Books

Why Bush Fears this Woman

Helen Thomas's dogged White House reporting has made her an unlikely celebrity.

By Deborah Campbell, 4 Jul 2006, TheTyee.ca

Helen Thomas White House

Thomas: 'Wanton killing...for what?'

Journalism icon Helen Thomas has been covering the White House for six decades. One might have expected the octogenarian reporter to retire and take up, oh, say, gardening, but the weeds in Washington continue to multiply, encouraging her apparently unflagging zeal to yank them out at their roots.

Her determination has made her something of a celebrity -- an unlikely enfant terrible to those who would prefer to operate under a cloak of secrecy, and a hero to those who believe the duty of journalism is to hold the powerful to account. Her persistent questions, particularly about the war in Iraq, had her banished from her traditional front-row seat at presidential press briefings.

At the 2006 White House Correspondents' Association Dinner, attended by the president himself, satirist and Bill O'Reilly impersonator Stephen Colbert showed a video fantasy in which he plays the new White House press secretary (a job that's been taken by former Fox News correspondent Tony Snow) who handily shakes off other questioners but is haunted by Thomas, who follows him all the way to New York City.

Her fourth book, Watchdogs of Democracy?: The Waning Washington Press Corps and How It Has Failed the Public, chronicles her views on the failures of contemporary journalism.

Deborah Campbell: You've had a front row seat on the White House press gallery since Kennedy, and now you've been moved to the back of the room...

Helen Thomas: Only for press conferences with Bush. He doesn't want to call on me.

What does that say about his view of the press?

I'm reluctant to personalize it. No president likes the press, period. But Bush in particular wants to sanitize who he talks to. They give him a list of reporters to call on -- which I've never seen done before -- and he sticks to the script. He's afraid of my questions. On the one hand it makes me laugh, but it's also sad. A president of the United States ought to be able to handle any question. If they can't, then why are they there? My requests are very simple. Usually it's like, "Why?" "Why did you do it?" "What's it all about?" If you're putting people's lives at risk, you should be able to answer questions like that.

Do you think the U.S. press is tough enough on monitoring the centres of power at this point?

No, I think they fell down on the job. But I sense that they're getting their sea legs, coming out of their coma in light of the hurricane and Karl Rove and a few other things. So they might get back to being real reporters again. I think they're beginning to realize they let too many opportunities pass, that it's okay to get angry and to really challenge, which is their job. Reporters represent the last frontier in terms of questioning public officials. If we don't do it, it doesn't happen.

Do you recall a time or a moment in history when journalism was more heroic than it has been in recent years?

Every other time but this time. And it's because of 9/11. People wanted to be more patriotic and were afraid of rocking the boat. From there, we were segued into a war where reporters were worried about jeopardizing the troops. So there was a heavy cloud, and reporters had to fall in line for awhile. But they're coming out of it, thank goodness.

What are some of the main obstacles to doing good journalism at the moment?

Fear. Lack of courage. You want to keep your job. Maybe some corporate heads are breathing down your neck. You've got to feed the family and send the kids to college. There might be financial reasons and others, and maybe some reporters feel they shouldn't raise uncomfortable questions at a time when patriotism is demanded. But our job is to find out the truth. That's our only job.

At the moment it seems there are some cracks in U.S. foreign policy. Do you speculate as to where any of that is going?

Well, I think that we've got to pull the troops out of Iraq. We've got to stop killing. This is ridiculous. It's more than ridiculous. It's tragic. Wanton killing, killing and being killed -- for what? I think the administration wants to hang in there, but they actually believe they can win. I think that's a long shot, if anything. And what is winning anyway? Winning what? A Shiite theocracy? Is that what American soldiers are dying for? Furthermore, we've got to find out what terrorism is really about, find out the root causes. I think that it was right to go into Afghanistan and right to go after Bin Laden. But what about the bigger picture? Is it a religious war? Is it American policy that is really motivating these people? What is it? Figure that out, and deal with it.

Deborah Campbell writes on foreign affairs, art, politics and culture for national and international publications. She sometimes stays up till the wee hours to catch the Colbert Report on rabbit ears. A version of this interview originally appeared in Adbusters.  [Tyee]

22  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • DPL

    5 years ago

    Comments on "Why Bush Fears this Woman"

    Bill Clinton did a bit of a skit with her just prior to his leaving the job. Obviously Bill didn't find her that hard to get along with. We hope she stays around for a long time. she is very sharp., Bush is the opposite, sort of dumb

  • OneWomanArmy

    5 years ago

    My wish is to have that story on every front page of every news media outlet all over the world. Especially Pakistan where both presidents can have a rap session about who are the most threatening women in their lives.LOL

    Thank you, Deborah, for probably one of the most enlightening pieces I've read on the media and the current President of the US.

