- Mary Carlisle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Prem Gill is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nancy Flight is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Justin Everett is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- John Westover is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nora Etches is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Edward Henderson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Bharadwaj Chandramouli is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Dean Chatterson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Marius Scurtescu is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Robert Parkes is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- James Murton is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Susan Doyle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Vincent Strgar is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Helen Spiegelman is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Subir Guin is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Kimball Finigan is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joanne Manley is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- David Leach is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joel Berger is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
Wedge-ucating Our Immigrants
Harper's citizenship study guide is designed to divide new Canadians from old ones.
Minister of Citizenship and Immigration Jason Kenney with 'Discover Canada.'
- Discover Canada: The Rights and Responsibilities of Citizenship
- Government of Canada (2011)
THE TYEE RECOMMENDS GEIST MAGAZINE
And congratulates the fine Canadian literary institution on its 20th anniversary. Geist's website is here.
Last winter, when my partner applied for Canadian citizenship, an envelope arrived at our home containing the government study guide for the citizenship exam (the 2009 version rather than the one slightly revised in March 2011).
Like any document where a country describes itself, Discover Canada: The Rights and Responsibilities of Citizenship makes for revealing reading. Yet as my partner shared passages, I was gripped by the disconcerting feeling that the country this booklet evoked is not the Canada in which I, or anyone else, was raised. I soon realized that this fantasy was deliberate. If I did not recognize the land described in Discover Canada, that was the volume's intention: to drive a wedge between old Canadians and new Canadians; between me, who did much of my schooling in Canada, and my partner, who arrived here as an adult; between the liberal, statist, internationalist culture of the past and what the authors hope will be the conservative, decentralized, militaristic culture of the future.
The project of changing the ideological orientation of coming generations of voters was heralded by a government press release that proclaimed this booklet "should be in the hands of... every high school student in Canada."
High school students will not find the Canada they know in these pages. Medicare, the policy that Canadians sometimes identify as defining our country, is bypassed in a fleeting reference to the Canada Health Act. Tommy Douglas may have been voted "the Greatest Canadian" in 2004, but his name does not appear here. The CBC, government aid agencies such as CUSO and CIDA, the right to unionize, gay and lesbian rights all vanish. (Forced by legislation introduced by NDP MLA Olivia Chow to do so, the government placed this sentence in the updated guide published this spring: "Canada's diversity includes gay and lesbian Canadians who enjoy the full protection of and equal treatment under the law, including access to civil marriage.")
Refugees and revisionism
Peacekeeping receives one grudging mention, devoid of any reference to the Peacekeeping Monument in Ottawa that enshrines this heritage; in this volume, which uses the word "war" 35 times, Canada is a bellicose nation, adamant about its "Christian civilizations" and fixated on "the rule of law." Discover Canada is not so much Canada for Dummies as Canada for Spartans.
In spite of the volume's militaristic tone, its most radical revisionism appears in the Conservative policy of regionalism. Most people reared in Canada learned in school that our country is made up of 10 federated provinces with equal legal rights and two (after April 1999, three) territories. New Canadians will have to memorize the five regions of Canada, each of which is introduced as having a distinct culture. The delineation of these regions betrays the fact that the lines on this new national map were drawn by a party that is strongest in Alberta. Ontario and Quebec, for example, become a single region. My partner, having made the difficult transition from living in French in Quebec to living in English in Ontario, knows that these two provinces do not share a regional culture. The majority of residents of both provinces -- which is to say, more than half of Canada's population -- would also reject the notion that they form a single region. New immigrants, however, will be obliged to affirm that this is the case.
Discover Canada's militarism and its propagandistic presentation of history are intertwined. The only two waves of political refugees identified by the guide are Hungarians who "escaped Soviet tyranny" in 1956 and Vietnamese who "fled from Communism" after 1975. My partner, like other aspiring citizens, is acquainted with some of the tens of thousands of Canadians whose families fled military governments in Chile, Argentina and Uruguay in the 1970s, or right-wing death squads in El Salvador or Guatemala in the 1980s. She is aware that among my family's circle of friends are men who came to Canada from the United States as refugees from the Vietnam War, and women who accompanied them. These immigrations were just as transformative of Canadian society as those of the Hungarians and the Vietnamese, yet Discover Canada writes them out of history. To include them would be to violate the booklet's star-struck reverence for men in uniform. The dignity of General Pinochet takes precedence over an accurate account of the origins of Canada's population.
