From Abu Ghraib to the RCMP

What leaders don't want to know.

By Richard Warnica, 19 Jun 2007, TheTyee.ca

Big Story

Two big stories on either side of the border this week are both in their own ways about gross abuse of authority and plausible deniability.

Down south, the New Yorker’s Seymour Hersh has another in his periodic dispatches on the still smoldering Abu Ghraib scandal. This week, Hersh interviews Antonio Taguba, the Army general who first investigated the allegations of abuse in the prison and saw himself sidelined for accurately reporting what he found.

If you get past the horror flick depictions of abuse Taguba uncovered, what is remarkable about the piece is just how far the General’s superiors went to be able to deny they knew of the assaults.

“Here I am,” Taguba recalled Rumsfeld saying, “just a Secretary of Defense, and we have not seen a copy of your report. I have not seen the photographs, and I have to testify to Congress tomorrow and talk about this.”…

At best, Taguba said, “Rumsfeld was in denial.” Taguba had submitted more than a dozen copies of his report through several channels at the Pentagon and to the Central Command headquarters, in Tampa, Florida, which ran the war in Iraq. By the time he walked into Rumsfeld’s conference room, he had spent weeks briefing senior military leaders on the report, but he received no indication that any of them, with the exception of General Schoomaker, had actually read it.

In Canada, meanwhile, our own never-ending scandal continued last Friday when a lawyer investigating the RCMP pension scandal found the national police force’s management structure “paramilitary” and “horribly broken.”

The report was just the latest in a catalogue of condemnations of RCMP behaviours that have surfaced in the past 12 months. But despite the growing list, the minister in charge of the force, B.C.’s own Stockwell Day, announced there would be no public inquiry into the RCMP.

Just like Taguba’s superiors, it seems, Day and the rest of Ottawa’s political leadership would rather not know what has gone on on their watch.  [Tyee]

5  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • munroe

    4 years ago

    Point taken

    Well done, Richard. The disease you identify is very pervasive and these are two excellent examples.

    "Deniability" is one sympton of the illnes. Another is the complete refusal to take responsibility for actions taken. Take Bush and Blair on the downward spiral in Iraq or Harper on the Atlantic Accord. Closer to home is Campbell and the Bill 29 improprieties. I expect we'll see both denial and responsibility refusal as the facts come out about the B.C. Rail case.

    Shining light, as in this short piece, is the only treatment that may work.

  • Gary

    4 years ago

    Of Course

    Ottawa doesn't want us to know what is going on within the RCMP. In my opinion there is probably enough to bring down the government. If that is not the case, then what are they hiding? Just like here in BC the provincial government doesn't want us to know what went on with the sale of BC Rail. This farce doesn't only alledgedly involve government ministers and bureaucrats there are allegations that the RCMP are involved insofar as their investigation was incomplete.
    It's time Canadians started holding their elected representatives accountable for these despicable events that are occurring in this country. Write, phone, e-mail,or visit your local MP and MLA's offices. Let them know your pissed. Maybe if they hear from the masses in person they will stop relying on the paid for polls they seem to want to beleive. And maybe, just maybe those actions will get their heads unstuck from that anatomical crevice where it seems to be imbedded.

  • murdock

    4 years ago

    NEW not needed. Return to correct oversight.

    The RCMP, like the Canadian Forces before it, was turned into an arm of the PMO in the 1970's.

    This must stop.

    Before this change the RCMP reported to Parliament. Was answerable to Parliament thru the Justice Minister.

    Now it is a toy of the PMO, with treasury board holding the purse-strings and therefore a gun to the head of the Commissioner, whom is no longer an 'independant' policeman, but a servant to the PMO mandarins. It is no wonder that, under Cretien, this force was turned into the mess that it has become.

    The CF (Canadian Forces) is in very much the same messy situation, if we are to bother fixing the National Police force then we should repair the top end of the CF before it is too late...

  • murdock

    4 years ago

    How Gary?

    Quote:
    It's time Canadians started holding their elected representatives accountable for these despicable events that are occurring in this country.

    The PARTY gets to decide whom the candidates are going to be and the Party leader can choose to not sign the nomination papers and thus kill the $$$ supply for any prospective candidate.

    Until we, the voting sheeple, start electing a LOT of independant candidates; your 'accountability' thoughts will never be acted upon.

  • jrb

    4 years ago

    non-article?

    what is this? a mention of two things going on in the news. nothing new added. no analysis.

    shape up, please.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.