  • tommymoore

    5 years ago

    Sheesh - Helen Thomas, while maybe sharper than many of the butter knives in the White House press corps, is as hoodwinked as the rest of the American populace vis a vis the TWAT (The War Against Terror).. when will they wake up and smell the coffee? When will the Twin Towers/Fire in the Reichstag be exposed for the orchestrated fakery/casus belli it really was? I want to see Dick (birdshot) Cheney on trial. I want to see Rumsfeld, Rove, et al dangling from ropes. (Bush already dangles from strings) Call me an optimist.

  • rikia

    5 years ago

    From the article: "Bush in particular wants to sanitize who he talks to. They give him a list of reporters to call on -- which I've never seen done before -- and he sticks to the script... My requests are very simple. Usually it's like, "Why?" "Why did you do it?" "What's it all about?" If you're putting people's lives at risk, you should be able to answer questions like that."

    Harper won't answer these questions either. In yet another page out of Bush's playbook, reporters who want to ask him questions must now sign a list so that his people can tell him who to call on for the easy questions.

    In the 2004 election, only 15% of Canadians would have voted for George Bush, but this is the guy Harper chooses to emulate?

  • ModernSerf

    5 years ago

    Just like big government big media is manipulated by a disturbingly small group. Despite this I believe that the leaders of a nation should be held to account if they are not responsive to national and even international media, as this is one of the most fundamental democratic checks and balances.

    Conversly, big media needs to have stricter rules on ownership so that diversification provides it some defense from direct manipulation. This is especially true in the U.S. but our most recent Senate report on the topic is somewhat damning.

  • BC Dude

    5 years ago

    I ran across this little bit of truth that may answer why Harper wants to be a dictator with G. Bush & kill/murder innocents & be killed our boys & girls.
    In the forties and fifties they invented a weapon that could wipe out mankind, if not life on earth. The thermonuclear H-bomb meant that if wealth was to be acquired it would have to be done stealthily and without upsetting governments. For this and other reasons big business around the world came together to formalize networks of influence with virtually limitless resources that transcended national boundaries and they began the final moves towards privatizing the Earth. They knew the main difficulty would be the nation state so they plotted its downfall. http://www.bilderberg.org/The
    Why maybe Gordo is in such a hurry to Privatize & ultimately break up Canada with Harper in Quebec & stirring up the hard line separatists!

  • jesterjogger

    5 years ago

    BC Dude
    You may expect a visit from a representative of the Parallax Corporation.
    I will hoist a drink at your funeral!

    Regards,

  • Yammer

    5 years ago

    Come on Jester. Everyone knows that Parallax is a cover for the real problem -- the Crab People!

  • Truman Green

    5 years ago

    So how come you and Yammer are poking fun at BC Dude, jesterjogger? Don't think the Bilderbergers have weird power, eh. Well, any organization that can invite a hundred or so of the world's most powerful people to its yearly convention and NOT be covered by the media, is indeed a powerful and secret organization, acting only in its own best interests.

    tommymore, point taken, but I think Helen Thomas may not really be hoodwinked. Maybe she's always just done the best any American journalist could possibly do and still maintain her relevance and her job. I've never seen her lobing any softballs to any president. In a recent article, she actually speculates that the Arab nations just might be pissed off at American foreign policy in that area, and that this disenchantment may be the source of the terrorism--an idea which has come to be as out of favour as holocaust or Aids denialism in the US.

  • Worrywart

    5 years ago

    The mainstream press has become a joke. They purposely avoid the most important topics and ask soft questions of our so called leaders. If George Bush or little Stevie Harper refuse to take questions from the press they should be immediatly boycotted by all press members. Of course, it won't happen as most of the press supports these corporate sponsored phonies.
    Why is all this money going into a military that supports illegal wars while healthcare and kyoto are forgotten? Why is the privatization of BC Hydro allowed to continue with little critical reporting?
    There is some good independent press such as TheTyee, The Republic,Coop Radio and the internet, however now the corporate mutts want to privatize the internet. The mass mind is fed disinformation by the mainstream press. Like they say "the best propaganda is 90 truth". One can't call the press liars outright, however it is safe to say they are full of bullshit! They will be trying to sell us a common north american passport and currency real soon and the spin will be full on.

  • Dungeness_Crab

    5 years ago

    Yes, yes, the Parallax... *grooms mandibles*

  • darcy.mcgee

    5 years ago

    I find a delicious irony in finding one of the scion's of American journalism interviewd and published in The Tyee.

