The Hook

The Hook Blog

Political News. Freshly caught. A Tyee Blog

Environment

Earth Day, then and now

*This story was updated April 22, 10:47 a.m.

When U.S. Senator Gaylord Nelson launched the first Earth Day in 1970, could he have imagined that 40 years later it would be so widely recognized? Commemorated by Disney t-shirts, blockbuster DVD releases, and Facebook applications?

Probably not. Back then, the issue was pollution, and the goal was to educate and organize people in a grassroots lobby to stop oil spills, pesticide use and haphazard toxic dumping. Today, the issues are energy, sustainable consumption, and the new green economy, writes Vicki Glaser in this month's special issue of Sustainability: The Journal of Record.

"The biggest change that defines the evolution of Earth Day is the shift from the collective to the individual. The focus used to be events and public demonstrations intended to raise political awareness of environmental issues and stimulate legislation action. Today, it is more personal. What can each individual do to save energy, reduce water consumption, minimize pollution, help other and improve the world?" writes Glaser.

Some wonder if this isn't a perverse turn for the worse. If you live in Ontario, Quebec or B.C., notes columnist Tony Keller, you can celebrate this year's Earth Day by buying a hybrid luxury SUV. . . you'll get a $2,000 subsidy from the government.

Rex Weyler, a founding member of Greenpeace recalled the actions he'd been a part of over the last four decades -- camp-outs, sit-ins and highway blockades. That was the the 'anger' stage, said Weyler, who likens our "cultural inertia" to going through Kübler-Ross' five stages of death. Now we've moved on to stage three: bargaining.

"If we call ourselves 'green' and 'sustainable' can we keep selling stuff?" he wrote in an email to The Tyee. "As a culture, we still resist the lessons of ecology. We are attempting to continue with our unsustainable habits and tack on "green" as a marketing slogan for more products."

It's easy to be cynical about Earth Day, especially when considering one's own personal actions against those concerted efforts of government and industry to extract oil and gas no matter what the ecological cost. In Canada, especially, surmises this Montreal Gazette article, there had better be strong individual actions -- because we have no climate leadership to speak of.

Dave Vasey, one of the 120 people who shut down Parliament in a tar sands protest last December, told The Toronto Star that environmental groups' increasing tendency to work with government on policy issues has created a "top-heavy" movement.

"Protests are effective in showing that there is passion. . . Policymakers need to know that we're not going to go away quietly," he told the Star.

Indeed, for proof of the power of one person's protest, look no further than Alexandra Morton, who kicks off her Great Migration tomorrow in Sointula. Or, consider the power of friendly competition -- today Vancouver took one step closer to its 'greenest city' goal by finally joining cities like Portland and Toronto in introducing kitchen waste pick-up.

If you do want to give a nod to Earth Day, there are dozens of activities happening around the province. Online, one could spend hours sorting through top 10 Earth Day action lists and suggestions on how to live a greener life. Or perhaps, suggests one contributor to this video, the best way to celebrate Earth is to "get the f*#ck away from your computer, and go outside."

Colleen Kimmett reports for The Tyee.

Filed in

7  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • freebear

    2 years ago

    40 years and ......

    More emissions than ever before!

    Seems Earth Day is more of a countdown to extinction; than a real sustaibale society and future!

    40 years and still the endless pursuit of growth!

    40 years of green wash

    Unless the sheeple wake up!

    Baah, humbug!

  • max von smartt

    2 years ago

    go outside

    yes absolutely enjoy the outdoors and get away from the screen and cellphone. take the day off from the hamster wheel.

  • Ramona777

    2 years ago

    Go Outside??????

    Until we can get vendors to:
    1. stop selling water in plastic bottles,
    2. to stop selling cheap goods that don't last;
    necessitating buying more cheap junk made in countries where environmental laws don't exist;
    3. stop importing sugar snap peas from China and apples for Argentina;
    we're doomed.
    Our insatiable habits and smug self-righteousness are destroying the Earth. I see so-called "greens" driving up to the farmer's markets in their big honkin vehicles from their precious big homes. What's wrong with the picture?
    We need more environmentalists like Alexandra Morton who take a tough stand and really do something not sell-outs like Tzeporah Berman who frolic with the demons.

  • freebear

    2 years ago

    My Ramona!

    You got that right!

  • Sask Resident

    2 years ago

    The issues should still be

    The issues should still be pollution, and the goal was to educate and organize people in a grassroots lobby to stop oil spills, urban encroachment, air pollution, pesticide use and haphazard toxic dumping. How can buying a new car, any new car, be considered environmentally sensitive and green?

    Bottled water was introduced because of Earth Day. People became fearful of toxins in their municipal water supplies so some enterprising 'green' entrepreneur started selling safe, spring water in a plastic bottle, a case of unintended consequences.

    What will the unintended consequences be from greater demands for electricity? Wind mills every where wiping out the rapture population? Noise pollution driving wildlife away? Swathes cut through forests for new transmission lines.

    Earth day is a good idea, just be reasonable and think about your ideas before they become demands.

  • Amanda Goodman

    2 years ago

    dis-alientation

    I agree that Earth Day seems to become more and more individualized every year. There may be an app for the iphone called "I-EarthDay."

    I think a large part of the challenge is the continuation of the capitalist context for the environmental movement which is largely not challenged- and for good reason as taking that on capitalism has been made unpopular by years of the mainstream machine. Because the environment movement continues to be commodified, it means that an exchange value is put on components, meaning they can be bought or sold. This is a distraction from the real issues of environmental degredation at hand.

    I think that the so-called environmental movement needs to dis-associate itself from the green commodity industry- sure we need "green" products, but that can't be the focus.

  • Frank

    2 years ago

    Earth day

    Its a day for environmentalists and since they don't vote NDP because they love capitalism too much I couldn't give a rat's ass about their day.

    • No best comments selected by an editor for this story yet. To see all comments, click the All Comments tab, above.
    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.

    Democratic Trust

    About The Hook

    As British Columbia and other jurisdictions consider allowing online voting, can it be made secure enough that people will trust it? Will it encourage more people to vote? But if something goes wrong, will it further erode people's confidence in their democracies? And what role is the media likely to play in shaping the debate?

    These are among the issues to be considered at a May 26 discussion that Fair Voting BC and PartyX are hosting at The Hive in Vancouver. I'll be on the panel, along with UBC Law's Fathima Cader and SFU computer scientist Steve Wolfman. The results and recommendations are to inform the two organizations' public positions on online voting.

    Meanwhile join me and other contributors on The Hook as we bring you the latest from B.C. and across Canada.

    -- Andrew MacLeod