organizing our very own Earth Hour events with humiliation parties including karaoke or trivia games. Suffering-with-questions? What is this: the Environmental Inquisition?
The site features photos of earnest folk holding candles, sitting in a circle, and (presumably) singing "Kumbaya." It looks like a church camp-out, just the thought of which makes me shudder. And speculate. Now let me get this straight: it's lights out at 8 p.m. on Saturday night, and candles are de rigueur, but the first activity that comes to their minds is karaoke?
Population explosion due
As an old-fashioned reporter, I did what I had been taught to when covering blackouts: jotted down the date nine months hence. Note to self, check for baby boomlet in December. That's sure to be one measure of the event's success.
Last year's original Earth Hour in Sydney, Australia was measured in reduced greenhouse gas emissions. When 2.2 million people and 2100 businesses, including the iconic opera house, went lights-free for 60 minutes, their small action caused a 10 per cent drop in the electricity grid. That saved 25 tonnes of carbon dioxide, which is the equivalent of removing almost 50,000 cars from the road for an hour. But I think my measure-of-success is more fun.
Of course, fun is the last word on the lips of too many activists. Why is environmentalism always about deprivation, sacrifice, and more deprivation? Is it mandatory to adopt that almost religious zeal that demands we all repent and suffer for our previous excesses?
Really, if the world is ending don't we just want to go on partying like it's 1975? How can we be persuaded to change our evil carbon-frittering ways when the image of the coming carbon-wasting hell doesn't look much worse than life in a carbon-neutral heaven. Frankly, a choice between floods and sing-alongs is really no choice at all.
So I'd like to propose a less earnest approach. I can see the slogan for Earth Hour now: "Make Babies Not Carbon."
We'll be rich, I tell you
Consider the sponsorship potential: Pampers, Gerbers, Fisher-Price, Baby Gap, Mattel -- and what's the high-priced Italian stroller maker? Purveyors of all sorts of baby products would be salivating at the thought of cute ads for Earth Hour along with the products you will need a year from now. The commercials will practically write themselves, and if they don't, I'm available.
A little TV advertising might be just what is needed to encourage more than 48,000 people -- the paltry number that has signed up this year -- to commit to an hour in the dark.
Apparently four Canadian cities have agreed to participate in Earth Hour: Toronto, Montreal, Ottawa, and also Vancouver, where the Vancouver Sun is one of the local "partners" promoting the event, along with the City of Vancouver and B.C. Hydro.
The Canadian government is always looking for more future pension providers: maybe they could get behind Earth Hour with some tax incentives hooked to December births?
Alternatively, the slogan could be "Make Whoopee Not Carbon." Again, there is a deep pool of sponsors just waiting for someone to take the plunge: Trojan, Victoria's Secret, and those men's body sprays that have to redeem themselves for making the halls of high schools a new environmental hazard.
Hooking up 2.0
Is there a marketer who doesn't have "social networking" on the tip of his tongue? Why aren't they running an Earth Hour networking site for those who want to meet at local Earth Hour parties? Think of it as a sort of face-to-face Facebook, with an open bar meet-and-greet at 5 p.m. and a candlelight party to follow.
Men it seems are always trying out pick-up lines. So how about a flirtatious investigation into what that nice woman minding her own business in the yogurt aisle is planning to do in the dark for an hour on Saturday night? If she already knows about Earth Hour, you'll make a friend. If she doesn't, you'll impress her with your social responsibility. And if she kicks you to the curb, don't blame me. (Do I look like Dan Savage?)
Yes, we have lemons here, but how about a little lemonade, preferably spiked with vodka?
Dark prospects
Having seen the potential of a candlelit evening, I've decided to turn out the lights and I asked Antler Boy (so named for the scavenged set of un-ironic antlers sitting on his fireplace mantel) what he is planning to do for the power-free hour. As a biologist and former activist whose eco-warrier tendencies once landed him in jail, I thought he might have some inspiration. Which he did, but only after I explained Earth Hour.
"I think I'll turn on all the lights -- that'll do just as much good," he said, deadpan. "These voluntary things are a waste of time. It's too late for that. We've squandered our opportunities to fix this for years now, and we've run out of options. There has to be legislation."
"But what about a "Make Whoopee Not Carbon" campaign?" I asked, smiling sweetly and stopping just short of batting my lashes.
He fixed me with that bemused stare he reserves for my most innovative schemes: "Are you serious?"