  • jesterjogger

    5 years ago

    Poking fun!?!
    I'm dead serious although I suspect our friend BC Dude will not actually have a sudden heart attack like Ken Lay about to "sing" about bushco and the bildebergs faced with a long and most likely brutal prison term.
    Sorry if it appeared that I was mocking you Dude.
    Look at what is happening in Mexico right now and tell me that some sinister, covert(albeit barely) forces are NOT at work around the world undermining democracy in order to serve the interests of the global ruling class.
    dttrc
    dttce

  • BC Dude

    5 years ago

    So jesterjogger are u saying I should not tell truths & just sit back watchin TV like a good lil boy till it's to late
    That may be your way but not mine and if U can see by these blogs I'm not alone!
    The information I'm putting out is on the net as you can(t) see as I've also added the website. So where have I been a bad boy?
    My & my granddaughters future is in OUR hands now!
    There is a boycott (dion't buyy) in progress now against Petro Canada & S(Hell) I'll have to send it on my next blog if anyone is interested?
    I'm A new breed of non consumer.

  • geezer75

    5 years ago

    Helen thinks that going into Afghanistan was OK but I feel that Afgh. is a bigger problem than Iraq.
    I've heard one Canadian Military Warrant Officer offer a worthwhile solution.
    He felt that if the Americans withdrew from Afghanistan, it would greatly aid a peace process. The Afghans regard American occupation as the evil situation and rebels are using it to stir the pot.
    However, their equipment is needed.
    Possible solution? - Americans get out but give the UN forces access to your equipment.

  • darcy.mcgee

    5 years ago

    At least in the case of Afghanistan there was a direct threat. That's where Al-Qaeda was based.

    Not so in the case of Iraq. This is undoubtedly part of the reason that the mission has been a failure: the lack of a clear mission in the first place.

    This war is not, unfortunately, a traditional war and it's hard to use traditional language to describe it. America is not at war with a "country" and yet we continue to use a vocabulary that discusses the mission in terms of geographical boundaries.

    No wonder Chomsky is having a field day.

  • Working Man

    5 years ago

    BC Dude, are you a new breed of consumer? How much Hite and This are you consuming? You should be comparing what you see in South Korea to Canada. I met a few "Englishie teachers" while was working a job in Korea and believe me, I wouldn't have them "teaching" my kids. It is a good place for people who can't get jobs in Canada, though..

  • geezer75

    5 years ago

    Darcy.....

    But to the people of Afghanistan, indeed it is a traditional war. They view the Americans as an occupational force. America's attitude of 'we'll give them freedom' should include the addendum 'whether they want it or not'.

    In my opinion, the Afghans (and Iraq) don't give a tinker's damn about our brand of freedom. All they want is peace in their own country without occupational forces.

    For the most part - and unfortunately - it was the Taliban that gave them that in the 1990s. Certainly, it was a training ground for terrorists but it was also a training ground for mercenaries of a few countries. Its terrain is ideal for this sort of thing since most of it is a sniper's paradise.

    Last but not least - U.S. geologists discovered it has significant oil reserves.

  • rafe

    5 years ago

    Great column. Deborah, on a truly first class journalist. Sad to say, our press gallery in Ottawa is, if anything, worse. They all get to ask questions and all the questions get answered because it's all puffery. Our good journalists like Stevie Camweron, Andrew MacIntosh and Clare Hoy are all silenced and nobody asks why because there isn't anybody left to ask.

    Good piece!

    Rafe

  • greengreen

    5 years ago

    Rafe, And, what about our "journalists" in B.C.? The Sun, Province and BCTV News have got to be the worst ever! Blatently biased reporting with the Fraser Institute as their #1 source of information.
    Why don't you tackle the incestuouos nature of our local media and pursue and political, personnel and economic ties between them.
    Write something with some balls, not just wimpy opinoin pieces that are not very informatilve or thought-provoking.

  • BC Dude

    5 years ago

    Now that Bell has bought out Chum TV & Radio stations (more profits for “$1.7 billion” shareholders, Chum stock up 50% today) 281 very talented group of people laid off!
    Why don't they get together and start an Independent Radio-TV station with real news?
    Owned & Operated "For the People By the People" no Government or Big biz money.
    Just an idea whose time has come!
    I for one would be willing to pay 40-50 bucks a month, multiplied by US people who are fed up with the Canwest rags and now Bell. What future for our youth?

  • Working Man

    5 years ago

    What future for our youth?

    Singing the ABC song for Korean kids.

    • No best comments selected by an editor for this story yet. To see all comments, click the All Comments tab, above.
    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.