Canada as war epic
The bottom of the opening two-page spread on the rights and responsibilities of citizenship is emblazoned with photos of happy soldiers. The accompanying text concedes that military service is not a formal obligation of citizenship, but suggests that it is "a noble way to contribute to Canada and an excellent career choice." Web addresses are provided for both the Armed Forces and the cadets, a privilege that these pages grant to no other organization. Would-be citizens must study the names of all Canadians who have won the Victoria Cross, and are expected to be conversant with a little-known military unit called the Canadian Rangers. The volume consistently militarizes our history. When I was in high school, the two Riel rebellions were taught as a constitutional crisis that pitted Louis Riel against Sir John A. Macdonald in a dispute about representative government. Discover Canada tilts the emphasis toward the battlefield, summarizing the conflict with portraits of Sir Sam Steele, "Mounted Policeman and Soldier of the Queen," and Gabriel Dumont, "the Metis' greatest military leader."
The Canadian tradition of opposition to militarism is censored: the long sections on the two world wars contain no reference to the 1917 Quebec City anti-conscription riots, the division of Parliament along linguistic lines during the war years, the second conscription crisis or Mackenzie King's response to it. Various passages broadcast Conservative ideology: the first section on the economy, entitled "a trading nation" -- a phrase coined by Tory strategists for Brian Mulroney's 1988 election campaign -- makes free-trade deals a Canadian trait; by contrast, Macdonald's National Policy, which built the nation, is omitted. Tory gun-lovers can thrill to a photograph of a gun-wielding hunter (who, unassailably, is Inuit).
Discover Canada's effort to induct new Canadians into values that will lead them to support militaristic right-wing policies should be obvious to many who study the booklet. The most enduring lesson my partner and thousands of other citizenship applicants can learn from this volume is that Canada is a country whose government misrepresents its past in order to deprive them of the information they need to engage in debate about its future. ![]()




7
Login or register to post comments
dave49
42 weeks ago
View from a journalist
This comes back to Harper's war against anything that smacks of liberalism.
During the last federal election, we asked a fellow who is a journalist in the Chinese language media for his thoughts. He noted that the old timers generally vote Liberal as they remember what past Liberal governments did to help them get started. The newer immigrants tend to have conservative values and are more open to Harper's messages.
This is part of Stephen Harper's attempt to remake Canada into what he wants it to be. He is, I fear, a Republican in waiting.
See this:
http://www.ctv.ca/CTVNews/SpecialEvent7/20051213/elxn_harper_speech_text_051214/
k.w.m
42 weeks ago
Canada is no longer Canada
When Harper said we won't recognize Canada when he is done is correct; [OFFENSIVE COMPARISON REMOVED.]
Harper is removing all our Rights in favor of Corporate profits, maybe everyone should read the book "Snakes in Suits" its about Corporate socio/psychopath's esp after Harper gave away our Sovereignty twice, first due to the World Governance, then due the Border perimeter agreement.
Sally Bowles
42 weeks ago
Community Outreach
People want to counter this sort of propaganda have to make an effort to get involved with the new immigrant community. Tutoring in English is one way, but there are other programs which help new immigrants adjust. Chances are, new immigrants have come up against a few leaflets of their own in whichever country they left behind. It's easy enough to tell people that the new handbook makes good birdcage liners when you actually are friends with them. Relationships and friendships are worth more than a million stupid government leaflets.
(Good grief, kwm. I'm no fan of Harper, or of conservativism at all, but comparing him to Breivik is ridiculous and counter-productive. It just makes people who oppose him look as extreme as he is.)
nikkobaud
42 weeks ago
Blue stalinism: re-imaging our history
When do photoshopped historical images making our history conform to the newly-minted ReformaTory version, start appearing?
Conductor274
42 weeks ago
Harper is a war monger
I can see Harper instituting the draft.
[UNSUBSTANTIATED COMPARISON REMOVED]
The US Department of Defense Dictionary of Military Terms defines terrorism as:
The calculated use of unlawful violence or threat of unlawful violence to inculcate fear; intended to coerce or to intimidate governments or societies in the pursuit of goals that are generally political, religious, or ideological.
According to that definition George Bush, for waging his illegal war on Iraq based on lies and deception, is a terrorist so it's not a stretch to think Harper will get there too.
Henry Dorsett Case
42 weeks ago
Geist Magazine
Great to see this in the tyee. I picked it up earlier in Geist - a great Canadian magazine. Buy it - if you like the tyee you will love it.
chayvice
42 weeks ago
1984 lives on
Thank you Stephen for this revealing article. I find it quite frightening. The opportunity to educate new immigrants on a wide range of historical events and ideas is lost here. An unbalanced view for the newcomers.