Right. Oh, I still plan to turn off the lights on Saturday night and, apparently, sit alone in the dark. But I'm taking no chances -- it's obviously time to find a real estate broker in Saskatchewan.
Related Tyee stories:
- How Will You Spend Your $100?
We'll each get a cheque to offset the carbon tax. Tell us your plans for the money. - Dust and Lust
The point at which sex and housekeeping collide. - Letting Go of Cool
Living better by going 'downmarket.'




10
Login or register to post comments
NicS
3 years ago
Make Whoopee?
Like we need more people on the Earth at this time. Get real!
mopled
3 years ago
Appeasing the Greenhouse Gods
http://carbon-sense.com/2008/03/28/dark-hour-a-sign-of-the-times/#more-64
The Carbon Sense Coalition today came out in support of “lights out” during Earth Hour (Saturday 29th) but claimed the time should be renamed “Dark Hour”
“And while contemplating this hour of darkness, they should steel themselves for the hour when, if the Global warming alarmists have their way, this will become a necessity not a nicety.
“The only thing that lifted mankind from the Stone Age was carbon energy from coal, oil and gas – for heating; for steam power; for electricity and water; for mining, smelting and refining of metals; for transport on land, sea and air; for lighting, heating, cooling and communications; for production of food and chemicals; and for power for processing and manufacturing.
“All of this comfort, safety, convenience and prosperity is now threatened by hysterical claims that man’s carbon emissions can and should be stopped. Even though the weather records and the science deny the doomsday forecasts, the politicians, like lemmings, are leading us over the Greenhouse Cliff. Without the nuclear parachute, it will not be a pleasant fall.
“Many other countries have already experienced their own dark days, most caused by silly decisions taken to appease the Greenhouse Gods."
rac
3 years ago
Great Idea But...
What's Everyone Going to Do for the Other 55 Minutes?
doggone
3 years ago
Nothing wrong with the idea
We played Dominos for the hour (I've got my kids and grandkids already) and tried to calculate the savings if we burn 3 or 4 candles and turn off the lights. Last year I posted here regarding the call for "Lights Out" event then saw no reaction ... Ah well
It is still worth doing.
There is little or no need for the amount of candlepower we radiate every night. I assume most of us are attempting to keep the "Boogyman" at bay or simply do not think that our individual action will make any difference.
Let us look at what we know for sure:
1)Energy resources are limited
2)Fossil fuel resources are terminally limited (they don't make 'em like that any more or at least not in the next few thousand years)
3) demand for energy has increased dramaticly and can be expected to continue this trend
4) There is no portable energy source that compares to gasoline/diesel fuel and there may never be
shmendrick
3 years ago
the idea is the thing, not the numbers
I'm not sure one should think about this as a solution... I am pretty cynical about the whole thing as well. But it seems it was able to get people to think about their energy usage, and have some exposure to the concept that many people doing not all that much can have a measurable impact, when added together.
freebear
3 years ago
More fiddl'in while Earth Burns!
Lights off for an hour once a year wow what commitment!!!!!!
More greenwash!
As one poster noted, too little too (likely) late!
And then to suggest make more babies! Or perhaps the author ws pointing out the foolishness of the idea?
All the little efforts and big efforts will have no impact if 'we' all still follow the growth mantra!
BC Hydro plans for increased demand, so des Kevin Falcon transpo Minister.
If the hour of lights out saved and energy will that not get cancelled out by the energy demanded by the x number of new homes/businesses/street lights/traffic lighyts etc. etc.?
Without recognizing limits to growth, the 'savings' are mere miniscule postponements!
Umslopogaas
3 years ago
Really
...and these candles that everyone was burning didn't produce any carbon dioxide?
wiley
3 years ago
more heat than light
silly to just turn out the lights.
turning off the heat would send 10x times the signal to BC Hydro.
Then we'd all have to snuggle under the covers to stay warm, and there'd still be a baby boom in 9 months. lol
asp
3 years ago
Crap
Anybody here read Heat?
We should have shut down the gas stations, the supermarkets, and the airport, rather then replacing the hydro powered light bulbs with fossil fuel powered candles.
As for a baby boom being good for the climate or not, see: http://www.monbiot.com/archives/2008/01/29/population-bombs/
Fii
3 years ago
I forgot all about earth
I forgot all about earth hour. But, I haven't watched (or had) tv in a decade and I go to bed at 10pm weekdays so... 10-11pm- that's my earth hour, five times a week!